See all
38 photos

Modern Snack Bar

American Restaurant$$$$

Aquebogue

Save

Modern Snack Bar

7.9^/10

ratings

"The soft shell crabs and lemon meringue are amazing!"(5 Tips)
"I highly recommend the soft shell crab sandwich."(3 Tips)
"Everything but esp the lemon meringue 🍋🥧😋"(2 Tips)
"Everything! Chicken pot pie and Prime Rib- Awesome!"(2 Tips)

22 Tips and reviews

Filter:

slice of pie
prime rib
pies
lemon meringue
casual
chowder
burgers
good for a quick meal
milkshakes
meats
turnips
old school diner
friendly staff
crunchy bread
lime
island
bread crumbs
lunch
citrus
parking
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Lynn Bednar-RandoOctober 1, 2019
The lobster roll.fresh mint mojitos and old fashions. Key lime oysters garlicky fresh local oysters with a crunchy bread crumb topping with a citrus key lime finish. Lobster bisque was also delicious
The Corcoran GroupMarch 14, 2011
Happening since the 50s. Great burgers, sandwiches and shakes. Bring the family it’s popular and reasonable.
Samantha StrockisOctober 19, 2011
Go here for great home cooked food! Plus it's the only place I've seen in the area with soft shelled crabs on the menu!
Dani DollNovember 3, 2013
The soft shell crabs and lemon meringue are amazing! Turnips are a must order! The waitresses are friendly. This is a great hometown place!
Neilson AbeelJuly 30, 2012
I highly recommend the soft shell crab sandwich. I love the laid back, friendly vibe of this place.
LarryAugust 19, 2016
Been here 5+ times
If you like duck, the Roast Long Island Duckling is a must!
Caroline JensenJuly 8, 2021
Everything but esp the lemon meringue 🍋🥧😋
Cathy WeschlerJanuary 4, 2015
Another local landmark. The burgers are great. Skip the scallops.
Varun ShettyMay 10, 2015
Old school diner with all the classic and all sorts of delicious pies
Mark ChellisDecember 9, 2016
Everything! Chicken pot pie and Prime Rib- Awesome!
CherylSeptember 22, 2015
Always love coming here for the fried chicken
Randy MeechMay 29, 2013
Solid. I like the fried seafood sandwiches.
Chris BrautJune 18, 2017
Been here 5+ times
Soft shell crab sandwich was very good.
Catherine CoffeyJune 17, 2012
Have to get a slice of pie...they have the best pie
Adam GeorgiouJuly 30, 2011
Crab cakes are awesome, as are all the pies. Coconut was my favorite.
Andra MateraNovember 25, 2015
Pie, lobster sandwich, meatloaf
Tom GilliganOctober 1, 2019
Been here 5+ times
Prime rib pies and cake
Gerald HSeptember 1, 2011
1/4 Duck Lunch is Amazing *****!
Jamie RaeSeptember 1, 2012
Get the Atlantic chowder!
Nicole BonuraJuly 8, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Soft shell crab, amazing!
Nicole HSeptember 2, 2012
Not good food. Soup out of a can & overcooked scallops! Keep on driving!
Anthony LeeJune 10, 2010
Soft-shell crab sandwich is deliiiiiishhh.

38 Photos

Modern Snack Bar

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Modern Snack Bar

Appears on 23 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.