Scooter's Frozen Custard is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

1. Scooter's Frozen Custard

9.1
1658 W Belmont Ave (at Paulina St.), Chicago, IL
Ice Cream Parlor · Lakeview · 60 tips and reviews

FatherlyFatherly: This mom and pop shop has been doling out smooth, custard since day one for its house-made creations like the Elvis (vanilla custard, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup, banana — no bacon). Read more.

Chefs FeedChefs Feed: Try the Elvis (vanilla custard, Reese's peanut butter cups, bananas). Scooter's only serves it in size large and with good reason. Read more.

Jose R.Jose Rumbo: Best ice cream in Chicago. Go for the CFNBC (Carmen Fudge Nut Brownie Chip)

Insomnia Cookies is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

2. Insomnia Cookies

8.3
2260 N Lincoln Ave (at W Belden Ave), Chicago, IL
Dessert Shop · Lincoln Park · 29 tips and reviews

Justin R.Justin Rand: Can't go wrong with chocolate mint chip or the peanut butter cup ones.

Maia F.Maia Feruzi: Quaint little spot open to 3am thank god to fulfill all your Kate night cravings. I had the chocolate chip cookie a la mode and it was a delicious vanilla and melted chocolate heaven in my mouth!

Eddy G.Eddy Gonzalez: Cookiewich = cookies with ice cream, Bigwich = cookies with frosting. Super important difference, always go for a cookiewich, bigwich is gross af

Trader Joe's is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

3. Trader Joe's

9.0
667 W Diversey Pkwy (at N Orchard), Chicago, IL
Grocery Store · Park West · 73 tips and reviews

Alex B.Alex Brehm: Shop during the day to avoid lines + get some dark chocolate peanut butter cups and you'll go home happy.

Priya V.Priya Vaswani: Get the roasted red pepper spread with eggplant and garlic with their sea salted pita chips. Makes for a great snack!

👥 CJI👥 CJI: My first time to discover the great ORGANIC savings I can get from here. Move over "Whole Foods"... This is my new Grocery Home.

Firecakes Donuts is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

4. Firecakes Donuts

9.2
68 W Hubbard St (at N Clark St), Chicago, IL
Donut Shop · Near North Side · 165 tips and reviews

ChicagoistChicagoist: The chocolate hazelnut long john is like shoving a jar of Nutella into your mouth and the peanut butter cup is the Reese’s of our dreams. Read more.

HwaPyeong C.HwaPyeong Cho: You don't need to try ice sandwich which is just having additional ice cream in it. Try other regular donut which so delicious!

ThrillistThrillist: Firecakes' donut ice cream sandwich is held together with chocolate espresso or vanilla bean gelato, and adorned with rich chocolate, caramel sauces, and cocoa nibs. Hell to the yes. Read more.

Cold Stone Creamery is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

5. Cold Stone Creamery

8.4
1316 S Halsted St, Chicago, IL
Ice Cream Parlor · University Village - Little Italy · 13 tips and reviews

AngelinaAngelina: Love the ice cream! Conveniently located a block away from UIC!

Kendra T.Kendra Torres: Add a brownie to your ice cream, make it taste great.

Jamie M.Jamie Marshall: Birthday cake remix!!!!!

Dairy Queen is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

6. Dairy Queen

8.3
5636 W Irving Park Rd (Central), Chicago, IL
Ice Cream Parlor · Portage Park · 10 tips and reviews

TanakilaTanakila: banana split is awesome. and sundaes arw great.

Aaron M.Aaron Massie: This place has the most poorly designed parking lot

William Q.William Quiñones: My kids likes it, so do I.

Beatrix is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

7. Beatrix

8.8
834 W Fulton Market (at N Green St), Chicago, IL
New American Restaurant · Fulton Market · 16 tips and reviews

morgmorg: wonderful fresh food in this restaurant slash coffee bar, gluten free and vegan options, don’t miss the cucumber mint soda!

C R.C Rey: The Market is open and offers a bevy of lunch and snacks options. Hot food/salad bar charges by weight and restaurant fulfils high standard set by other locations. Fresh ingredients, honest food.

Elizabeth H.Elizabeth Hagen: Excellent brunch, cocktails and ambiance. I had the cauliflower and egg grits.

First Slice Pie Café is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

8. First Slice Pie Café

8.9
5357 N Ashland Ave (at W Balmoral Ave), Chicago, IL
Pie Shop · Andersonville · 21 tips and reviews

Leia N.Leia Nichole: The blueberry cheesecake pie was AMAZING. Love this spot, tucked on Ashland and begging you to stop in. Homey, friendly, generous.

