See all
684 photos

St. Elmo Steak House

Steakhouse$$$$

Downtown Indianapolis, Indianapolis

Save

9.0^/10

651

ratings

Ranked #1 for seafood in Indianapolis
Go here. Experience the shrimp cocktail. It's worth it.
"Loved the shrimp cocktail, ribeye steak and lobster mac n' cheese."(95 Tips)
"navy bean soup with a touch of cocktail sauce..."(5 Tips)
"Devour Downtown participant"(3 Tips)
"The filet mignon was excellent-- perfectly cooked, and excellent."(8 Tips)

191 Tips and reviews

Filter:

shrimp cocktail
good for dates
devour downtown
filet mignon
good for groups
navy bean soup
spicy food
prime rib
trendy
bar
tomato juice
dinner
surf & turf
big portions
prix fixe menu
spacious
great value
creme brûlée
pork chops
cocktail sauce
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Downtown IndyJuly 17, 2014
St. Elmo Steak House has been a landmark in downtown Indianapolis since 1902 and has earned a national reputation for its excellent steaks and professional service.
PureWowJuly 26, 2016
St. Elmo is especially famous for its shrimp cocktail, which comes out with great to-do-four jumbo shrimp, on ice, with a generous dollop of cocktail sauce. And the steak’s pretty epic, too. Read more
John PestkaSeptember 20, 2014
The Shrimp Cocktail is a must though beware the heat... holy cow. I also highly recommend the infused Maker's Mark on the rocks - tasty and enjoyable. Extensive wine list with something for all.
Jon B.January 6, 2019
Start with the shrimp cocktail (warning, the cocktail sauce is potent!), and grab one of their steaks with a side of green beans. Baked potato is also a solid side. I also like their navy bean soup!
Erik RowleyOctober 1, 2016
A prestigious must-eat restaurant. Shrimp so hot it will clear your sinuses, steak filet mignon that is world renown, and their signature cocktail "Elmo Cola". A once in a lifetime dining experience.
MarcJanuary 21, 2021
Esquire: Out of all great old steakhouses across the US landscape, might be the strangest. Its signature dish is a shrimp cocktail overloaded w/horseradish (waiters will warn u, u won’t listen)
Linds EllisSeptember 26, 2016
I was so full and couldn't possibly fit another bit of food in my belly. However, my husband insisted I try something. So, I had one filet slider. It was amazing. Fell apart right in my mouth!
Christopher FlossNovember 15, 2020
The shrimp cocktail is a must. A steak is a must (the New York strip was my choice), but don’t overlook the pork chop!! Very tasty!
Rona.August 13, 2019
I think it’s the best restaurant here in Cleveland. Try the lamb it’s very good, if you’re gonna try the “famous shrimp cocktail” pls be careful because it’s too hard 🦐
Marc Edouard Jean MarieNovember 3, 2018
I had the chopped steak and my girlfriend had the Flat Iron and they were both amazing. Hearty portions and delicious meals. Their beer and wine selection is also interesting
Kyle AdamsJune 26, 2017
Probably the most well-known Indianapolis restaurant, famous for its blistering-hot shrimp cocktail sauce. Don't be surprised if you see celebs or pro athletes eating there.
James DeGraffenreidtSeptember 4, 2013
Classic steak house ambience featuring wood panelling and friendly noise level. Good spirits list, especially rye and bourbon whiskies. Steaks, salads and desserts were very good. Large portions.
Justin LockeMarch 12, 2015
Shrimp Cocktail, Amazing Steak, Great Beer and awesome atmosphere. You have to come if in Indy
Match ThisflyJuly 8, 2014
Their shrimp cocktail was always my highlight for the Indy 500. It's about the cocktail sauce though. Yes, the shrimp are humongous & fresh, but it's the sauce. It will blow your top of your head off!
Jennifer EvansSeptember 25, 2014
Amazing dinner but come hungry! Loved the shrimp cocktail, ribeye steak and lobster mac n' cheese. Homemade apple pie was delicious!
Staff PicksDecember 6, 2016
St. Elmo Steak House was one of the more wished for places throughout 2015’s I Want Somewhere holiday campaign. Where’s your somewhere? Enter to win a bucket list experience. Read more
Jake SmithMay 5, 2013
The 12 oz. Filet was magnificent, but my favorite parts were my waiter (incredibly helpful and knowledgeable), the mashed potatoes (rich and decadent), and the tomato juice (weird but fitting).
Robert BodineAugust 24, 2013
Of course I got the shrimp cocktail; it was incredible. This time, I tried the pork chops. They were also fantastic. If you visit Indianapolis and don't eat at St. Elmo's, you wasted your trip.
John KAugust 24, 2015
Cowboy Bone In Ribeye blackened and medium rare was perfect! If u have the shrimp cocktail your sinuses will be clear for days! Great service too! Place is a classic!
Amy CummingsDecember 20, 2018
Don’t even try to hold back. Go for the Elmo Cola, Navy Bean Soup, Filet Mignon, and Cheesecake.
David FoxApril 2, 2012
