Paulie Gee's Slice Shop
Pizzeria$$$$
Greenpoint, Brooklyn
"Hellboy slice with hot honey is on point as well"(8 Tips)
"Get the Freddie Prince, simple, airy, delicious."(6 Tips)
"Hellboy and Freddie Prinze are excellent."(3 Tips)
"Sesame crust on the square slices"(3 Tips)
45 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- hellboy
- freddy prince
- pizza
- freddie prinze
- good for groups
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
THE slice shop in North Brooklyn. Mootz=garlicky white slice; hellboy=pepperoni w/ hot honey; Freddy Prinz=upside-down square. + vegan options.
Edlynne LSeptember 2, 2018Hellboy is still my favourite. They have more seating in the back with TVs.Upvoted Apr 27
Max BpmOctober 1, 2018Really great pizza! I loved how the crust was thin, though crunchy enough to eat it. It wasn't overpowering at all. I got 7 slices - 3 vegan supreme 4 vegan cheese which were delicious
- The Freddy Prince has arrived and there’s no question about this upside down square slice with the entire underside lined with a crunchy sesame seed crust: 👑
Kimmie OhhJuly 29, 2020Get the Mootz - fresh & grande mozzarella, romano, garlic & a drizzle of olive oil & the Freddy Pepperoni Square - tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, romano & pepperoni on a sesame seed Sicilian crust!
AmateurConciergeJanuary 2, 2019Old school 80s vibe including 2 seats with an Atari. Both the Freddie Prinze and the pepperoni were great
Some of the best slices in the city. Tops Joe's without a doubt. On the pricier side, and the place is usually slammed, but whether you're taking a slice to go or hanging out, it's always good.- Kimmie OhhJuly 29, 2020Due to COVID-19 : Outdoor seating is along Noble Street along with the takeout window. Pick up your pizza at the entrance on Franklin Street.
The Hellboy squared aka the Freddy Prince with Pepperoni and hot honey drizzle is by far the best slice here- Nash PleasantDecember 27, 2018Freddy Prince Slice with sesame seed crust. Hellboy slice with hot honey is on point as well
The amount of pepperoni on each slice alone makes this joint worth it. They allow takeout orders!
Richard BergerSeptember 2, 2018Hellboy and the mootz would be a great superhero pairing, but are even better as pizza slices
- Colin DuRantFebruary 8, 2020Amazing slice shop. Sesame crust on the square slices and the hot honey slices are the highlights.
I’m not vegan but I often try the vegan specials because they have such a great, creamy texture!
Stephen MMay 5, 2019Way overcrowded and stressful for me. We even skipped the line by ordering at the bar. You have to listen over a lot of loud noise for your name to get called. Decent slices but not worth the ordeal.
Elizabeth BursteinNovember 15, 2020The hell boy is so good!! Also had the moots and freddie jr were ok
Tariq AhmadMay 8, 2021Freddie Prinze slices are phenomenal. Sesame seeds on the bottom of the crust is a nice touch.
GS NFebruary 1, 2022An unfortunate side effect of its former buzzy allure is the persistent rudeness of its staff. Arrogant and self-important, they seem to delight in making customers feel stupid or misunderstood
Brent ChapmanSeptember 4, 2018We went around 4:30 on a Sunday and they had closed due to lack of help. Can’t wait to actually try it!
Nate SOctober 9, 2020So overrated. Been going to original place for over a decade, and for it was A+ pizza. Now, it’s mediocre at best. They’re pumping out quantity (tourists!) over quality. A relic of the 2000s, RIP.
CarolMarch 4Sometimes they just run out of pies and they’re so busy that the person taking orders walks away and you’re stuck in line. Pizza is good but expect a wait or disappointment if they don’t have pizza
George BronosSeptember 20, 2018Good dough, standard cheese for a slice shop, pelati was nothing special. Only tried the cheese slice, so I can’t speak to the rest of the pizzas
- Dan GouldMay 18, 2019Well located with a clean and fun retro decor.It has some nice Yankees memorabilia. HOWEVER, we had 3 different types of pizza and we were disappointed with all 3. Fountain drinks were very good.
Chris GampatSeptember 2, 2019The decor is beautiful and just like the old school pizza shops. Their slices are mediocre at best.- Lukasz GMarch 12, 2019Overrated!! Had cheese and bellboy slices, both decent but not worth a trip to specially get them. There are way better options - Best Pizza, Di Fara or Roberta’s!
Alex RobertsonApril 2, 2019Sort of like Scarr’s or Upside, quality ingredients and preparation just don’t make the grade taste wise. Expensive too
kate wSeptember 8, 2018Sold out of pizza at midnight on a Friday, except their vegan “pizza.” Worst slice in recent memory.
207 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 11:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- Noon–4:00 PM
- 6:00 PM–11:00 PM
- Fri
- Noon–4:00 PM
- 6:00 PM–1:00 AM
- Sat
- Noon–1:00 AM
- Sun
- Noon–11:00 PM
(929) 337-6384
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner
See More
You might also like
- 8.7
"This place offers a NY pizza experience like no other. The deep dish-style crust is baked to perfection w/ a crispy outside & soft center. Each 6-slice pizza serves 1.5 people. Save room for dessert!"
Mike Waterhouse - 9.4
"Excellent pizza, best slice in Williamsburg (including Joe’s and Best Pizza)"
Dan - 9.3
"Stacks up to best pizza in NYC. Perfect char on the pies. Vegan options including daiya cheese and excellent, housemade vegan sausage. The hot honey on the hellboy is great. Paulie makes u feel home."
Paul Tepper
Places people like to go after Paulie Gee's Slice Shop
- 9.5
"Great place to hangout on the weekends. Scenic views of Midtown. Love that it's one the waterfront."
Marie La Rue - 9.0
"My kind of bar: cheap drinks, outdoor patio, and soul soundtrack."
Eric L - 9.2
"This is my favorite beer spot in williamsburg. Very knowledgable staff and a killer assortment of beers that's ever-changing. Go!"
Nathan Musgrove
Appears on 353 lists
Created by Rebecca Sutter
98 items • 26 followers
Created by Cole Kennedy
56 items • 40 followers
Created by Adam Kuban
67 items • 837 followers
