See all
70 photos

Cooperage Inn

American Restaurant$$$$

Baiting Hollow

Save

Cooperage Inn

9.0^/10

119

ratings

"Creme brûlée, key lime pie, Chicken Pot Pie and Atlantic Cod Fillet"(7 Tips)
"The Fall Festival is super fun, a nice place to lunch after..."(2 Tips)
"The Cooperage Inn always has great fresh seafood dishes!!! Enjoy!"(12 Tips)
"local wines and produce add to the experience"(5 Tips)

43 Tips and reviews

Filter:

fall festival
chicken pot pie
brunch food
wine
desserts
good for dates
pork chops
creme brûlée
healthy food
good for groups
trendy
pumpkin
salads
dinner
fresh food
takes reservations
lunch
sesame
blueberries
well
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Cheryl EchevarriaSeptember 8, 2013
Have everything healthy portions very generous. Go early visit the east end of long Island. They are in the heart of wine country and farm country. Buy fresh fruits and vegetables.
John WJune 20, 2016
Appetizer tower was good for two to share. Center cut pork chops with Apple Chutney was delicious for me and Chicken Pot pie for her. Strawberry shortcake was good
Justin MiyagiJune 2, 2014
Amazing brunch. High quality pastries and just plain out worth the $27. Even with just one plate. Low key and worth it. Head to the vineyard after if you're still feeling a nice day.
Bernay SacksAugust 29, 2018
The food here is delicious. Service was excellent. Tony was kind, warm and wonderful. He had great food suggestions as well. We had a wonderful experience here!
IrinaJune 2, 2014
Quite a large space, but quaint at the same time. Make a reservation on Open Table and ask to sit I the music room when you get there. You'll be dining to some crooning and guitar.
ElisaSeptember 8, 2023
Cozy ambience. Great for large groups. Food portions are on the larger side. Get the chicken pot pie! Pork chop is also delicious.
John WJuly 4, 2016
Crab cakes were delicious with steamed vegetables. Fried Calamari for an appetizer was cooked perfectly! Chicken Pot Pie for her was sumptuous
Ricardo D'O. AlbanusNovember 24, 2017
Went here for the Thanksgiving buffet and was blown away by the diversity and quality of the meals and desserts. Highly recommended.
D VolpOctober 17, 2020
Chicken pot pie, meatloaf, pulled pork, & calamari were excellent!! My North Fork Blueberry Collins was PERFECT & not sweet!
Brian LeeJuly 18, 2014
Family style business dinner was solid. (Garden Salad, Chicken Francaise, Penne Alla Vodka, Paella, Tartufo)
Pam PDecember 29, 2013
Best Sunday brunch! Huge buffet with everything you can imagine. Love the fresh watermelon juice.
Rich ZbikowskiApril 24, 2017
The food is excellent and service is also but needs to add some new dishes its always the same
Edgar JonesAugust 5, 2012
If you order the family sized entree this place does not kid around. The menu said "feeds 3 or more" when its more like 6 to 8 more. Awesome!
The Corcoran GroupMarch 14, 2011
You will experience the most amazing brunch and the local wines and produce add to the experience as well. Make the trip.
KaitlinOctober 25, 2012
Go for lunch! Their pre-fixe menu is delicious and you get to choose from an app, entree and dessert!
Angelique ChatparJune 16, 2017
All the food was amazing! Definitely, try the tuna tare tower
AJ HoffmannAugust 14, 2011
Been here 25+ times
Sesame Seared Yellowfin Tuna is one of my favorite meals here. The Cooperage Inn always has great fresh seafood dishes!!! Enjoy!
Cynthia JNovember 12, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Go for the crab cakes as an appetizer! Delicious!
John WApril 9, 2016
Creme brûlée, key lime pie, Chicken Pot Pie and Atlantic Cod Fillet
John WMarch 21, 2017
Shepherds pie was delicious along with Key Lime Pie
Lara WizApril 13, 2015
Terrific Sunday brunch! I suggest reservations.
Mary DonohueMay 5, 2014
The food was delicious. Great deal during restaurant week!
Lyndah RayDecember 14, 2013
Delish!!! Make reservation early in month !!!!
Michele DowlingSeptember 22, 2018
This place is good. A little pricy, but they give bigger portions.
Courtney ThompsonNovember 4, 2012
Try the seafood bisque! No longer has pumpkin ice cream so go to Magic Fountain for dessert
Allen SchneiderDecember 23, 2015
Food was excellent, the atmosphere is great.
Paola ViscogliosiJuly 21, 2020
The chicken pot pie and chicken Caesar salad were good !
Ricardo D'O. AlbanusNovember 24, 2017
Buffet, fish, wine, desserts
NOOOOOO EWWWWWWOctober 2, 2010
The Fall Festival is super fun, a nice place to lunch after the farmers market or the LIVokda distillery next door
Danielle TaylorSeptember 30, 2012
Fantastic brunch!!! Beautiful and great for pumpkin picking too!
Rich ZbikowskiApril 14, 2018
Everything loved it
Tom LocurtoOctober 6, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Atmosphere festive for fall. Tuna very good.
Lyndah RayJune 9, 2014
They have a wonderful Sunday brunch!
Chet ManciniMay 28, 2015
Good seafood and wine.
Catherine ChiarelliMarch 24, 2013
Delightful desserts, scrumptious brunch!
Angela MAugust 13, 2015
Thursday Date Night
Joyce Coleman ZinnelFebruary 21, 2022
The food was great
Tom LambuiNovember 20, 2019
Fantastic as always!!!
Jeff SolomonOctober 9, 2011
Fall festival!!!! Get here early to secure a table outside
Jamie RaeDecember 22, 2013
Steak and bread pudding
Peter ShankmanJuly 30, 2011
Reservation process is circa 1918. Prepare for drama.
Jeff SternDecember 14, 2010
The chicken pot pie is a must!
Shawn RuizApril 30, 2012
The definition of pretentious dining...waaaay overrated.

70 Photos

Cooperage Inn

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Cooperage Inn

Appears on 25 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.