See all
120 photos

First Slice Pie Café

Pie Shop, Café, and Bakery$$$$

Andersonville, Chicago

Save

8.9^/10

123

ratings

"Order a slice of pie."(2 Tips)
"Love the pecan pie!"(2 Tips)
"The pound cake is moistened with mulled red wine called glogg."(2 Tips)
"The cherry pie is divine!"(2 Tips)

21 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pies
desserts
cozy
great value
coffee toffee
blueberry cheesecake
sandwiches
coffee
salads
Tabasco sauce
lunch
(6 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

MightybytesJuly 23, 2012
First Slice is not just a great place to get a slice of pie. Buy healthy meals for your busy family, and you'll pay for the same meals to go to Chicago’s hungry and homeless. Read more
Leia NicholeMarch 15, 2014
The blueberry cheesecake pie was AMAZING. Love this spot, tucked on Ashland and begging you to stop in. Homey, friendly, generous.
GinaDecember 29, 2019
Lovely pies of so many varieties and coffee. Next time, I'd love to try their great-looking salads and sandwiches. Best thing is that they support homeless and food insecure people around Chicago.
Chicago TribuneAugust 1, 2014
The pound cake is moistened with mulled red wine called glogg. It is dotted with raisins, flavored with whisper of cinnamon and other warm spices and topped with contrasting crunchy slivered almonds. Read more
StephenApril 10, 2017
I got the apple pie - OMG. Massive and delicious. The star of the show was definitely the crust. So good.
Globetrottergirls DaniOctober 16, 2013
Order a slice of pie. Or two. All of them are delicious!
Rob FreedmanJune 7, 2013
Pie is exquisite. Had classic apple (so good!) and the Pecan (would make any southerner proud).
Sean YannellMarch 18, 2013
Been here 10+ times
feeling adventurous? Try the Tabasco Cream Pie...fluffy creamy goodness with the tiniest kick at the end
Liz WeberSeptember 11, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Michigan cherry, Occupie, Chocolate Peanut Butter--you can't wrong with the selection of pies here!
Chris SteeleJuly 14, 2013
Been here 5+ times
The glute-free options here are just as delightful as the rest of the menu, but they go fast.
Nuri PazolOctober 25, 2018
Exquisite pie. Truly.
Brenda MagnettiJanuary 26, 2013
This non-profit feeds more than me. They serve 500 meals a week to those who can't afford groceries. You had me at hello!
AhmedJune 26, 2015
Great pecan pie.
Amy SalgadoJune 3, 2016
Great coffee! Great service.
MargaretApril 21, 2015
Coffee toffee pie. You won't regret it. :-)
Waverly HumphreyMarch 26, 2015
Love the pecan pie!
Bill McMurrayJanuary 15, 2013
The cherry pie is divine!
Dallas MaynardOctober 9, 2013
Don't forget about the cookies!
Jen OstafinskiFebruary 17, 2015
Mini pies!
Michael AlbanyMarch 19, 2012
Lemon Bars, need I say more!
Dallas MaynardSeptember 25, 2013
All the pies!!!!

120 Photos

Planning a trip to Chicago?

Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.

First Slice Pie Café

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after First Slice Pie Café

Appears on 85 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.