Pete & Elda's Bar - Carmen's Pizzeria
Pizzeria, Bar, and Italian Restaurant$$$$
Neptune City
"They have the best thin crust pizza I've ever tasted in New Jersey."(23 Tips)
"Double extra large pizza is incredible."(3 Tips)
"The best thin crust pizza down the shore."(2 Tips)
"Oh, try the wings :)"(6 Tips)
94 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- shore
- good for groups
- casual
- good for a quick meal
- (10 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
TomSeptember 23, 2013Regional food at it's finest! Paper thin pizza. Sit at the bar, have a beer, and get a 'bar pie.' You will get two bills (one for the pizza, one for the beer), but your total will only be $10.
amy hurleyMay 17, 2015Best thin pizza around. Lete and eldas is a go to place and is always packed! Be prepared to wait a little but worth it- Dominic Di cocoNovember 3, 2013So great l, I get to pay a bar tab and a food tab ? That's so much easier than everywhere else on planet earth . Oh, try the wings :)
Perri SilverAugust 13, 2017Pizza and pasta are so good. Easily some of the thinnest pizza I've ever had.
Robyn McAllisterMay 2, 2012Linguine and white clam sauce is outstanding!!!!!! And you never go wrong with a thin crust pie. All the staff is always 5*. Never an nhappy face
I love the spaghetti and meat sauce here. Its excellent along with the new England Clam Chowder
Late night menu is awesome and cheap when you sit at the bar. The bartenders are very friendly and attentive.
Amanda EveAugust 27, 2012Best thin crest pizza ever. Not usually a fan but I'll only eat it here. Pair that with a Malibu and coke your golden.
Todd HamiltonJanuary 2, 2015Most unique pizza you'll have; my family loves it! Also love the meatballs and chopped salad.
Andrew DeinertDecember 8, 2012Get an extra large pizza for two people......we finished it no problem and it was the best thin-crust pizza I've ever had!
It’s all about the pizza, but the sandwiches are good, too. Try the wings!
LiederNovember 5, 2011We stop in for some of that famous thin crust pizza anytime we're in the area. They make a darn good burger, too.
- Elle MundyOctober 1, 2019Double extra large pizza is incredible. One of the best in the New York metro area
Try the Steak Murphy - Under those mountain of spicy peppers and potatoes were a slab of tender steak.
Oso VinOctober 31, 2015Good thin crust pizza & fried Calamari.... But it's smells like old beer and cleaning supplies ??? But love the pizza
Brian HoldenMarch 18, 2014Only pizza that makes sense as a plain cheese. Others need toppings. The thin crust is like no other pizza in the world.
best pizza in the state of new jersey. period. (my opinion)
Rich OttenstroerNovember 5, 2011I love the food. Just have to time it right so the wait for a table isn't outrageous.
Tony L.September 13, 2014I'm sorry but a antipasto is not deli meat with a salad dumped on it. And what's the deal with the calamari? Taste and looks like it was previously frozen... Here's hoping the pizza is better...
For best service, eat at the bar. Their pizza is super thin and delicious!
Eat a XXL-sized pizza, get a free t-shirt. And the pizza is good enough to do so.
Awesome pizza ..staff...so damn busy...which is a good thing right...
Kelly StocksJune 5, 2010The thin crust pizza is so delicious. Spring for the double extra large - it makes great leftovers.
I love the staff here! I'm here so often they remember me!
John ParkAugust 9, 2010Great thin crust pizza! Actually need to order 2 because 1 isn't enough for 2 people.
NJ CoorsOctober 11, 2010Enjoy $1.75 pints of Coors Light Every day. Nothing better to go along with the best thin crust pizza in the area!- Catherine BerardiDecember 5, 2011Cheap pizza, calamari and wings at the bar after 10. Looping this play.
Matthew GivensNovember 13, 2011The Pizza is fantastic but stay away from the seafood. It's frozen and pre-breaded.
211 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Pete & Elda's Bar - Carmen's Pizzeria
96 Woodland Ave
Neptune City, NJ 07753
United States
Neptune City, NJ 07753
United States
Specializing in Thin Crust Pizza - The Original for 50 years - No Copycats Here!!
#1 Pizza - Voted Best "Pizza and Bar" - New Jersey Monthly Magazine 2007
Open until 1:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:30 AM–1:00 AM
(732) 774-6010
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
Yes
Dining Options
Bar Service, Take-out
Parking
Yes
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, BYO
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Pete & Elda's Bar - Carmen's Pizzeria
- 8.3
"I LOVE it here... They have great Irish / Pub / Seafood... But for the pizza I'd go down the street!"
Corner Tavern - 8.3
"Cake batter ice cream; cotton candy ice cream; flying saucers; ice cream cakes that they will specially make for you; cookies and cream ice cream; red velvet ice cream"
Kara Cuneo - 9.2
"Always clean and barely any people during the week but Sundays are so crowded. Be sure to go to Pop's Garage when it opens up again and get the corn. :)"
Amanda Schlesier
Appears on 77 lists
Locals Guide 48hrs: Monmouth County Jersey Shore
Created by Ann M
84 items • 79 followersCreated by S Rios
12 items • 4 followers
Created by Elle Mundy
71 items • 16 followers
