Fish
(Now Closed)Seafood Restaurant$$$$
West Village, New York
The folks at Village Voice and Gothamist like this place. Would you agree?
207 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Jason H.March 26, 2016Great specials - nice dish of 6 oysters with a beer for 9 bucks. Good value, good food
An XiaoJune 3, 2010So good. Get the red white and blue special for a half dozen blue point oysters with a drink for appetizers. Try the lobster or crab (with bib :), but be sure to wash your hands with lemon afterward!
Ava LuSeptember 24, 2011The Red, White and Blue ( 6x Oysters) + PBR or White/Red Wine = $8 is the must have! The Fish Market Soup and the Kings Crab Leg was a bit salty but good nonetheless.
Paolo TraversJanuary 4, 2019Very tasty seafood in very good portion sizes. Filling and delicious. Tight seating though.
Helen LinJanuary 6, 2013New fave. 6 clams or 6 oysters + 1 glass wine $8. Fish soup spicy hearty perfect.
Public House WineAugust 19, 2014This seafood shack has an unbeatable happy hour deal: 6 oysters or clams + house wine or P.B.R. for 8 bucks.
Lobster Mac and cheese - calorific heaven! Must do the oyster/wine $8 deal. AND THE FISHERMAN STEW!! No to the mussels.
Antonio PoloniAugust 16, 2014Wonderful Ceviche. Avoid fried calamari (which are just on par). Great selection of oysters.
Candace HoMay 10, 2013Love Ryan!! Happiest server on the face of the planet! Despite the WORM that was on our oyster!! Eek!! Check if your food is moving!! #protein #thatswhatyougetwhenyouordertheoysterspecial
Daniella NicoleSeptember 28, 2013Awesome all day red, white, and blue special with half dozen oysters and drink. Great way to start your night.
Hien LyNovember 23, 2014Servers have attitude problems and ruins what could be a great little spot. The oysters and all three soups were delicious.
Natasha AMay 6, 2012Can't go wrong with a half dozen oysters or clams and a glass of red or white wine or PBR all for $8. Amazing deal.
Carlie RiceSeptember 23, 2015Great place! LOVED the scallop frisée salad with fried egg on top and bacon and onion. Mediocre mussels- would not recommend you get them here.
Graet specials, like oysters and wine for $10. No frills but a consistently dependable spot.
Janelle GraceJanuary 30, 2014How about that oyster hour deal! Beer and half a dozen oysters for less than $10 is a pretty good deal.
Preston KJune 17, 2012Every single item on the menu looked amazing. The $8 Oyster Special has to be the best deal in the City.
Tim VetterJuly 12, 2010The 6 x Blue Points + drink = $8 special (taken at the 3-stool street bar!) is a winning snack, but if it's Sunday night, head to Joseph Leonard instead for the premium oysters at $1.50/ea
Curtis ShoungMay 31, 2015Great deal on 1/2 dozen oysters and beer... But don't sleep on the lobster bisque!
Jess SNovember 20, 2011Selection of oysters were better than the burger (avoid). Fried clams were fresh & really tasty! Cramped space, better to sit at the bar.
JokerAugust 6, 2013Ousters special (6 pcs) are the smallest blue point ousters, but they come with wine or PBS. If you order them not as special ($1.25 a piece) they will be way bigger, but without drink
Theresa GApril 5, 20126 blue points and a glass of house red or white for $8 - or upgrade from the full wine list for $2 more = awesome!
julie kennedyMay 5, 2012can't go wrong with the red, white, and blue oyster special. half a dozen + pbr, red or white wine for $8? yes please.- Ava LuSeptember 24, 2011My Waiter's name was Will or Wilson, I don't remember because it was really loud in the place but he was great! I would go back definitely just for him!
Zenzele BellMarch 30, 2013Red, White & Blue special is the best raw bar deal I've ever seen! House wine is excellent.
- Take a pass on the lobster roll, if you're with someone get 2 dozen oysters and a pile of fries (go HEAVY on the old bay)
Amanda WilliamsMarch 28, 2015Had the bucket of crabs and the fish sandwich. Both were good but would have the sandwich next time as the crabs were quite small and hard to eat.
The food was amazing, and the bartender is one of the best I saw in NYC.
the famous raw bar special is $8.00 and gets you 6 blue point oysters with a PBR. It's shucking perfect.
Alexandra RoddaFebruary 8, 2012You can order anything on the menu and it will be awesome. It is always fun and service us great.
New York HabitatOctober 31, 2011Great seafood in the West Village. Get the Red, White, and Blue special: 6 oysters and a beer for 8 bucks!
If you are like me you probably eat two lobsters!Get the lobster dinner for $18 and add another lobster for $12!and yeah start w the red white and blue special.
ZenFoodsterAugust 18, 2013No uni, stone crab claws, $25 AYCE Maryland blue crabs, & $8 RWB 6 oysters + PBR tdy!
661 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- Noon–11:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- Noon–Midnight
(212) 727-2879
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar
See More
You might also like
- 8.5
"Lobster combo.... Portion is not so big but flavor is amazing....is a must in NYC!"
Mr. Critic - 8.9
"Seafood plate is good and fresh. Sushi and easy appetizer like calamari is also excellent."
Janut Suchato - 9.0
"Super fresh oysters, must try the fettuccine with clams and grab a beer with that. Frindly staff will def return!"
Afro lynne
Places people like to go after Fish
- 8.6
"Solid spot for quality craft beer on tap with a huge selection. You can keep track of the beers you've tried; just ask the bartenders and you can create your own card for when you come back!"
Andrew Choi - 8.2
"Mini cannoli's are to die for! The regular ones are better than the chocolate ones. Also - incredible decaf coffee (for late night drop ins)"
John Fontein - 9.4
"Buy a Burrata Mozzarella and Parma ham, take it home and enjoy with a good baguette!!"
Alicia L
Appears on 508 lists
Created by New York Habitat
44 items • 316 followers
Created by SMKN 5 Pandeglang
50 items • 78 followers
Created by Daniel L.
12 items • 163 followers