Bella Vita Pizzeria
Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$
Theater District, New York
"Cash only kind of sucks but great pizza and the best garlic knots!"(32 Tips)
"fast service or just a slice of pizza."(3 Tips)
"Try the pizza or the eggplant pasta, can't go wrong with either"(10 Tips)
"amazingly authentic and the service"(2 Tips)
62 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- eggplant parmigiana
- Caesar salad
- wine
- cute
- (12 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Candace HFebruary 16, 2014Much quieter during the day gets busy once the Broadway crowd lets out. Most authentic tasting pizza! Must try: Plain (for the enthusiasts) and the family style Sicilian pie
Eduardo MekitarianDecember 9, 2013Delicious pizza and a lovely spaghetti with meatballs. Sauce was excellent. Not as pricey as expected for Times Square. Great experience!
Martin KargDecember 29, 2014The pizza is excellent and huge (great for 6+), great service and very nice pasta. Very close to Time Square too!
Tyler TomasinoOctober 25, 2014Pizza was awesome. Very thin and crispy, sweet sauce and not too much cheese. Perfect. This place charges for refills though so beware.
Marisela RitchelJuly 30, 2013The tea sucks but I'm from Houston and use to sweet tea.. so sent it back and ordered a coke... Tables are really really close but the food is worth the trip...
Jennifer SNovember 14, 2015Caesar salad was amazing! Service was also great. I was told it would be 25 minutes for a table, and it only took 5.
Ashley LoAugust 31, 2015The pizza was amazing but our waitress gave awful service. She realized she was going to get a bad tip and put AUTOMATIC GRATUITY on our tab. I argued against it but she insisted that was normal.
T FMay 2, 2014Never coming here for dinner again. Slices at the counter with a drink is the way to go. Wine $11 for no name house wine. Panini is made with pita bread & not hot. Too bad since I work a block away.
barbeeJuly 17, 2015People who came in after us were seated before us. No slices in house, only to go. Staff not so friendly. Good garlic knots.
- barbeeJuly 17, 2015Garlic knits initially good but dough after taste is yucky. Not the most amazing pie but better than average. Maybe a 7 on a scale of 1-10.
- barbeeJuly 17, 2015Gratuity included on the three top and service not worth the 18%. 45$ for an extra small pie and garlic knots. Boo
PizzaSnobo pizzasnobo.comApril 26, 2011Thin soft crust. An underrated pizzeria and restaurant combo in Times Square. For more NYC pizza reviews check www.PizzaSnobo.com.
Sarah FrazierJanuary 27, 2014For Times Square pizza, this isn't bad. Expensive, but worth it to avoid La Famiglia.
Barrie SegalApril 29, 2013Steve F. got a slice from here earlier and it looked good from 5 feet away. You will have to follow up with him for details.- Deniss MaksimenkoSeptember 14, 2010Best pizza in town!!!! Great salads(ask for grilled chicken on top) and pastas My fav is penne ala vodka. mmmm
Tammy WuMarch 28, 2014No seating if want to order a slice. You can eat by the counter, but it only has room for ~3 people.- Proverb NewsomeOctober 14, 2010Great pizza! I know occassionally people have bad experiences but the pizza was amazingly authentic and the service was great.
- Great pre or post theater stop when you want good food and fast service or just a slice of pizza.
Discount for Thomson Reuters employees, AWESOME PASTA AND SALADS, andddd the most random 90's music ever. I love this place!
Vg KrishSeptember 2, 2014Ordered spinach ravioli and a lemonade. Ravioli was rubbery and lemonade tasted like cardboard
If you're a garlic lover, then you cannot pass up on the garlic knots here.
Michael J. PerezMarch 15, 2012This place has the name "Brick oven Pizza" for a reason... so stick to that ;) lol
susan andersonNovember 17, 2013Open late but wasn't crowded and was a great first slice of NY pizza for me.
Giovanni OliverDecember 18, 2014What kínd of pizzeria does not allow you to eat a slice inside?!?! Pizza is good though..
Kimberly ChadwickOctober 7, 2012Food was great, the service, however, was non-existent. Our server never came back once she took our order, we had to flag down another server just to get the check. Very disappointing.
- If you happen to spot a bacon & onion pie, grab a slice.
Priscilla S.November 27, 2016Used to be my favorite spot in time square. Got burnt food twice and no comp. whatsoever
Lennon CarusoJanuary 23, 2012Music sucks. Vibe ehh... Service is present. Pizza and salad were delicious.
Jennifer YorkDecember 17, 2013Their pizza sauce tastes like spaghetti-o's, didn't like it at all, stick with the white pizza & avoid the sauce altogether~ ;p
163 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 11:30 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 10:30 AM–11:30 PM
- Sun
- 11:30 AM–11:30 PM
(212) 730-1479
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Wine
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Bella Vita Pizzeria
Appears on 46 lists
Created by Ana Ferreira
33 items • 6 followers
If you love food and you love NYC!
Created by Karina
41 items • 12 followers
