See all
52 photos

Vine Street Cafe

American Restaurant$$$$

Shelter Island

Save

Vine Street Cafe

8.9^/10

103

ratings

Has a stamp of approval from Travel + Leisure and The Corcoran Group
"Calamari salad, duck confit, scallops, steak and Bolognese 👌"(7 Tips)
"The Calamari Salad and Bolognese are the picks here."(6 Tips)
"get the filet mignon with a side of bok choi and mushrooms!"(2 Tips)
"Calamari salad, filet mignon, scallops"(2 Tips)

25 Tips and reviews

Filter:

good service
filet mignon
restaurants
big portions
casual
bar
good for special occasions
chicken
dinner
parking
mushrooms
ragu
chefs
crowded
liquor
(10 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Benjamin PalmerAugust 31, 2013
if you're gonna go for it you might as well go for it: The Double Chateau - a bottle of chateauneuf du pape and a chateaubriand steak for two. Bean and/or green salad to start
naveenAugust 27, 2018
the salmon; the beets. all delicious, big portions too. great for a fancy, special occasion dinner.
The Corcoran GroupMarch 14, 2011
Chefs/Owners Lisa & Terry Harwood in 2002. Features daily "Plats du Jour," local seafood and produce, and desserts. Notable for the calamari salad and the famous Pineapple Tart Tatin.
Greg HillsNovember 7, 2011
Go here. This is my favorite restaurant on Shelter Island. Chef proprietors led the kitchen at Sunset Beach for a few seasons before starting VSC.
Travel + LeisureJune 14, 2012
Foodies flock to Shelter Island for crisp calamari salad and miso salmon in this simple space with high, beamed ceilings.
Daniel HowellsSeptember 7, 2013
Consider taking a half portion of the (amazing but huge) pasta, and explore the rest of menu too.
Justin PulitzerJuly 15, 2013
Perciatelli Ragu is seriously one of the best pasta dishes I've ever had.
CBAugust 22, 2014
Been here 10+ times
The Calamari Salad and Bolognese are the picks here. Everything is generally good though
ClineJuly 31, 2016
get the filet mignon with a side of bok choi and mushrooms!
Amnon BAugust 14, 2014
The best food on shelter island ....but it's NYC prices
Morgan PolotanDecember 4, 2016
Get the butter it's soft
Amanda GluckAugust 31, 2014
Calamari salad, duck confit, scallops, steak and Bolognese 👌
Anthony DeRicoDecember 23, 2015
Food and bar scene. Can get a little crazy, but in a fun way
amanda berkowitzJune 29, 2019
Bolognese on Food Network’s Best Thing I Ever Ate. Hometown favorite.
KD McNultyMay 18, 2019
Two of us had the lobster pot pie special. Yum!
Julia DennisonDecember 28, 2014
Sorry to say but totally mediocre and overpriced. They mean well but the pastas were mushy and the bolognese was nothing special. Not worth the $30 entree prices. Calamari was pretty good, though.
Ashley KnightAugust 26, 2020
Been here 5+ times
Love the calamari salad and profiteroles
TV Food MapsAugust 26, 2014
Check out Vine Street Cafe as seen on Best Thing I Ever Ate Read more
Stephen LenzenAugust 19, 2017
Calamari salad, filet mignon, scallops
Sebastian RojasJuly 28, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Everything is amazing.
Kimberly de GeerMay 17, 2015
Everything!
Ashley KnightSeptember 20, 2019
Been here 5+ times
Calamari salad & the salmon
Mickey Beyer-ClausenMay 26, 2013
A 5-minute ferry trip and you're there.
David HertogAugust 22, 2014
Been here 10+ times
get the bolognese
Jennifer  KimSeptember 23, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Bolognese!

52 Photos

Vine Street Cafe

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Vine Street Cafe

Appears on 90 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.