See all
194 photos

Harry & Izzy's

Steakhouse and American Restaurant$$$$

Castleton, Indianapolis

Save

Harry & Izzy's

8.7^/10

204

ratings

Ranked #5 for seafood in Indianapolis
"Of course the world famous shrimp cocktail is a must have."(15 Tips)
"Esp the brownie and filet sliders."(3 Tips)
"The famous shrimp cocktail!!"(2 Tips)
"Prime rib sandwich and calamari are a must!"(3 Tips)

50 Tips and reviews

Filter:

good for dates
fried green tomatoes
prime rib sandwich
great value
trendy
brownies
outdoor seating
dinner
mashed potatoes
bar
lunch
good for special occasions
parking
green beans
pricey
good for business meetings
liquor
town
city
takes reservations
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Melody SkeesAugust 16, 2021
Our waiter Zachary was a wonderful young man. Fried Green Tomatoes and Chicken Avo Kale sandwiches. French fries also seasoned perfectly.
Sean MolinApril 23, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Possibly the best fish 'n chips in town. Hard to bring myself to get them when there's such an epic prime rib sandwich on the same menu, though.
Stu ColemanMay 4, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Prime rib sandwich and calamari are a must! Shrimp cocktail is just as good as advertised. Prime rib pizza is also delicious.
Craig HuseSeptember 14, 2014
The sliders, steaks, pizza, smoked pork chops, lamb...
Keith BlodornMay 23, 2018
Expect a wait even on weeknights, but the food is excellent! So good I had to stop at the airport location before my flight!
Michael Antonio CanganelliFebruary 4, 2020
Penne Alfredo, calamari (unbreaded), shrimp cocktail, New York Strip steak, mashed potatoes and service were all great!
LaDonna HaleSeptember 21, 2015
Of course the world famous shrimp cocktail is a must have. Have the fried green tomatoes, too.
Christina HumpheryApril 7, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Great service. Great food. Great times. Get the shrimp cocktail and a pomegranate martini! Thank me later. ; )
Meco ChandlerJune 25, 2014
Pricey, but good service. The shrimp cocktail is AWESOME! The tomahawk ribeye was too fatty for my taste.... I think it was the marbleizing
Chris HuffmanDecember 21, 2012
The lunch special is $20, and you get three courses. Not a cheap lunch, but worth every penny.
Ali EdwardsOctober 19, 2013
First time here & loved it. Esp the brownie and filet sliders. Will be back!
Zach SteinerAugust 16, 2016
St. Elmo's shrimp cocktail and steaks in more casual environment.
January HinesApril 22, 2013
Best fettuccine alfredo I've had get it with the blacked shirmp.
Tony CastellanoApril 2, 2013
Start with the shrimp cocktail. Sauce is extra spicy......it will wake you up!
Tom BrowneJuly 15, 2012
Been here 5+ times
New patio is fantastic! Nice to sit outside & enjoy the weather.
Carolyn HadlockMay 16, 2013
Try the fries green tomatoes. The Asian sauce that goes with them has the perfect kick
Alex TioMay 25, 2013
Great service as usual. Try the toasted ravioli... It's pretty good
ThomFebruary 12, 2015
Prime Rib A+++, shrimp cocktail - can't beat it
Roger Trahin IIFebruary 1, 2014
Get the green beans they are awesome.
Kelly Taylor-FosterMarch 17, 2013
Best Steak ever put in my mouth! Best Staff !
Bryce TollMarch 16, 2014
Hoitak is the man! Good service good food good time!
Matthew Van DykApril 7, 2013
Click here to read the Urbanspoon reviews of Harry & Izzy's. Read more
Duncan AlneyJanuary 22, 2012
Try the fried green tomatoes!! Possibly the best in the city!
Tom BrowneAugust 17, 2012
Been here 5+ times
What a great patio! Can't think of a better place to eat a fantastic meal!!
Chuck GoseSeptember 6, 2012
Sister site for the downtown Harry & Izzy's, which is a cousin of St. Elmo's. Big family.
Devin BakerOctober 27, 2014
Filet sliders and shrimp cocktail!
Dining Out IndyDecember 19, 2011
The shrimp cocktail is out of this world, and something people crave.
Heather HagyJanuary 25, 2016
Shrimp cocktail and fried green tomatoes!
Elena BarbaAugust 8, 2014
Shrimp cocktail..of course and the bar!
Sean MolinApril 23, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Probably the best prime rib sandwich ever conceived.
Rich KrampOctober 30, 2013
Got food to go, looks like a nice place. Food was good but not amazing
Tina ClineFebruary 24, 2017
The famous shrimp cocktail!!
Marlee BreunigAugust 8, 2016
Salmon is awesome.
Kerri Officer-YoungSeptember 5, 2014
Alex is my favorite waiter!!!
Kasey MayAugust 9, 2014
Steak and wonderful atmosphere
Dimitris CrewApril 10, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Everything was great & waiter joe rocks !!!
Tami HollandJanuary 3, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Filet sliders. Nom nom!
Gemini KPMarch 25, 2012
Been here 5+ times
U absolutely HAVE TO HAVE the Wedge Salad!
Aaron BradshawJanuary 2, 2015
Been here 10+ times
I'm not crying... I'm just enjoying my shrimp.
Todd GundersonNovember 30, 2014
Sliders and shrimp cocktail
Melissa BrownApril 9, 2015
Shrimp cocktail!
Sarah FedorAugust 1, 2013
Luv the sliders
Nicholas LloydJanuary 10, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Great steak
Bret WilliamsMarch 9, 2013
Great service!
Karen McDonaldDecember 29, 2013
Yummy but very pricey!
Alex GroveJuly 15, 2013
Awesome place
Pat WisemanAugust 3, 2013
Try a slider.
Daniel PolaskiDecember 7, 2011
Been here 5+ times
mmmm.. good.
Skip MorseAugust 4, 2013
Go somewhere else....
Nicole HetzlerJanuary 17, 2012
Bad service!

194 Photos

Harry & Izzy's

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Harry & Izzy's

Appears on 25 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.