Di Fara Pizza
Pizzeria$$$$
Midwood, Brooklyn
Has a stamp of approval from Eater and Village Voice
"Buy whole pie and resell :)"(17 Tips)
"The square pie is the best pizza I've had in my life."(10 Tips)
"Best pizza in NYC... a must... Full Review..."(7 Tips)
"Authentic square slice is heaven."(7 Tips)
346 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- whole pies
- square pie
- square slice
- dom demarco
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
The Corcoran GroupMay 1, 2010Dominick is a true pizza master and takes his time to get it right. Be patient and don't be picky. You will be back. Cash only
Closed Mondays and Tuesdays, and unannounced private parties on Thursdays. And they don't pick up their phone. And Maggie is a moron.
Juston PayneFebruary 3, 2012If you want the best, you've gotta work for it. Get there before it opens if you want to wait for 20 minutes instead of 2 hours.
Roland YampolskyJune 13, 2012Most incredible pizza of all-time, hurry up before Dominick is no longer with us. He is one of a kind.
Louis MattaNovember 22, 2015The above average slice isn't worth the waiting time, but it's an institution that merits at least a visit.
Emily VerkruyseJanuary 8, 2010Go to DiFara around 5:45 pm so you're there when Dom opens back up at 6 (thus avoiding the line). Still wait about 45 minutes. Experience magical pizza goodness that's oh so totally worth it. Read more- Andrew YochumOctober 2, 2011Indeed the best pizza in NYC. Be prepared to wait for hours... but its worth the wait.
Hope Anne NathanDecember 8, 2011Beware the small square table: it's so wobbly, my drink literally slid from one side of the table to the other - I was lucky I caught it before it fell off!
Annie TOctober 13, 2014With all that wait, you might as well get a pie. Square cheese pie with sun dried tomatoes.
Tiffany SFebruary 10, 2010best. pizza. ever. Push your way to the front of the crowd at the counter (the line isn't really a line) and order a pie -- it's often faster than waiting for a single slice.
Jason HernandezOctober 14, 2012Get there early and be prepared to wait a while your pie is being made...bring cash!
The best pizza ever. Be sure to get a whole pie, not just a slice.- Lissa M.December 2, 2012Not a tip. More like Upset that I can't ever go to that place because its always so packed! They MUST be really good! Can't wait to try their pizza
- Hope Anne NathanDecember 8, 2011Beware the small square table: it's so wobbly, my drink literally slid from one corner to the other - I was lucky I caught it before it fell off!
Josh ChanJanuary 3, 2013Instead of waiting in the store for your pie go to the Dunkin Donuts down the street for hot coffee and seating.
Jeff WooDecember 5, 2010Best pizza in Brooklyn: Get here mid week & mid afternoon, less wait. Get a pie with porcini, pepperoni and/or sausage toppings
Jeff StevensMarch 18, 2012Get there early and be patient! Dominick is a master pizza artist, you'll love it!
Billy SaltsSeptember 29, 2012Try the Pizza With Pancetta - Holy moley!! Trust me, it's worth the wait
Katherine M.June 5, 2014Happy we tried it, but I don't think the long journey + long wait quite justify it.
waisum tFebruary 15, 2010Get there early. Stand your ground in front of the counter and don't move. If you're not assertive, you won't be able to ever taste the most delectable slice of pizza. Welcome to Brooklyn.
Jâck ChéèJune 21, 2017$1 pizza shames this place. 1st two times here, badly burnt but at least ok where not burnt. this difara classic was a soggy mess uneven toppings, unsupportive crust. Best rip off pizza....
StageBuddyApril 5, 2013Come as close to noon as possible. The lines get outrageous very quickly. Read more
PatrickFebruary 2, 2010If you don't speak up, you won't get your pizza. You may think there is a line, but unless you assert yourself, someone else will get your pizza. Don't be a jerk though, its too mellow for jerks.
Arrive at 6pm to avoid lines (Di Fara closes at 4:30 and reopens for dinner at 6:30 / 7pm) Read more
Great Pizza, but $5 a slice!!!! The Pope would have to make it and serve it !!
Norman HathawayMay 18, 2012Artichoke or cherry tomato pie is best. Long wait - bring a Zen book with you.
919 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Di Fara Pizza has been voted #1 Pizzeria in NYC for 8 years running. Try our mouthwatering pizza and see for yourself why we are the best.
Closed until Noon (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- Noon–9:00 PM
(718) 258-1367
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Music
No
Parking
Street
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer, Wine, BYO
See More
You might also like
- 9.0
"We had a great time. The wait was long but we started with a half pizza outside then moved over to dinner. Baked clams and chicken pram were awesome. Don't miss the Spumoni"
Paul Mcnamee - 9.1
"Everything is sooo yummy. With the coziest vibe and friendliest owners this new spot is a gem. You MUST get the Emily pizza and sprouts of course. Their homemade mozzarella is out of this world!"
Raquel Rose - 9.0
"THE slice shop in North Brooklyn. Mootz=garlicky white slice; hellboy=pepperoni w/ hot honey; Freddy Prinz=upside-down square. + vegan options."
Gregory Fisher
Places people like to go after Di Fara Pizza
- 9.1
"A great sand beach in NY. It's crowded but still good. Great place to have lunch, and it is right by the adventure park. There's also a store that sells all beach items (towels, sunglasses, toys..)"
Dilara❥ - 5.2
"They now have veggie bacon!!!"
Möish Solöway - 8.8
"Top notch drink selection and some of the best rotating chefs in the backyard. Home of Johnny Lupiani's Awesome BBQ."
Marc Mayer
Appears on 2,857 lists
Best Places to Check out in United States Pt 3
Created by WannaSee ItAll
200 items • 347 followers
Created by ballsohardbmore
197 items • 280 followers
Created by Adam Kuban
67 items • 837 followers