MightybytesMightybytes: First Slice is not just a great place to get a slice of pie. Buy healthy meals for your busy family, and you'll pay for the same meals to go to Chicago’s hungry and homeless. Read more.

Brenda M.Brenda Magnetti: This non-profit feeds more than me. They serve 500 meals a week to those who can't afford groceries. You had me at hello!

Annette's Italian Ice is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

9. Annette's Italian Ice

8.9
2009 N Bissell St (at Armitage Ave.), Chicago, IL
Dessert Shop · North Side · 26 tips and reviews

Emily H.Emily Harnish: You must try Annette's! Everything is so good and the people are so nice! Went back in opening day and they were so excited to see customers again! My faves are the red raspberry and the strawberry.

Rebecca T.Rebecca Thalhofer: Eskimo Kisses is to die for..... coconut ice cream w/ chocolate chunks.

Daniel M.Daniel Meza: This place is great!! Need a place to cool down from the summer heat or humidity? Come here and get refreshing Italian Ice in over 15 different flavors. My combo is Lychee, Blood Orange & Grapefruit!

First Draft is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

10. First Draft

8.3
649 S Clark St, Chicago, IL
Sports Bar · Printer's Row · 22 tips and reviews

Allison K.Allison Kaminski: Awesome service, super extensive beer selection and flights! What more can you ask for?? Oh, tasty food too! Get the porksicles and poutine!

Heather F.Heather Folsom: Simply put, we will be back ASAP. Poutine, wild boar meatballs w/cheddar grits, mac, & gnocchi were all phenomenal. Impressive beer list and server Amanda was spectacular- so funny & knowledgeable!

Andrew S.Andrew Stiles: Good for sports if you can get a table. The goose island Ogden is a good local craft beer. Pizza was a pleasant surprise.

Travelle is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

11. Travelle

8.5
330 N Wabash Ave, Chicago, IL
Lounge · Near North Side · 37 tips and reviews

Dana J.Dana Jensen: We were here for the Christmas dinner, which was lovely. Good bartenders, excellent steak, and an incredible beet salad. Perfect portion sizes.

Brock W.Brock Wanless: If having brunch, order the signature Travelle Benedict for a delicious combo of eggs Benedict, lobster, spinach, and potatoes!

M. Katie H.M. Katie Hunter: Eric and James are true gentlemen -- the bar staff here is unparalleled. Come in on Thursday nights for a signature cocktail and to listen to the live lounge act! They take requests!

Beatrix Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

12. Beatrix Market

7.6
155 N Wacker Dr Ste 102 (at W Randolph St), Chicago, IL
Market · The Loop · 2 tips and reviews

AVAV: Good ambiance with delicious food at reasonable price. They change up the items everyday. The serve some great queso fresco!

Shannon J.Shannon Jeropke: Their buffet and their grab and go options are quite good.

Beatrix is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

13. Beatrix

8.9
671 N Saint Clair St (Erie and N. St. Clair), Chicago, IL
New American Restaurant · Streeterville · 62 tips and reviews

Daniela G.Daniela Garcia: Loved the quinoa cakes with poached eggs!!

Shurooq A.Shurooq Alsada: Yummy breakfast, great service 🥰

Varsha S.Varsha Shete: Healthy options for lunch & dinner and they actually taste better than the burger & fries! I would order something other than chia pudding for dessert next time though.

Iguana Café is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

14. Iguana Café

8.4
517 N Halsted St (btwn W Grand Ave & N Milwaukee Ave), Chicago, IL
Café · Fulton River District · 70 tips and reviews

EstabonEstabon: Food was great. Service is great (hot waitress). Had honey, walnut crepe. Delicious.

Victor S.Victor Sotelo: I just noticed a live iguana that lives in the upper northeast corner of the room

DeannaDeanna: Vegetarian sandwich is great and reasonably priced!

The Bagel is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter Cups in Chicago.

15. The Bagel

8.3
3107 N Broadway St (at W Barry Ave), Chicago, IL
Bagel Shop · Lake View East · 75 tips and reviews

Margot C.Margot Chapman: Great omlettes with lox. Yum.

Mike G.Mike G: Mish mash soup. Delicious. HUGE. The glass bowl it comes in is a monstrosity. Approximately 2.3x bigger than your head.

Giancarlo T.Giancarlo T.: Sweet and sour cabbage soup is glorious!