Lantern's Keep
Cocktail Bar$$$$
Midtown East, New York
Has a stamp of approval from Village Voice and Serious Eats
"Lovely, quiet cocktail bar tucked in the Iroquois Hotel."(9 Tips)
"Great bartenders, great service, and an intimate ambiance."(14 Tips)
"The only one of its kind in midtown, go for bartenders choice."(5 Tips)
"Wildest Redhead (yum!)."(4 Tips)
105 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- cocktails
- iroquois hotel
- good for dates
- wildest redhead
- jungle bird
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- KC HudsonSeptember 28, 2012Great service, great cocktails. Loved The Troublemaker, NY Harvest, Double Barrel, and Wildest Redhead (yum!). Big ice cubes are the best - they don't melt / water down drink, but still keeps it cold.
Chelsea RenaudNovember 6, 2015The lobby of The Iroquois Hotel, a great place for a highly civilized drink. There are private tables, and you can even make a reservation. Keep it in your back pocket for when you need to impress.
NY WaterwayAugust 7, 2012One of the finalists for Best Hotel Bar in the World for the 2012 Spirited Awards, this bar is one of Manhattan's hidden gems, tucked away in the Iroquois Hotel. Great cocktails in a classy setting.- April WallogaFebruary 12, 2014So intimate and cool, but without trying too hard. Almost has the feel of a vintage train car. I usually do bartender's choice, but they have a port cocktail on the menu that I really love.
Tian XieDecember 28, 2013Reminds me of Bioshock Infinite, esp the music. Relive your time with Elizabeth with the select vigors and voxophone music here. 5% of ppl who see this will know what I'm talking about.
The Corcoran GroupJanuary 2, 2014One of our favorite Midtown hotel bars, due to the intimate vibe and delicious upscale, classic cocktails. Be sure to snag a seat near the fireplace if possible!
AmateurConciergeAugust 21, 2016Enter through the Iroquois Hotel lobby and head straight back to find a small, under the radar cocktail bar with great drinks and a nice vibe. Good post work spot
This hidden gem in the Iroquois Hotel is a great place to have a well made cocktail in an otherwise area of New York void of good cocktail bars. Try the Manhattan.- Lindsay CJuly 1, 2016Hidden inside the Iroquois Hotel, this prohibition style cocktail bar is a nice choice for a unique drink. Warning: it gets packed and there's usually a wait. Also they don't serve vodka.
Ernesto GutierrezJanuary 20, 2017Delight yourself with an incredible selection of well balanced cocktails. Then feel lucky and leave it up to the bartender to surprise you with a drink based on your specifications.
simon sOctober 15, 2014Solid cocktails (if a bit sweet) and bartender's recommendations. Menu organization (by shaken, stirred, up & rock) was a nice touch. Menu could be streamlined to remove redundant drinks
DipsologySeptember 27, 2015If you're looking for great cocktails in Midtown, look no further. We like it best for late-night and on Saturdays when it's quieter and the suits have moved elsewhere.
Serious EatsJuly 29, 2013At this intimate bar tucked inside the Iroquois Hotel you can sip wine or beer, but we suggest trying the carefully-made, retro-style cocktails.
Laura ChinMay 11, 2013Intimate, cozy space perfect for tables of 2-4. Let the bartender know what you're in the mood for, and you won't be disappointed.
Cole KennedyApril 8, 2016Super cozy space with delightful bartenders. I liked the "Stay Up Late" and this thing made with gin, cucumber, orange, hot sauce, and Worcestershire. Amazing.
Andie SleemanDecember 14, 2016The best kept secret in Midtown. The cocktails are perfectly crafted. The staff is knowledgeable and friendly. Impress your date by bringing her/him here...you're welcome. ;)
Alicia GFebruary 8, 2014Order an off-menu cocktail. If you can't decide, the super knowledgable server will help guide you to the cocktail of your dreams.
Miguel LopezMay 21, 2016Quality bartending. They can make great off-menu cocktails Baer on what you like. Mezcal? Sin problema.
Great cocktails, super attentive helpful service and nice intimate space with a nice playlist to boot.
DHR.comFebruary 14, 2012This is an intimate and elegant place to have some amazing drink concoctions in an exquisitely-designed environment. The great drinks are created by famous mixologist Meaghan Dorman.
Ricky SherrillOctober 14, 2015On my list of goto Midtown bars to go for drinks with friends. It's a little hidden inside of a hotel which is a nice bonus.
