See all
130 photos

Keylime Bistro

Seafood Restaurant$$$$

Captiva

Save

Keylime Bistro

7.4^/10

111

ratings

"Key lime pie is totally a must try... definitely award-winning!!"(5 Tips)
"Keylime pie is delicious."(2 Tips)
"foodie and enjoy being on "island time"."(2 Tips)
"The live musician is fantastic!!!"(6 Tips)

39 Tips and reviews

Filter:

live music
key lime pie
seafood
cocktails
margaritas
breakfast food
brunch food
blackened chicken
spinach salad
outdoor seating
bacon
dinner
meats
island
lunch
appetizers
fruit
(12 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Chris HowardSeptember 26, 2017
Been here 50+ times
Our favorite restaurant on Captiva. Sit outside and have dinner while listening to live music. Chris Workman on Monday evenings is the best! Full bar and the drinks are always good. Enjoy!
Keith KaplanAugust 26, 2014
A bit expensive for their entrees, but was delicious. The daiquiris are so great, want to try the margaritas next time. Coconut shrimp is tasty as well.
C. J. McElhinneyAugust 4, 2013
Great menu. Just like RC Otter's across the street, there's almost always a musician playing. Try the Banana Creme Pie Martini.
Chris MorganJanuary 2, 2014
Sit outside for live music. Order blackened grouper & avoid crowd pleaders. Key lime pie is too sweet and over creamed. Good beers on tap. Skip dessert and get ice cream @ Latte Da
Andrew CMarch 17, 2015
went on a Tuesday night in early March... seemed unusually crowded and quite slow service--BUT food was absolutely delicious and honestly worth the wait!!!
Isabella KayatSeptember 4, 2017
They have breakfast until 2 pm. The eggs benedict with crab are awesome
Jeremy LebensDecember 4, 2020
Nice little spot for breakfast. Pancakes and breakfast potatoes were decent. Chocolate milk was killer.
Heather VoightApril 5, 2013
This was by far our favorite restaurant on the island. Great staff, excellent service and phenomenal food. Great night out for adults!
Ruth PlateFebruary 26, 2019
Nachos appetizer— enough for the table — AND the key lime pie AND the live music!!!
Dave GAugust 11, 2014
Awesome breakfast service. The corned beef hash was really good and they kept the coffee flowing.
✨Misty WuoriJanuary 31, 2013
Outdoor seating and margaritas! The live musician is fantastic!!!
Lisa BrumbaughJuly 22, 2020
Chicken Voodoo is amazing! Great blackened chicken flavor.
Liz PallattoJuly 8, 2013
Liked our live musician and general vibe - would say grilled salad was an interesting idea that failed in execution
Michael LapkoMarch 13, 2015
Loco Risoto was Excellent, and the live entertainment on Wednesday evening was super !
Dave WMay 14, 2012
Great brunch! Love the crab cake Benedict. The bloody mary with shrimp is great too
David CobbAugust 9, 2012
Great food and atmosphere but a bit more expensive than some others, especially for dinner.
Jason MontgomeryJune 22, 2011
The stuffed salmon was out of this world and the 3 scallops at the corners were a party in my mouth.
Michael P. HillMarch 12, 2014
Paella is very tasty with good seafood. Tuna steak was flavorless.
Rose L.December 13, 2013
Great Paella! Very flavorful broth!
Gail KoernerMarch 24, 2012
Spinach Salad & the Bacon Wrapped Scallops are both AMAZING!
Ryan StonerOctober 29, 2012
Go to Key lime Bistro if you are foodie and enjoy being on "island time".
David CobbApril 28, 2013
Great food and music. Shame no wi-fi though.
Mary Jeneverre SchultzMay 10, 2017
Keylime pie is delicious.
Michele MaherDecember 11, 2011
Key lime pie is totally a must try... definitely award-winning!!
Heather McCainJune 6, 2013
Crab cakes are good. Amazing drink list.
Julie LangloisMay 18, 2013
Very tourist-y. Outside tables are nice. Don't get the grouper sandwich..frozen so it tastes super fishy! Yuck.
Michael FJune 18, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Most everything is excellent but you must sit outside and realize 'island time' applies!
Chandler ParisDecember 30, 2014
Scallops wrapped in bacon and Grilled Mahi
Susan StewartOctober 7, 2017
Great food, live music.
PatrickJanuary 19, 2013
Been here 10+ times
The French toast is the TIT's
Michael SilvesterNovember 6, 2011
A few john daileys and a plate of nachos with steak....
Peri BaptistaJuly 19, 2013
Key West Ale is very nice.
Pamela SotoJanuary 24, 2014
The best Keylime pie!!!
Jörg D.August 16, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Horny Margarita is great
Leo OjedaMay 27, 2013
Overpriced and bad food. They start you with a plate of a ball shaped-wheezcheez-spray cheese and grapes. First and last time here.
Kari BakalJune 16, 2013
Key Lime pie ★★★★
Caitlin ReaganJuly 15, 2012
Beware: breakfast is mediocre. I ordered an omelet--no flavor. Fruit was unripe. Service was sluggish.
JJ S.June 18, 2013
Food was so so. Key lime pie was good.
Nathan SchockJanuary 19, 2010
The Keylime Margarita is as good as it gets!

130 Photos

Keylime Bistro

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Keylime Bistro

Appears on 11 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.