City Sandwich
(Now Closed)Sandwich Spot$$$$
Hell's Kitchen, New York
The experts at Time Out New York and Serious Eats recommend this place
148 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Srdjan VranacOctober 18, 2014Great staff, delicious food, nice place, with all the bases covered, what are you waiting for?
A little long to make the sandwiches, but it's cuz they're fresh! Victoria was great
MonicaSeptember 24, 2012Super accommodating and delicious. While I'm not a vegetarian, I love the Christina and Diana sandwiches.
- Katie SchnellerMarch 5, 2011This is the best new sandwich place in midtown. Pavia is AMAZING - and so much better than egg and cheese on a bagel. LOVE.
Tom JenningsNovember 10, 2011Super friendly and helpful staff. Cool choices. I liked the Dave sandwich. The baguette that it comes on is great!
Ben RNovember 11, 2012Best sandwiches in the area. Anything with Portuguese sausage or bacalao is a winner.
Get the LGBT. The Portuguese salad Sandwhich is also good. The consider fish a vegetable.
R. BÜLENT PEKCANJuly 25, 2018Very small store, menü on the wall, It is possible to find different kind sandwiches including vegetarian type.. Not super but average level..
- Silvie SenaukeDecember 18, 2015Henrique was great, and use the four square deal for a free panna cotta!
Adam BordowOctober 26, 2011Unbelievable service and sandwiches. Get the blood sausage sandwich with spicy olive oil on the side!
Dan DurkinAugust 30, 2014Hole in the wall spot with Portuguese sandwiches. Perfect for a quick bite.
Shaun PeachamJuly 1, 2013A must is to go the MmmEatBalls - yum yum yum.. Service is amazing as well :)
Zach MerouaniMarch 24, 2015JAMES. Chicken, roasted peppers, sautéed onions, fresh mozzarella, seasonal lettuce.
The Dave is pretty damn perfect. And with the hot chickpea soup...mm-mm... makes the perfect combo.
incredible, fresh sandwiches. amazing options for vegetarians!
- Sweetheart service and the owner is the perfect example of how to be a restauranteur. Love this place!
- Wake up a little earlier in the morning and get their breakfast sandwiches. I recommend the Tricia. Mmmmm...
Adrianne BenzionFebruary 5, 2012Christina! Check in an get the manna cotta for free. The owner is also very nice here
Jasmine ChongDecember 6, 2013Not a sandwich person, but I'll gladly fork over $10 for one of these. Seriously. So. Good.
Pierrepont FinchMay 9, 2011H2S's Rob Barlett Tip: Ask for an extra side of their yogurt sandwich spread. You will forget mayonnaise forever.
Mike DudasJanuary 2, 2012The Salvatore chicken and fillings were pretty mushy but the bread was crispy and delicious.
Lily YuanJanuary 29, 2011Definitely want to order the Henrique - yummy smokey sausage and better bread than Cosi's!
124 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Take a bite and become one of us at City Sandwich with our homemade bread, fresh ingredients, and flavorful original sauces!
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 9:00 AM–8:30 PM
- Sat
- 10:00 AM–3:00 PM
(646) 684-3943
Features
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
See More
You might also like
- 8.0
"After one visit, I’m ready to declare this one of the best lunch spots within walking distance of Madison Square Park. The sandwiches are enormous, delicious, fresh, and cheap. Here’s the Firenze."
Cole Kennedy - 8.5
"Sandwiches are fresh, all the food is delicious with organic ingredients and lots of options. Staff really friendly too."
Mairéad Ní Dhubhthaigh - 8.7
"Roasted pepper sandwich is highly recommended 🥰"
Rana ✨
Places people like to go after City Sandwich
- 8.8
"Every cookie is phenomenal. Favorites include key lime, red velvet, blueberry cobbler, sea-salt/chocolate. The coffee is also really good."
Vivek Pradhan - 7.2
"Best baklava I’ve had in the US. Like in Greece."
Stephen Perle - 8.5
"Cozy up to this outpost of Amy’s. Get breads, cookies, sandwiches, and coffee from the famous baker."
Compass
Appears on 713 lists
40 Cure-All Breakfast Sandwiches
Created by Foursquare City Guide
40 items • 288 followersCreated by Real Cheap Eats
199 items • 2,343 followers
#100best dishes and drinks 2011
Created by Time Out New York
100 items • 5,313 followers