Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
(Now Closed)Sandwich Spot, Diner, and Coffee Shop$$$$
Flatiron District, New York
Has a stamp of approval from Village Voice and Serious Eats
273 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Scott BurdickMay 30, 2013Sit at the counter and order a hot pastrami on rye, add mustard and enjoy the old school charm of this place
Patrick BaskinJanuary 15, 2017Old school diner and sandwich shop, solid pancakes and breakfast sandwiches
Jonathan RobinsonJune 26, 2013Great classic NY greasy spoon. Been around for ages. And they make one heck of breakfast sandwich
A true New York landmark. I always leave Eisenberg's satisfied and a few pounds heavier
Craig TurpinOctober 16, 2011You can't go wrong with anything the menu but what I love is the Pastrami corner beef swiss & slaw. Great breakfasts too.
Paul BerardinoAugust 9, 2011This is one restaurant where virtually everything on the menu is delicious. Also, the egg creams and the milkshakes are excellent!
Jeff PetrielloAugust 7, 2014A basic, solid grilled cheese and tomato soup. That's what the atmosphere is like too. Classic ny.
Arjumand BonhommeAugust 19, 2014Friendly staff. Good selection of custom salads/pasta/sandwiches. Hot food bar and baked desserts.
The onion rings and tuna melt on rye with cheddar will change your life. DO IT
Daniel HMay 14, 2013If you have a sweet tooth, get the apple pie a la mode and either an egg cream or Lime Rickey.
Marianne CiminoMarch 25, 2014this looks just a bit like a smaller place I went for coffee on the Lower East Side when I worked on Mott Street years agi
Justin OrdovezaSeptember 19, 2014A small hole in the wall place the tuna melt is a run of the mill sandwich. Nothing great but not bad either.
Pastrami eggs platter was nice. Music and vibe were great.
I AmosApril 25, 2013One of the shockingly few places you can get grits in this town, believe it or not. Also, Cel-Ray soda.
Amazing reuben pastrami in an original atmosphere.
Spotted by Locals - city guides by localsAugust 9, 2015Make sure to wash down your food with a chocolate egg cream. Read more
James LFebruary 12, 2020It really shows its age. But if you can get past the dust and grime of the place, the reuben is fairly good.
James MullanyMarch 26, 2015Tuna melt, hot pastrami. Sit at the bar and you'll smell like grease for the rest of the day
Travel ChannelNovember 17, 2010It still serves the working person’s lunch and classic New York City non-alcoholic beverages in like, 2 minutes flat. – Anthony Bourdain, No Reservations Read more
Dev AnandDecember 17, 2011Excellent breakfast sandwich on a roll, be sure to get with a side of fries and pour Cholua over errything
Arvind DasJune 24, 2013A decent Salami sandwich with loads of meat, the iced tea was without sugar but t'was my fault ;)
Uber NYCOctober 10, 2013Some of the best sandwiches in NYC, and a favorite of Ops & Logistics Manger, Ben.
Ricky SherrillMarch 22, 2016Do not let their name fool you because this place in a great for breakfast.
Pamela TMay 13, 2011Alot of "quaintness" here if that is the appropriate word...like going back to another era...just a few steps away from the magnificent Flatiron
674 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
174 5th Ave (btwn 22nd & 23rd St)
New York, NY 10010
United States
New York, NY 10010
United States
Opened in 1929, this classic New York City eatery sits across the street from the iconic Flatiron Building and serves delicious Jewish deli-style food. Eisenberg’s has been open for over 90 years and still maintains its original vintage charm, attracting loyal customers for its hearty American fa...
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 7:30 AM–6:00 PM
- Sat–Sun
- 10:00 AM–3:00 PM
(212) 675-5096
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch
See More
You might also like
- 8.8
"Best sandwich place in the city hands down! Fresh ingredients straight from Italy! Very popular will most likely wait in a 20 minute line but we’ll worth it!"
Marino Boccuzzi - 8.5
"Sandwiches are fresh, all the food is delicious with organic ingredients and lots of options. Staff really friendly too."
Mairéad Ní Dhubhthaigh - 9.0
"The must do, legendary pastrami sandwich joint of NYC. Rueben or the classic with pastrami instead or corned beef is the way to go. It’s huge! ideally share one between two. 10/10."
Ondrej Sedlacek
Places people like to go after Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
- 9.4
"Picnic in Madison Square Park. It’s one of our favorites!"
Barneys New York - 9.1
"Among the gastronomic greatest hits worth checking out here: handmade mozzarella, oysters, veal and lamb stuffed ravioli, and gelato. And lots and lots of wine"
Ubeyd Dalmis - 9.3
"Favorite market in the whole city. The winter months are a little sparse, but come Spring and Summer, I find everything I need for a well-stocked fridge. I think Wednesday afternoons are the best."
Mary Ann Caram
Appears on 1,257 lists
15 Bucket List Sandwiches in NYC
Created by Foursquare City Guide
15 items • 287 followers
Created by NYC: The Official Guide
11 items • 180 followers
Created by Travel Channel
36 items • 4,974 followers