Colter Bay
Beer Bar$$$$
Allen, Buffalo
"Best Draft Beer selection in Buffalo!"(11 Tips)
"due to the owners falling in love with Wyoming"(3 Tips)
"Thursday's DJ trivia 5-7pm"(2 Tips)
"Craft beer draft list is pretty awesome."(7 Tips)
36 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- wyoming
- great value
- good service
- sandwiches
- happy hour
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Don KJanuary 27, 2017The food was excellent. The beers were awesome. But, it's a Mike Shatzel/New Buffalo kind of bar/restaurant and so don't expect $3 drafts and $6 burgers.Upvoted Mar 24
The food is seriously delicious here. Burgers, chicken sandwiches, etc. Don't come for food on a Sabres game or a Fri night- they understaff and huge wait for food. Awesome beer selection.
Paul BetancourtNovember 14, 2014Really fun place. Fabulous tap beer selection, great bartenders, even to out of town visitors like me ... even when the Bills lost like on this Thursday night. Kitchen/food was spot-on. Will return!
"Complimentary breakfast at noon," said no one. But really come here for the Muddled Old Fashions. They're mouth shaggin' good!
Messie JessieMarch 10, 2015If you can manage a lunch time brew get in here and enjoy people watching during the down time with a good selection of beers.
Brent GatewoodApril 15, 2019Very nice spot. Good selection of beer and food. Great staff. On my list to get to again!- Mike WeaverMay 21, 2011Great tap list, all the Wyoming stuff is due to the owners falling in love with Wyoming while camping there. If you ever get the chance go there but watch your speed if you're to Cody, WY.
The zesty turkey sandwich w/ avocado on a pretzel roll special (side if sp fries) was one of the best sandwiches EVER! Just get it.
Ben TsujimotoSeptember 25, 2012I had low expectations for the wings, but they were really good. Crisp outside, still juicy inside. Medium spice was pretty accurate.
The perfect place to go when u can't decide where to go, and are looking to have a mediocre time before fun begins
Play DJ Trivia every Thursday at 5:00. They give out a $30 Gift Card to the Winning Team!!! Lots of fun!
Shipyard PumpkinHead. Best beer on tap. Only available September and October though!
Beer list is good. Wyoming chicken and fish fry are great
Don't come here when your friends are camping. They'll make you feel like shit.
225 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 2:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:30 AM–2:00 AM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:30 AM–3:59 AM
(716) 436-5197
Features
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Music
Jukebox
Parking
Street
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Colter Bay
- 6.8
"Best jukebox in Buffalo?"
Chris Bissonette - 8.4
"Memphis Pulled pork sammich is a must. Cheaper, delicious, and just as filling as the full dinner version, which just has an extra side."
Scott Howard - 6.4
"Always a diverse crowd on weekends, also always packed. No beer on tap but good coffee mixes in the back."
Buffalo Eats
Appears on 25 lists
Created by phil ciallela
12 items • 9 followers
Dale's Places to Eat & Drink...
Created by Dale Bessinger
127 items • 6 followers
Created by Alicia Hark
85 items • 9 followers
