See all
1,772 photos

Carnegie Deli

(Now Closed)

Deli, Sandwich Spot, and American Restaurant$$$$

Theater District, New York

Save

Carnegie Deli

261 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Mark CortejosSeptember 10, 2013
Out-of-towners be advised, food servings are massive. Pay the split charge to share and save yourself some money (and pounds).
Eric ReyesMay 5, 2013
The Woody Allen Sandwich is good and huge! Enough for two people
AaronMay 9, 2013
Tip: Portions are big so share a Woody Allen with someone cute who's about to give a talk at a prestigious economics conference.
Lizz C.April 12, 2015
Excellent food!! They permanently closed their back room so there is always a line out the door.
A AlawadiJanuary 10, 2015
The monstrosity of the pastrami.... one of the best sandwiches i have ever had!!
Examiner.comMarch 11, 2011
A local favorite and known for their delicious meats. Try the 'Melo' sandwich in celebration of Carmelo Anthony's arrival to the New York Knicks NBA Team. Read more
Jody Eis-KraemerAugust 21, 2012
Coffee is perfectly strong. Try the chocolate babka with coffee for breakfast. Service is great.
Yousef RaffaApril 6, 2014
You can never go wrong with the best Pastrami sandwich
JPAugust 11, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Must have a hot pastrami on rye and a slice of plain cheesecake, much better than Juniors
Joseph OsorioMarch 9, 2015
Pastrami manwish is to die for. greeeaaatt.
David SolimanoFebruary 9, 2016
Try one of everything. If you get the Reuben, being someone to split it with.
Josh MilchJuly 15, 2010
come here -- eat a roast beef sandwich -- you'll get so much on your plate you'll never wanna see it again! a true new york jewish deli. don't miss!
Stephanie GittinMarch 28, 2013
You would not even realize you're walking by it it's a hole in the wall but the food is so good. A must stop and eat
Josh DantoAugust 26, 2016
Pastrami on rye is a staple, but I dig the salami even more!
Michael ONeilAugust 6, 2014
Corn beef is great, and massive (like all their sandwiches)!
Chax ChacaAugust 20, 2014
Gargantum Rouben and blueberry cheesecake. I regret nothing!
Arlene MurphyJanuary 3, 2014
Don't go alone. Oversized portions of everything but so good!!!!! Avoid sharing fee by one ordering sandwich and other ordering dessert.
Brett VSeptember 21, 2016
Bring you appetite and definitely get the strawberry cheesecake!
Joe CheskinAugust 14, 2014
Huge sandwiches and the best pastrami this side of Katz's Deli.
Sven LenaertsNovember 24, 2014
I don't really like cheese cake but I was pleasantly surprised by the strawberry cheese cake. Would order again.
Alycia CuckaMarch 15, 2014
The hard salami is...really hard. Only order if you have a strong set of teeth!
Susan BurroughsNovember 27, 2014
Excellent hot pastrami sandwich and must try the latkes !
Héloïse MJuly 29, 2014
Great pastrami!!!! Excellent service and ambiance. But expensive
Elizabeth EngelbrechtMarch 14, 2016
Sandwiches were great. Cheesecake was even better!
Kerri HeddellMarch 18, 2013
The sandwiches are HUGE!!!! If you end up sharing you will get charged $3 and there are not free refills!!!!
Fluying ✅November 6, 2011
Best deli in NY. Pastrami sanwich. Cheescake and carrot cake. Evertything is for share.
Eva CelmaAugust 11, 2013
The best cheesecake in the world. Woody Allen sandwich is delicious too.
Jenn PAugust 10, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Share the Reuben and fries with Russian dressing. So good!
Matthew BrownNovember 8, 2011
Fantastic sandwiches! I had the pastrami, my wife had the liverwurst, and we loved it!
Victor NappenDecember 4, 2011
Amazing food and service! Get corned beef on rye w/ coleslaw and Russian dressing, it's a life changer!!
JavierDecember 31, 2016
Rubens pastrami is great and big!!
Tankut AkayNovember 24, 2013
Pastrami and pickles, very delicious
Sandra RNovember 17, 2013
Get the Woody Allen, a pastrami cornbeef combo its the bomb!
Theresa PowellJuly 28, 2013
Best cheesecake!!! Must try!
TK BaltimoreSeptember 30, 2010
When the waiter tells you that you want a slice of cheesecake at the end of your enormous meal, you DO, in fact, want it. And you want to *share it*.
OldLadyMan TornãdoDecember 17, 2012
Here's a tip, leave a tip. Then come back and get same server. Your world will be a brighter place.
Julio VillarrealMay 24, 2015
Try the pastrami sandwich, there's nothing like it on earth!
Ulysses De GuzmanMarch 7, 2012
I love going here when I'm NYC. Have a pastrami sandwich Prepare to eat!
ArmanJune 6, 2013
The pastrami Sandwhich was the biggest I've ever had, good food!
DJ Pauly DMarch 22, 2010
You've got to try my absolute all time favorite deli in NYC. They even have my pic hanging up with all the celebs right in front!
Rafael BagmanovDecember 25, 2014
Best cheesecacke I've ever tasted. Neato. Mucho neato
Chris CaloApril 8, 2012
Wow, these guys can be obnoxious. Enforcing a $12.50 minimum per person when we came for dessert and the place has lots of open tables?
Vivian GuMarch 7, 2013
get go wrong with the lean pastrami
Glafira Elena CarrAugust 14, 2011
The pastrami, corned beef, and beef tongue are all delicious (get them hot!)!
Brian FosterNovember 21, 2010
Hot Pastrami sandwich is as big as your frigging head! Best ever also and a deal at 16 bones.... Oh yeah cash only!!
Brian BishopMarch 17, 2013
The pastrami, my God the pastrami. It's so good.
Nichole FavreauJuly 2, 2013
Shared a pastrami there, waiter said we get a free piece of cheesecake, and recommended the strawberry. Long story short, we were charged, and cashier said he must have been joking..not going back.
Sean GeraghtyMay 18, 2013
Ask for the Strawberry cheesecake! You won't regret it!
Bradley SacksDecember 28, 2012
Just went here having difficulty checking in thanks so much Dylan and Hannah really enjoyed the matzoh ball soup!!!
Marquillo SDecember 29, 2014
The Pastrami Sandwich could feed 4 guys at a time

1 2 3 4 5 6

1,772 Photos

Carnegie Deli

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Carnegie Deli

Appears on 724 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.