Toast Coffeehouse
(Now Closed)Breakfast Spot and American Restaurant$$$$
Port Jefferson
63 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
ReiMarch 12, 2016Lots of pancakes! coffee! and French toast!! 😻 vegan meal options too, and cool art on display. Please make vegan pancakes for my sisters! We'll love you forever. :) <3
Laura San NicolasMarch 23, 2013Never disappoints. Best coffee I've had in a long time. But don't go there in a hurry, the place is usually busy and therefore it takes a little while to get your food. But,Definitely worth the wait!
Lynn Bednar-RandoJuly 19, 2018Corned beef hash dish is amazing, Vermont maple nut coffee, fruit tea, are must haves, best multi grain and fresh rye toast
K WFebruary 18, 2018I used to work as a barista and became very aware of what good and bad coffee tastes like, especially lattes and cappuccinos. This place had really great coffees and really yummy and unique foods.
Sandy QuesquenFebruary 6, 2014Delancey omelette, sweet potato waffle and las amigas omelette were delish. Apart from some very home like comforting cups of coffee :)
Barbara TjiongJune 23, 2015Always go there for breakfast and loved. Just try there lunch recently, had "Hampton ham n Brie" wrap, OMG! So good! Nice service, nice people.
Graham cracker coffee is delicious. Honestly everything here is amazing, but my favorite is the Mediterranean omelette with those potato hash browns.
Jackie MillerJune 12, 2011tofu scramble is absolutely amazing. chai latte to die for and if you are vegan i would ask them to make you their secret special oatmeal...
StephenAugust 2, 2012I absolutely love toast and would recommend it to anyone! Try to make it down on the first Thursday of every month, they kick off a new artists 1 month show with live music !
Nikolas FlorosJanuary 25, 2015Best breakfast spot in Port Jeff. Omelettes and coffee are great and they have some truly delicious multi grain bread.
Blueberry lemon mimosa's for breakfast & the bad Larry for lunch. You won't be sorry. Show up early and prepare yourself for a wait on the weekends
Meg FarmerFebruary 3, 2015In a small town, this spot serves some solid breakfast/brunch foods. Make sure you order before 3pm, even on wkends, or you'll be regulated to the lunch menu. Service could be better, not friendly.
Rebecca Van Orden BerkowitzSeptember 26, 2015Had a nice brunch with Hubby. It was a fun atmosphere and delicious food. Want to go back to try more menu items that sounded yummy!
Sean LlewellynSeptember 2, 2015Awesome selection of unique pancakes and French toasts. You can't go wrong with any of them.
Kendra McCarrickSeptember 21, 2013Butternut squash and maple bacon with caramelized onions and green apple omlet... heaven
Stefan WernerMarch 31, 2017Why go to a diner? Food here is better, and prices are on-par. GREAT cup of coffee, and 1st rate service!
CharlieNovember 7, 2011One of my favorite breakfast eateries! Great food and service!! But get there early on the weekends. The line starts to form very quickly.
N AvedisSeptember 30, 2018Lovely place, loved their eggs Benedict. Definitely was worth the long wait.
Marites SonSeptember 29, 2011A great place to enjoy & relax with your friends over fondue, tasty appetizers and an excellent selection of wine!
Carolyn 🎗☘January 6, 2016Coffee was yummy and came in big mugs the place is small so they call you when the table is ready.
Sara NelsonJanuary 10, 2011Great for breakfast, of course! But come later in the week for evening tapas, fondu, and wine. Local artists are featured there as well.
Amanda LegeneApril 8, 2012Absolutely the BEST breakfast on LI! I like to try a different coffee each time I go - NEVER disappoints!
Corey-Jason SaileApril 2, 2011Every time im come here I say "im gonna get something new" and I still always get the "Tom on the town" best thing on the menu! Mmm turkey and asiago.....
Everything tastes amazing. Don't be scared to try something awesome like the Graham cracker FT
Diane HaleckyAugust 10, 2013Seated us and forgot about us until I asked to see the waitress. took our order then forgot about us. Brought toms and Jacobs and not mine. And theirs was cold. Needless to say, we got a free meal.- Kelsey LaPortApril 6, 2010Must check out Toast Coffeehouse. Burritos and omelets are hardcore. Best part is the random coffee cups and laid back atmosphere. Read more
The Original breakfast burrito, the Crunchy French toast, & Miss Lucy's are my breakfast favorites!
Tyler OconApril 21, 2013The wait is absolutely unacceptable. Was told it was 45 minutes, wound up being an hour and a half, and they wound up sitting us at the same table as three other people with two open tables around.
Best thing on the menu: Graham Cracker Encrusted French Toast! Of course all of the calories are taken out. ;)
W Legacy👑April 17, 2011This place has the most awesome breakfast options...creative and extremely tasty
Brian MedeirosDecember 10, 2015Why offer organic items, but unless you are willing to pay the real syrup tax, you get liquid corn?
Their pancakes are HUGE and amazing! Try them, you won't be disappointed!
120 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Toast Coffeehouse is an innovative breakfast & lunch eatery with an artistic vibe. We've been reviewed by The New York Times & voted the 2008 best breakfast on Long Island by AOL City's Best. Additionally, we have tapas, fondue, cheese plates, eclectic wines, & desserts for Friday & Saturday nights.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 8:00 AM–3:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 8:00 AM–11:00 PM
- Sun
- 8:00 AM–4:00 PM
(631) 331-6860
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Music
Live Music
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch
Drinks
Wine, Full Bar
See More
You might also like
- 5.8
"Request a table on the deck, as the view is magnificent. I can recommend the Chicken and Sausage Campagnola; good flavor and a large portion."
Jake Smith - 7.3
"Best warm lobster roll EVER!"
Daniel AroundtheWorld - 5.9
"Happy hour hummus is so good! Make sure you get your drinks from Rachel or Dan!"
Siobhan
Places people like to go after Toast Coffeehouse
- 7.2
"Orang Mango Smoothie is the way to go! Tastes almost like Jamaica :) ps: barely any seating here, but great service!"
Dustin Wingate - 7.9
"Very relaxing to just sit on the deck, listen to music and have some food and drink with friends."
Gretchen Hoey 
"Great little town with all kinds of hole in the wall shops....loved Salsa Salsa for lunch and the amazing views from the pier..."
Michelle Lopez Casten
Appears on 56 lists
Created by Kelly
92 items • 10 followersCreated by Kortney B
199 items • 25 followers
Guide to New York's best spots
Created by Charlie
51 items • 9 followers
