See all
225 photos

Mary's Fish Camp

Seafood Restaurant$$$$

West Village, New York

Save

Mary's Fish Camp

8.5^/10

425

ratings

Ranked #2 for seafood restaurants in the West Village
Go here. Experience the lobster rolls. It's worth it.
"The shrimp burger was Amazing the lobster rolls are really delish!"(75 Tips)
"whole fish of the day"(6 Tips)
"... for my wife. And the lobster knuckles are fun and tasty if you are skilled at..."(4 Tips)
"Very fresh ingredient!! Nice place to stop by for oyster n drink."(12 Tips)

140 Tips and reviews

Filter:

lobster rolls
french fries
chowder
casual
mary s fish camp
ice cream sundaes
deviled eggs
good for dates
spicy food
good service
trendy
healthy food
roses
ribs
salads
corn
village
buns
brunch food
crowded
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Tim SheyOctober 11, 2011
Everything's great, but save room for the strawberry shortcake if they have it, or be filled with eternal regret.
Javier CoboApril 20, 2011
The Halibut BLT is delicious,but be sure to ask for something other than onion rings ots. The O rings may be the only bad thing on the menu.
Xx XxJuly 10, 2016
The chowder was fantastic! Great service, lovely room.
Dennis BajecApril 15, 2015
The grouper is a great looking dish, but I always get the Lobster Roll.
Village VoiceOctober 25, 2012
Readers' Poll winner of The Village Voice Best of NYC 2012 Best Fish!
Kate FurmanAugust 10, 2017
Delicious lobster roll with a mountain of shoe string fries
Dominic PreussMay 18, 2011
Been here 5+ times
HarryH is right, best lobster roll in the city but the star is the whole grilled daily fish. I prefer the bronzini!
Edris NichollsOctober 16, 2010
Been here 5+ times
2 thumbs up! Love! My west village haunt... Every dish is worth it here...I like the whole fish (any) and fries .... Mmmmmmmmmmmm!
Dominic PreussSeptember 10, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Best lobster roll in NYC. Whole bronzini is the 2nd best dish. Sundae's are amazing too.
Hugo SlimbrouckJuly 14, 2018
The lobster rolls and fries were excellent.
James DenmanAugust 7, 2014
Great place, good atmosphere, but the Fish Taco's gave my girlfriend food poisoning. You've been warned.
CharlottesOctober 6, 2015
But disappointed with my meal at this local stalwart. The skin on my Arctic char was limp and fatty and my partner's lobster roll was drowning in mayo. Service was good tho.
Selim AykutMay 3, 2016
lobster rolls, fish tacos, banana bread pudding.
Konstantinos PsychogiosJuly 16, 2016
OMG. Amazing food. Everything.is.great.
Pu MackMarch 25, 2022
Been here 10+ times
Get the pozole 😋
Saif DiaJune 5, 2013
Great lobster roll and bouillabaisse, although serving sizes are inconsistent. However, service is horrendous. Also, pricey, even by West Village standards.
Living Jazz ArchiveJanuary 15, 2016
Oysters, fish specials, service
TrevorJuly 1, 2014
I've never had a fish well cooked here. Save your money for Pearl Oyster Bar, a few blocks over.
Christine NgoAugust 30, 2010
Heavenly lobster roll and grilled squid appetizer. Friendly staff and warm atmosphere. Could prob eat here every day.
William MullinApril 29, 2012
Lobster roll a little overrated. It is fine. But not a huge standout. Obviously people here have not tried a hot buttered lobster roll at Lenny and Joe's Fish Tale in Connecticut.
Aaron DuncanJuly 16, 2011
The best lobster roll in the city - worth the wait.. partic if having the fresh oysters!
Brad GreenJuly 31, 2016
Lobster rolls and steamers are the best.
Conor WittMay 4, 2019
Trout dip, lobster rolls, shrimp burger
Jenna KangJuly 13, 2013
It was great spot for fresh seafood. But the price of robster roll was insane...
MarthaMarch 7, 2015
lobster roll. that's all. it's amazing.
🍕Lisa R Henderson 🍕May 22, 2016
Lobby aka lobster roll🦀🐟
Lauren BersonApril 17, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Best restaurant in NYC and best lobster roll on the east coast - Maine included
Tracie FranklinJune 28, 2012
The lobster roll was delicious but overpriced considering you can get 2 for that price at Luke's.
erinocookiesSeptember 2, 2010
MFC is a weekly staple. Grilled whole fish, fish tacos, cockles, lobster knuckles...all good!
Sam SaundersSeptember 23, 2011
Sardine special was great. Lobster roll too. Deep fried oysters and clams were only OK. Sliders were fine, not overwhelmingly great, but not bad.
Matthew OliverNovember 29, 2013
It's true what they say, they make a mean lobster roll!
Pineapple FroyoMarch 6, 2019
Disappointed. The artichokes side dish was like eating dried leaves. Fish of the day was grilled nicely but nothing special. Lobster knuckles was not outstanding, didn’t taste fresh.
Helmut LangJuly 14, 2010
NY. Nothing feels more like summer than a lobster roll and shoestring fries. This place wins for best lobster roll in the city. Read more
E CabreraDecember 21, 2012
Excellent. Chowder and lobster roll. Delicious.
Ryan AmbsSeptember 3, 2016
The food was good but there are better places to spend that kind of money
Karen BellantoniJune 22, 2014
Worth the wait. Best lobster roll.
Chefs FeedAugust 22, 2014
Anthony Sasso, chef of Casa Mono, eats here on his nights off. He loves the Lobster roll. Read more
RachelleSeptember 29, 2015
Deliciously!! Great
harryhMarch 8, 2009
Been here 5+ times
I know you want a lobster roll, but that's the wrong move here. At Mary's you want to go for a whole fish. Ask your server which one, they'll know what's best today.
sarah lipmanOctober 5, 2011
can be a wait but you can get a drink and take it outside
Gabe RoseNovember 19, 2011
The Guatemalan shrimp is delicious & spicy. Spilicious.
Blake EllisonDecember 2, 2010
This is a great new find! Be sure to check out the amazing specials.
Lasse LeskinenAugust 18, 2013
The bouillabaisse, priceless!
Patrick DolanSeptember 15, 2013
Lobster Roll was great but pricey.
Lucy TraversApril 25, 2013
The scallops are amazing!
Sandip PatelAugust 19, 2014
Awesome lobster rolls
Tracee MoeckerJanuary 7, 2012
The spicy Florida conch chowder is amazing.
Roxanne TehranianJune 30, 2013
Best tarter sauce ever!
Jasmine DJune 6, 2017
Cod sandwich + fries
Jes CySeptember 15, 2014
Great lobster roll!

1 2 3

225 Photos

Mary's Fish Camp

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Mary's Fish Camp

Appears on 822 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.