Planning a trip to New Orleans?
Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.
Mahony's Po-Boy Shop
Sandwich Spot$$$$
Central City - Garden, New Orleans
"Opinion from a Chicagoan: Da Peacemaker Po-Boy is Da Best!"(11 Tips)
"Their roast beef poboy is amazing!"(28 Tips)
"We also love the grilled shrimp, fried green tomatoes & remoulade."(7 Tips)
"Had the fried chicken liver Phobos and it was amazing."(3 Tips)
85 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- po' boys
- peacemaker
- fried green tomatoes
- onion rings
- shrimp
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Mike WinstonMay 5, 2015Yes, do what Emeril & Fieri say and get The Peacemaker, but don't miss the arguably even more delicious Grilled Shrimp, Fried Green Tomato, Remoulade Po-boy. Read all about it on WinstonWanders below! Read more
Andrew CJuly 11, 2018Original location of this po boy shop... menu is quite extensive and fries shrimp po boy + shrimp/grits + etouffee fries were all so phenomenal and hot and delicious and I want it again!!!
Food NetworkNovember 20, 2014Chow down on the Peace Maker, a po'- boy stuffed with fried oysters, bacon and cheddar. For dessert have a slice of the sweet potato crunch pie. Read more
Chefs FeedAugust 2, 2016Mahony's has real po' boy bread from Leidenheimer's and crispy fried chicken livers with a creamy coleslaw to tone down the gaminess. It's balanced and so simple. Read more
- Food NetworkAugust 4, 2014Guy, along with Emeril Lagasse, chowed-down on the Peace Maker, a po'- boy stuffed with fried oysters, bacon, and cheddar. For dessert, Guy had a slice of the sweet potato crunch pie. Read more
- Food NetworkJanuary 28, 2015Recommended by local celebrity Chef Emeril Lagasse, Mahony's is doing the po' boy 22 different ways. The Peacemaker includes fried oysters, bacon and cheddar. Read more
Kevin ThompsonDecember 8, 2012Drove to NO From NC. Heard about this place on food network. It didn't disappoint. Wow. We had the French fry PO boy and the root beer ham. Amazing! The sweet potato pie is out of this world!
Colleen LoriaNovember 25, 2013The shrimp po boy was absolutely delicious. The roast beef po poy is made with chuck Roast not the typical type of beef usually used in RB po boys. It was good but the prices were very very high!
Boyd CaptainGritsJuly 22, 2014Ok this place is amazing. I had a great waitress and great food. My wife had shrimp, fried green tomato poboy and I had the peacemaker. We both loved our choices.- Bryan IraceApril 17, 2017Great sandwiches, if you’re over by the cemetery. Not sure it’s worth trekking all the way here just for the food if you’re not already in the neighborhood, as I’m sure there are comparable places.
Anna de JesusApril 8, 2013Good pacemaker and jumbo shrimp poboy. Ask for the mini or 6 inch. Lots of food. Oyster is market price, so can be pricey. Great breading on the oyster- Find. Eat. Drink.July 5, 2011Chef Adolfo Garcia says, “get the chicken liver po-boy with coleslaw.” We also love the grilled shrimp, fried green tomatoes & remoulade. That’s chef Wicks’ grandmother delivering the po-boys from the
Cameron GarrardMarch 22, 2015The service was great, and the Fried Shrimp Po'boy was delicious. With some background music, and TV's, Mahony's is a great place for lunch!
Andy CampbellNovember 14, 2012Agree with previous posts on the Peacemaker on price. Pretty expensive but very good. I suggest putting a little Louisiana hot sauce on the sandwich. Adds the perfect missing component: heat!
Will NSeptember 12, 2013Ask how much your "Market Price" item is going to be to avoid sticker shock. I spent $14.95 on Shrimp/Fried Green Tomato/Remoulade Poboy when trying to get a cheap lunch.
Kimberly H.January 20, 2016Yummy po-boys, huge portions....outdoor seating....loaded fries/dirty fries...whatever they're called, they're awesome
etta yApril 6, 2015Great sandwiches and crispy shoestring onion rings. Lots of cute browsing and shopping in the hood too.
Lisa JettNovember 29, 2013In NY we call them "heroes" and they're usually heavy and filling. These po-boys were tasty and light and overpriced. Bloody Mary was good and spicy.
Miranda McDonaldNovember 17, 2014The pig fries are delicious, and as much food as a poboy, if not more. The fried shrimp was good. It was a bit expensive.
Anne FaderJune 2, 2012Yes it's pricy but the food is GOOD! Get a peacemaker, some fries and sweet tea. You won't have room for dessert but try if you can.
