Goodfellas Pizzeria

Pizzeria$$$$

Over-The Rhine, Cincinnati

Save

Goodfellas Pizzeria

8.7^/10

ratings

Ranked #5 for cocktails in Cincinnati
"Really great cocktails and beer upstairs."(3 Tips)
"Excellent slices of New York style pizza"(6 Tips)

9 Tips and reviews

Filter:

Sort:

Leah WarnerApril 1, 2019
The best place to go after a night on the town. Expect lines if you go past 11. It’s worth the wait though. The slices and breadsticks are enormous, and they have tons of sauces to choose from. Yum!
Anna HiderJune 29, 2016
The lunch special is a great deal: pizza, side and drink for like $6 or $7. Cocktails upstairs are good, too. The drink menu is huge and some drinks have flavored ice!
Erik RowleyMay 21, 2016
Excellent slices of New York style pizza, perfect place to grab food after a night on Mainstrasse. Check on the speakeasy bar upstairs for classic bourbon drinks.
MikeJuly 4, 2015
Awesome pizza. Really great cocktails and beer upstairs.
Manoj AmbalavananFebruary 9, 2020
Debateably, best late night slice in Cincy
Yaz SAugust 10, 2019
Best pizza in Cincinnati
Deborah SpiesJanuary 12, 2017
The Marilyn Monroe cocktail is my favorite. A sweet and easy drink for happy hour
Nate SAugust 17, 2015
Staff can't be bothered to chase away homeless harassing patrons.
Susan StoneJanuary 31, 2015
Pizza is ok, usual brick oven pizza. Nice atmosphere, just not enough seating, service disappears after you are served.

51 Photos