Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
(Now Closed)Sandwich Spot, Diner, and Coffee Shop$$$$
Flatiron District, New York
Has a stamp of approval from Village Voice and Serious Eats
273 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Tara StilesJuly 29, 2009Best egg and cheese sandwich and coffee is pretty good too. If you like meat stuff they have all that too. I love them. Like walking into worm hole to NYC's past.
Roberto TobarApril 12, 2013It's no Katz's, but it is quite tasty and a lot easier on your wallet too!
If it looks busy from the window don't worry, there's a lot of seating in the back.
Ben MackeySeptember 25, 2018I don’t think this place has changed in the last century. Get the Ruben.
Jack GashiJanuary 26, 2014If you crave a pastrami Reuben that won't make you hate yourself afterwards, this is your spot.
Travel ChannelJanuary 26, 2011Lime Rickey: Considering the alarming color, a truly delicious thing. - Anthony Bourdain, host of No Reservations
The split pea soup is vegetarian if you're not the pastrami type.
Bill B.June 15, 2011Where else in the city are you going to go for a lime ricky or an egg cream? Don't even know what the hell is in a lime ricky, but I know I love 'em.
Brigette R.July 31, 2011Breakfast sandwiches, tuna melt, rueben...you can't go wrong here. What a gem!
Jarkko JokirintaMarch 27, 2013Had a GOOD experience here. "Great sandwiches with plenty of Mayo!" Read more
Try the french fries....extra crispy and delish!! Egg salad is also unreal.
Thomas KnüwerOctober 29, 2014Strange and unfriendly service but a true NYC gem. You feel like Don Draper could come in any second.
Richard NievesDecember 27, 2011Try the Franks And Beans - It was great! It's the special every Monday.
- Drew ShannonSeptember 14, 2011Great vibe of old New York, along with killer sandwiches and egg creams
674 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
174 5th Ave (btwn 22nd & 23rd St)
New York, NY 10010
United States
New York, NY 10010
United States
Opened in 1929, this classic New York City eatery sits across the street from the iconic Flatiron Building and serves delicious Jewish deli-style food. Eisenberg’s has been open for over 90 years and still maintains its original vintage charm, attracting loyal customers for its hearty American fa...
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 7:30 AM–6:00 PM
- Sat–Sun
- 10:00 AM–3:00 PM
(212) 675-5096
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch
See More
You might also like
- 8.8
"Best sandwich place in the city hands down! Fresh ingredients straight from Italy! Very popular will most likely wait in a 20 minute line but we’ll worth it!"
Marino Boccuzzi - 8.5
"Sandwiches are fresh, all the food is delicious with organic ingredients and lots of options. Staff really friendly too."
Mairéad Ní Dhubhthaigh - 9.0
"The must do, legendary pastrami sandwich joint of NYC. Rueben or the classic with pastrami instead or corned beef is the way to go. It’s huge! ideally share one between two. 10/10."
Ondrej Sedlacek
Places people like to go after Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
- 9.4
"Picnic in Madison Square Park. It’s one of our favorites!"
Barneys New York - 9.1
"Among the gastronomic greatest hits worth checking out here: handmade mozzarella, oysters, veal and lamb stuffed ravioli, and gelato. And lots and lots of wine"
Ubeyd Dalmis - 9.3
"Favorite market in the whole city. The winter months are a little sparse, but come Spring and Summer, I find everything I need for a well-stocked fridge. I think Wednesday afternoons are the best."
Mary Ann Caram
Appears on 1,257 lists
15 Bucket List Sandwiches in NYC
Created by Foursquare City Guide
15 items • 287 followers
Created by NYC: The Official Guide
11 items • 180 followers
Created by Travel Channel
36 items • 4,974 followers