See all
47 photos

Cosimo's

Italian Restaurant$$$$

Newburgh

Save

Cosimo's

8.9^/10

112

ratings

"Delicious calamari."(2 Tips)
"Get the half salad- half pizza combo for lunch!"(6 Tips)
"The chicken parm was the best I may have ever had!"(2 Tips)
"Love the wine selection and can’t go wrong with the seafood 🦞"(2 Tips)

26 Tips and reviews

Filter:

good service
chicken parmigiana
good for dates
spicy food
good for groups
salads
restaurants
outdoor seating
trendy
eggplant
bar
dinner
lunch
well
appetizers
liquor
parking
takes reservations
(13 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Nadia StOctober 21, 2017
Delicious calamari. We also had the black steak salad that we really liked as well, sautee shrimp pasta, mixed grill and margherita pizza. Picture is for the mixed grill entree. Recommend this place!
JR ColcolMay 31, 2013
Order the shrimp sautee, grilled tomato bruchetta, mozarella fresca eggplant sicillano. delicious calamari
Charles RossiOctober 12, 2012
Love the food but don't have them seat you at the table by the door. Too much traffic, everyone who is waiting for tables stand there and if its the cooler seasons you get the cold air from the door.
Wayne KinlockJune 9, 2019
Been here 10+ times
Love the wine selection and can’t go wrong with the seafood 🦞
Chuck MorrisAugust 5, 2016
Must stop by and see and eat
Edwin VazquezJuly 17, 2013
Great Veal pasta salads and egg plant dishes!!!
Edwin VazquezDecember 2, 2013
Couldn't beat the veal cutlet with a stick it was great!!!
Kelly K.March 18, 2018
The chicken parm was the best I may have ever had!
William LeeOctober 19, 2013
The brick oven bread is delicious
Ni LiAugust 9, 2020
Fried calamari was so good!
Edwin VazquezDecember 3, 2013
Great food. Brick oven pizza awesome
Donna VentoOctober 29, 2017
Been here 25+ times
Chicken parm & pizza. OMG so good
Joe ColomboMarch 25, 2013
Been here 10+ times
The spicy New Yorker is awesome
Geoffrey GoldNovember 26, 2014
Grilled chicken penne is phenomenal.
Alan SnyderJune 8, 2013
Caprese appetizer is amazing!
Nikki CawleyOctober 16, 2017
Was not terribly impressed. Garlic bread was more like a cracker made of pizza crust with mysteriously no garlic.
George PolisJune 2, 2013
The food here was great
@JohnnyBlack__June 28, 2011
Tip Taylor well! She's an absolute doll!
Vanessa CruzMay 12, 2012
Mango Promegranete Martinis.....ymmmm....
Christopher LortzJuly 21, 2013
Best pizza ever
JoniApril 4, 2013
Jazz Night
Blair Larsen-HoltzJuly 25, 2011
Great food and great service!
Liz ZammitAugust 27, 2010
Get the half salad- half pizza combo for lunch!
Wine EnthusiastJune 9, 2010
Wine Enthusiast Restaurant Award Winner 2007-2009! Read more
Lori EllenAugust 12, 2013
too expensive for what you get
Fer CJuly 16, 2015
Puedes pedir pasta alfedo aunque no este en el menú pero la verdad no está tan rica, le ponen demasiada mantequilla.

47 Photos

Cosimo's

Related Searches

Places inside Cosimo's

You might also like

Places people like to go after Cosimo's

Appears on 20 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.