We shared 2 steaks amoung the 5 of us. No extra charge for splitting (though you cut it up yourselves). Also, amazing shrimp coctail. Huge shrimp (prawns?) in a sauce with lots of fresh horseradish.
JKJuly 6, 2021
St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail is a must. Joey Chestnut made record here with 9 pounds, 4 ounces of shrimp in eight minutes
Alan HedrickMay 11, 2017
Such the perfect treat. Love the shrimp cocktail!! A must do bucket list place to stop.
Greg HammondMarch 16, 2018
Steak was fantastic. Service was awesome. We had Will as our server and he went above and beyond. Really great guy. Very memorable experience.
Andrew BorgenJanuary 25, 2015
Best steak I've ever eaten, excellent sides, and over the top service! Try the shrimp, it will make you cry!
Diana DomanNovember 7, 2016
Holy hell- the shrimp cocktail should be called Brain Freeze. Amazing yet painful at the same time ... also the asiago bread/cracker is the best thing maybe ever.
doug jaegerSeptember 22, 2014
Ok, so sometimes things tat restaurants are famous for, are tourist traps, but in this case, the shrimp cocktail, is in fact the 'balls'. Order it. If you horseradish!
Monster Energy SupercrossOctober 8, 2010
If you know anything about Monster Energy Supercross in Indy, it's that this is the best steak house in town. Try their shrimp cocktail and run into some famous faces at the same time!
Zach HedrickSeptember 7, 2014
One of my favorite steakhouses in the country! Order a shrimp cocktail, their cocktail sauce is the best I've ever had!
IS KLEApril 6, 2015
Lives up to the hype for hot homemade horseradish cocktail sauce and good shrimp. It's really hot. Good steaks, creamed spinach.
Dee HibbardAugust 1, 2012
Delicious food, especially the Chicken for those who don't like steak, but expect to take a lot home. Shrimp Cocktail, of course! Waiter was VERY rude, though, to any 21&under members at our table.
Terri SigaiJuly 2, 2014
Absolutely everything is Devine. Steaks perfect, shrimp cocktail is amazing and a must have. Extensive wine list.
Leah BeyerNovember 9, 2012
The shrimp cocktail is amazing and painful all at the same time. It is a must have if you go! Just be careful with the amount of cocktail sauce.
Renee MaslikhovAugust 16, 2011
Their shrimp cocktail was the highlight of my visits for the Indy 500. It's all about the cocktail sauce though. Yes, the shrimp are humongous & fresh, but it's the sauce. They should sell it!
Martin OvandoMarch 22, 2016
Definitively my fav restaurant in Indianapolis so far! Try the Filet Mignon with potatoes, a beauty!
Maria AlvizMay 10, 2018
The most famous steakhouse in the city. Anyone visiting Indy needs to try their famous shrimp cocktail!
Emmanuel TiglaoAugust 26, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Whatever you order, add a Shrimp Cocktail. It's worth it. Large jumbo shrimp topped with their freshly made cocktail sauce.
Ellen CarlMay 20, 2013
If you're there on a Sunday, ask for the "Sunday Dinner." $35 pre fixe includes their famous shrimp cocktail.
Dougie RocksMay 27, 2016
Shrimp cocktail, Lobster Bisque, and a huge hunk o' Prime Rib..
K BoJune 8, 2017
As good as it gets. The prime rib is wonderful.
Karen L.February 4, 2012
Not a seafood lover but I have to say the shrimp cocktail was the rave in the room. Nice atmosphere. Good sized portions. Great ambassador venue for the city. Yummy
Alberto AcuñaMay 6, 2016
Best. That describes it perfectly. It is the best by far. Great food, great people.
Matt McCourtFebruary 18, 2014
Everything was great...except the Steak....disappointed....to say the least....great service and the other items were awesome....I've just had better Steaks....
Omid MoradshahiJune 16, 2017
As many others will clearly say, you must get the shrimp with kicking' cocktail sauce (use sparingly)!!!
Men's Health MagApril 10, 2015
After the Indanapolis 500, head down to Mass Ave. and don't miss out on the shrimp cocktail at St. Elmo's. Read more
Rebecca MathewsApril 12, 2015
AMAZING. The shrimp cocktail definitely lived up to the hype & the service was wonderful.
Stephan HotschJune 13, 2017
If you got the money, you should try to eat the steak here. It's awesome... The service is tremendous good.
MissKris 🎀 1011December 31, 2013
I don't eat red meat so I got the king crab and shrimp linguini...delicious! Upgrade to the lobster bisque!
Ben HarrisonMarch 18, 2013
Like everyone says, the shrimp cocktail is awesome and has a devastating kick but totally worth the burn >:-)
Winnie KhooOctober 10, 2019
Fave: Sunday set menu - shrimp cocktail, petit filet, bourbon sauce, creme brûlée

1 2 3 4

684 Photos

St. Elmo Steak House

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after St. Elmo Steak House

Appears on 250 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.