Sotto Sopra

Italian Restaurant$$$$

Amagansett

Save

Sotto Sopra

6.9^/10

ratings

"The pizza, the chicken and the grilled corn are all great!"(4 Tips)
"At pizza bar with bill."(4 Tips)

13 Tips and reviews

Filter:

Sort:

Steve ColemanJune 3, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Farfalle with Broccoli Rabe, Gorgonzola and Pine Nuts is amazing. Order it with half the oil and get some red pepper flakes. Mad house on weekend: make a reservation. Bar scene verrrry NYC.
Justin OrgelAugust 17, 2013
Fungi pizza. Veal Milanese. Order the second you are seated or after you read this tip. Welcome to the winner's circle.
Mary PAugust 19, 2016
The lemon drop martini, the pizza and the grilled corn!
Mary PAugust 26, 2014
The pizza, the chicken and the grilled corn are all great!
Mary PAugust 12, 2017
Terrific Skirt Steak and Tasty Duck Breast!
Jane BresslerJuly 26, 2012
So far, the focaccia is very fresh, gazpacho is delicious, fresh and spicy.
Elena V.September 21, 2012
Whole menu is a snooze and wine list is pathetic. Branzino was great but then again who can screw that up?
David DruckerSeptember 1, 2013
At pizza bar with bill. Don't forget to take a mint on the way out
Tory BrooksJuly 14, 2012
The atmosphere here is pretty. Everything else is horrible. Focaccia is stale, calamari is cold, crab crostini is too crabby, and the clam pasta is really quite bad. I wanted to love it but no.
Jane BresslerJuly 26, 2012
Great early bird prix fixe
David DruckerAugust 4, 2013
The mints are awesome !!!!!!!
Brian PitzJuly 8, 2012
Been here 5+ times
I am sorry, but the food blows at this place... Great atmosphere, but red sauce is 10x worse than Ragu out of the can...
Tony BerkmanAugust 27, 2017
Been here 25+ times
Picante Pizza!

24 Photos