Mayahuel
(Now Closed)Cocktail Bar, Mexican Restaurant, and Lounge$$$$
East Village, New York
The experts at Village Voice and Men's Health Mag recommend this place
260 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
max dNovember 28, 2010Wasn't into the Red Ant River (sweet/bland), but the Slight Detour cocktail is *excellent*: jalapeno tequila, reposado, mezcal, mole bitters.
Pueblo Viejo TequilaFebruary 15, 2016When you visit Mayahuel, start by ordering a delicious cocktail mixed with Pueblo Viejo Blanco.
WillMcDDecember 3, 2011Do a tequila tasting. Ask for Ocho Single Estate 2009. Rob the bartender gives great insight.
- Pueblo Viejo TequilaDecember 30, 2015If you are in Mayahuel, try a real Mexican taste, order a Spicy Paloma mixed with Pueblo Viejo Blanco.
Order some black bean croquettes, and drink mescal straight all night: try to use your high school spanish to tell drunken stories of love affairs. It's better this way, really.
Best bar in east village. Hands down... Maybe manhattan.
- WillMcDDecember 3, 2011Rob the bartender really knows his tequilas. The Siembre Azul Reposada is incredible
- Pueblo Viejo TequilaApril 4, 2016The Easter colors reflect in a Margarita mixed with Pueblo Viejo. Get yours here at Mayahuel!
Katie DelzAugust 12, 2014Good strong cocktails, but the food was just okay. Not a lot of vegetarian options for the boyfriend.
- Appleseed punch: mezcal, Smith & Cross rum, Laird's apple brandy, lemon, Fuji apple, and nutmeg.
The Randy Cocktail is sensational. If you're in for something harder, the Slynx.
naveenSeptember 18, 2009get the 'red ant river' if you're feeling sweet. and the 'slight detour' if you're feeling spicy. and the 'ocho' if you're feeling it...if you're feeling...
Jarret WeinrichJuly 17, 2011Lots of fruity drinks... Except for the warlock, it's got tequila and absinthe.
Melody HanJanuary 19, 2010$1 tacos and $10 cocktails on Sundays. Get there early or be prepared for a loooong wait. Try the pilot punch.
The Local East VillageAugust 18, 2011Rachel Dratch of SNL says, "I think they have the best margarita in New York." Read more
Jill FilipovicApril 18, 2010Anything Phil touches is magic. Mayahuel is no exception -- best tequila cocktails ever.
- Pueblo Viejo TequilaDecember 9, 2015If you are in Mayahuel, try a Margarita with Pueblo Viejo Blanco.
301 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 6:00 PM–2:00 AM
(212) 253-5888
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 9.0
"Great new addition to the neighborhood. Trendy cocktails and decent wine. Try the deviled egg appetizer"
Jeff Solomon - 8.9
"Get Fong's Colada! A vibrant fusion of coconut, lemongrass, and pandan. My new favorite summer cocktail."
Amanda - 9.1
"Beautiful seafood-based broth (get the Kyoto style!), eclectic rotating selection of oysters. Nicest owners that put care into every detail."
Grace Tan
Places people like to go after Mayahuel
- 8.9
"I tried the Double barrel julep and the Pendennis club cocktail when I was there on my first night in NYC from STL. EXCELLENT! No need to say any more - except "JUST GO"."
FAC - 9.0
"Bitters paradise. Try the Negroni (home-made vermouth!)"
Hilda Ura - 8.1
"Easily top 5 best cocktails bars in NY. Charmingly rustic. Go for the Mezcal Mule. Try the 2Pok Crif Dog with Pok Pok wing sauce (hold the cilantro though)."
Karen Vanetta
Appears on 1,300 lists
Created by Noah Weiss
36 items • 210 followers
Created by Men's Health Mag
180 items • 506 followers
Created by Kathryn Yu
74 items • 407 followers