The Pie of Port Jefferson
Pizzeria, Italian Restaurant, and Wine Bar$$$$
Port Jefferson
"Some of the best pizza in Port Jeff."(2 Tips)
"Classic thin brick oven pizza."(2 Tips)
"Sangria, pizza and cannoli are very tasty!"(3 Tips)
"Great family place..try the clam pizza!"(2 Tips)
22 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- good service
- sangria
- great value
- casual
- (14 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Jake SmithAugust 17, 2014Undecided? Give the Di Parma and Casino pizzas a go, although I don't think you'll be disappointed in any of the pies from here.
Debbie CraigOctober 7, 2012The mixed green salad with Gorgonzola cheese, cucumber, red onion and toasted crusted walnuts was Fabulous! A large serving for ten bucks. Great pizza and meatball subs too.
KellyJune 24, 2012Great food, reasonable prices, great service & a very family friendly spot for a sit down meal in the heart of town. We love coming here!
My favorite table is the little one in the front window. The restaurant is rather loud, but this table seems to be the best.
In addition to making a mean brick oven pizza, the staff at the pickup counter was the friendliest!
Katy RayJanuary 17, 2014Every time I come here I remember how lax the service is...after I order my food and don't see the server until they deliver the bill. Everything else is great though!
Explore Long IslandFebruary 20, 2013- Scott CohenFebruary 18, 2012Classic thin brick oven pizza. Yea its on the pricey side, but worth it.
Best pizza in Port Jeff. Tad expensive but expected in a tourist area.
ShawnDecember 7, 2013This thin crust Chicky Cheeses is way too loud and disorganized for the high prices.
21 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
The Pie of Port Jefferson
216 Main St (at E. Main Street)
Port Jefferson, NY 11777
United States
Port Jefferson, NY 11777
United States
Closed until 11:30 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:30 AM–9:30 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:30 AM–10:00 PM
(631) 331-4646
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Drinks
Wine
See More
You might also like
- 8.9
"Cash only...great service..excellent pizza meatball, sausage toppings are fresh and their salads are delicious, their house dressing is bomb"
Lynn Bednar-Rando - 7.8
"Chicken Parm is out of this world!"
Michael Sweeney - 7.5
"Family dinners, romantic dates, or quick slices - never disappoints! Yum!"
Amanda Legene
Places people like to go after The Pie of Port Jefferson
- 8.1
"French Macarons are good :)"
Julie⚓️ - 7.2
"Orang Mango Smoothie is the way to go! Tastes almost like Jamaica :) ps: barely any seating here, but great service!"
Dustin Wingate 
"Beautiful place to spend the day walking through town, or hop on the ferry to CT. either way it's an amazing place and a place you must check out"
Jimmy C
Appears on 12 lists
Created by Jay Jo
1 itemCreated by ᴡ Feinberg
5 items • 2 followersGuide to Port Jefferson's best spots
Created by BIG D .
16 items • 7 followers