Colleen Newvine TebeauApril 12, 2011The fried green tomato and shrimp remoulade po boy is amazing -- but don't do it if you're in a hurry. This isn't a rush in and rush out place.
Gambit New OrleansOctober 24, 2012Try the chicken livers in a singularly rich po-boy dressed with slaw. Gambit's Five spots for fried chicken livers. Read more
Maggie MacGSeptember 27, 2023The salad with the raisins is good but maybe get the dressing on the side.
Jessica LlanesJune 17, 2010I do love the grilled shrimp and fried green tomato poboy here but recent long waits and decline in shrimp quality have demoted this one favorite to a rare choice for me. Too many other poboy places.
PARANOLAJanuary 20, 2012Mahony’s is a popular place for the PARANOLA team to hang out and discuss ongoing investigations, paranormal theories... and eating some tremendous po-boys! Stop by, you could run into one of us!
John TraubFebruary 16, 2012Get here early to avoid the line and enjoy one of the greatest sandwiches you will ever have
- Gambit New OrleansMay 13, 2013
- Gambit New OrleansDecember 9, 2011A standout shrimp po-boy...shrimp are grilled, tomatoes are fried, and remoulade is everywhere... Read more
Cecily FogartyMay 17, 2010NOT a true po-boy shop. Shrimp po-boy is all wrong and I've been eating them for thirty years. Great shoestring onion rings, they are the only thing worth the very long wait.
Elizabeth ThompsonOctober 5, 2013Awesome dirty fries. Share or order only this because they are big.
Don't underestimate the size of these Po Boys. You'll have to be carted out if you finish the whole thing.
Unfortunately mahony's has become too popular for its kitchen to keep up with. Bring a book. You'll be here awhile.
Jeff WisemanDecember 28, 2011the onion rings are delicious, they are like shoestrings and wonderful!
Doug OvervoldNovember 14, 2012Unbelievable Po'Boy. Pot Roast is the bomb. And dirty fries. Pretty fast got sandwich
Mike MortonNovember 6, 2010The dirty fries are heavenly, and the po-boys are good, but there's just as good or better elsewhere in this town...and for less money too.
Geoffrey GauchetJanuary 17, 2011Staff was great and polite. Food was awesome! Peacemaker was amazing, but expensive due to oysters
Cherie FernonJune 13, 2016Besides the fried shrimp, the food was HORRIBLE! Po boys were dry and served on extremely stale French bread. Most of the food was burnt. No help from server. Spent $200+ but left hungry. NEVER AGAIN!
The greatest Magazine poboy. You have to gave the grilled shrimp, fried green tomatoes, and roumelade poboy. It is a religious experience.
TV Food MapsAugust 27, 2014Check out Mahony's PO Boy Shop as seen on Diners, Drive-ins and Dives Read more
- Gambit New OrleansJuly 7, 2011Choose a 3-inch po-boy & a pint of beer for $8 every night from 7-10PM
207 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Mahony's Po-Boy Shop
3454 Magazine St (btwn Delachaise & Aline)
New Orleans, LA 70115
United States
New Orleans, LA 70115
United States
Open until 9:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
- Sat–Sun
- 10:00 AM–9:00 PM
(504) 899-3374
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Dining Options
Bar Service, Take-out, Delivery
Parking
Street
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 9.2
"The po boys are must here. The surf & turf is great, but if you like your fried shrimp crispy, make sure to get the shrimp only po boy. Gumbo here is bangin' as well."
Emily Simon - 8.7
"So many great selections to choose from, you'll want to keep coming back to try everything! The ham and cheese is a must try, and don't forget to get the freshly pressed French coffee."
maneesha - 6.5
"Great service! Best subway in Uptown/Garden District."
Kevin Gallin
Places people like to go after Mahony's Po-Boy Shop
- 9.0
"From a barista: try the white chocolate lavender and ADD espresso. The espresso cuts the richness (but still tastes amazing). It's a little pricey, but after a taste, you'll appreciate why. Enjoy!"
Ryan Colgin - 8.4
"Great outdoor seating, loved their fries with cheese,bacon and ranch"
Kate Hogan - 8.6
"Heart stoppingly delicious. A must visit in NOLA. Go for one of the specials, they are creative and guaranteed hot dog heaven."
Anthony Gomez
Appears on 253 lists
"Diners, Drive-Ins & Dives" (Part 2, KY - TN)
Created by Tristan
182 items • 562 followers
Created by Paul Chang
200 items • 442 followers
Created by Gina Ciullo
200 items • 225 followers
