3. Eataly Flatiron
9.1
200 5th Ave (at W 23rd St), New York, NY
Gourmet Store · NoMad · 1479 tips and reviews
M.E.: Great gelato. Get the pistachio -- it's dreamy!
Yvette Thornton: Fresh Pasta, the Beer Garden, Fresh fish, Fresh breads, Amazing Espresso and Gelato!
1lostnewyorker: Sea salt caramel gelato, the pizza and pasta, illy coffee, and the cheeses yummmmmm
5. Amorino
8.9
721 8th Ave (btwn W 45th & W 46th St), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Theater District · 49 tips and reviews
David: We really liked the atmosphere here, authentic feel and delicious gelato. Had the pistachio and Nutella ice cream, along with a hot chocolate.
Ket Moryashaya: Great place with a lot of gelato flavors and good Italian coffee!
Polina Weitz: Amazing gelato, great variey of flavors
8. Ferrara Bakery
8.2
195 Grand St (btwn Mott & Mulberry St), New York, NY
Bakery · Little Italy · 249 tips and reviews
Lisa Garcia: The mini cannolis are the perfect size and absolutely delicious. Grab espresso with one or try the homemade gelato.
Luz Andujar: The Tartufo Tre Scalini: Tartufo Tre Scalini chocolate hazelnut gelato, with a center of whipped cream, pieces of chopped cherries & biscuit, dipped in a bittersweet chocolate. YUMMMM!!
Daniel Cohen: Amazing Red Velvet & Salted Caramel Gelato!
11. Gelato Giusto
8.2
164 9th Ave (20th Street), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Chelsea · 12 tips and reviews
Maximiliano: Real house-made Italian gelato and sorbetto. The espresso is also outstanding. The combination of espresso and one scoop of gelato make one of the most delicious "affogato" you can find in NYC.
Susan H: Excellent, house-made daily, unique flavours and the beloved standard flavours of gelato are offered by super friendly and genuine staff. Sample the different flavours and discover a new favourite!!
Neha Sebastian: Delicious rich gelato. Tried the pistachio! Yumm...
12. Chelsea Market
9.2
75 9th Ave (btwn W 15th & W 16th St), New York, NY
Market · 1218 tips and reviews
K: Super cool place to go - market with organic foods, fruits- popsicle place!- best gelato stand - t salon - eleni's cupcakes - amy's bread - delish food throughout! - anthropologie, of course! artwork
Ana Carolina Miranda: The lobster place is an incredible experience. The Filling Station and its craft beer is a party saver, and the L'arte del gelato has the best gelato in town.
Pieter Delaere: L'arte del gelato for really great ice cream!
14. Gelateria Gentile
7.7
43 8th Ave (West 4th Street), New York, NY
Gelato Shop · West Village · 11 tips and reviews
Kirk McMurray: Long overdue West Village ice cream shop. Delicious daily flavors of gelato & sorbet, as well as coffee and espresso drinks. You can’t go wrong with a scoop of “nocciola” and panna (whipped cream!)
Kevin Keating: Great, classic, authentic Italian gelato. Didn’t have the sorbetti or granita in my first visit, but as the shop is Barese those are probably on point. Ingredients and flavors are well-curated.
Leisl Evans: Long-delayed Ice Cream Shop in the West Village. Delicious gelato & sorbet flavors every day, as well as coffee and espresso drinks.