Igor LevitOctober 10, 2014Best speakeasy in midtown. Every cocktail is great, served in an intimate setting. Can get loud.
Sergo GAugust 3, 2014Upscale and intimate bar with very sophisticated drink menu. Try something new, you won't go wrong as the drinks are all well crafted.
Theo Lieberman heads up the bar, which was conceived by Meghan Dorman (of Raines Law Room fame). The space is small, so make a reservation! All the drinks are great.
Daniel WAugust 10, 2014When they says "cozy", they mean it. Doesn't detract from the experience though. Poet's Dream isn't on the menu - strong but good.
Nina YiamsamathaSeptember 20, 2012Perfect place to enjoy cocktails after a show at Radio City - a real midtown gem. You might be tempted to order every drink on the menu...
Kevin SkobacDecember 20, 2014Nice speakeasy close to the barren theater district. The waiter made great recommendations. Reservations are recommended.
Chet ManciniAugust 16, 2015One of the best cocktail spots in midtown. Get the bartenders choice if the menu is too large.- Tracey ChurrayNovember 30, 2014Lovely, quiet cocktail bar tucked in the Iroquois Hotel. Nice spot to get away from midtown craziness.
Lisa LDecember 2, 2014Swanky cocktail bar. The drinks are worth the money. I enjoyed the regal business and remember the alimony!
eFlirt ExpertFebruary 8, 2012Date Tip: You need to make a reservation, but this is a great upscale, intimate hideaway with incredible cocktails. (Same owners as Milk & Honey.)
Jamison AntoineAugust 18, 2011Very good cocktails. Try the Wildest Redhead and the Star. Super J approved. Quite place to share a drink and good conversation. Don't bring the rift raft here.
Victor LowAugust 25, 2012Its a small place so if you go late, you probably won't get a seat. That said, get the keeper's choice: let those wonderful bartenders pick a drink for ya!
Best Gold Rush cocktail in town. Not on the menu, but you can ask them to make it!
Gilt CityJune 29, 2011Delicious upscale cocktails. Try the Poet’s Dream with orange bitters, gin, dry vermouth and benedictine. You'll be a poet before you know it.
Open Air PublishingApril 24, 2012Try the Poet's Dream. Want to make this cocktail at home? Find the recipe in the book "Speakeasy Cocktails" created for iPads. http://oapub.co/c48b46af
Tasting TableJanuary 30, 2012At Lantern's Keep, ask for a Regal Daiquiri--Theo Lieberman will shake it with a grapefruit twist for a drier, more balanced version of the classic. Read more- Josh MateoJune 16, 2015Go for a bartenders choice cocktail. Always a nice surprise and sit at the bar.
Breeze SkrrtAugust 29, 2015I love that the menu is broken down by kind of ice and whether a drink is shaken or stirred.
Jeremy Scott FosterAugust 8, 2014Comfy, upscale and intimate cocktail bar and lounge. Great for a date, prepare your wallet.- _November 6, 2014Extremely well-made cocktails! Great bartenders, great service, and an intimate ambiance.
Heather LiAugust 13, 2013Intimate, classy cocktail bar with very cute and attentive waiters! Try the Penicillin here!- Jeff SmithApril 11, 2015A dark, intimate bar that's perfect for winding down after a busy day. Bartenders are very talented, so let them suggest a drink for you.
Alayna FMay 4, 2013Try the "high horse" - a smoky slightly sweet drink with the right amount of kick.
162 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Lantern's Keep
49 W 44th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave.)
New York, NY 10036
United States
New York, NY 10036
United States
Closed until 5:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 5:00 PM–Midnight
- Sat
- 5:00 PM–2:00 AM
(212) 453-4287
Features
Credit Cards
Yes
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.7
"crispy fries and wing are good. Yardbird scotch eggs is little bit spicy but tasty. Drinks are good too. Definitely will come back!! Highly Recommend"
Carrie Ni - 8.7
"Good whiskey and rum selection, live swing music"
Matt Watson - 9.0
"Sophisticated venue with superbly executed cocktails. Great for groups, or an intimate tête-à-tête. Check out their new location opening on West 40th."
Andrew D.
Places people like to go after Lantern's Keep
Appears on 914 lists
Created by Cora Lambert
25 items • 115 followers
Created by Kathryn Yu
74 items • 407 followers
Date night spots (you're welcome)
Created by Nina Yiamsamatha
63 items • 425 followers
