American Hotel
Hotel
Sag Harbor
Ranked #2 for hotels in Sag Harbor
The experts at Travel + Leisure and The Corcoran Group recommend this place
"backgammon table in the front room"(2 Tips)
"Billy Joel is standing next to me."(2 Tips)
"Make sure to try the crab cakes"(4 Tips)
"Very tasty lobster sandwich in a nice and luxus atmosphere"(2 Tips)
33 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- backgammon table
- outdoor seating
- roasted chicken
- desserts
- bar
- (10 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Linda SongAugust 24, 2015It's no Maryland crab cake and the 'burger' in the title is misleading, but their crab cake burger (rather, sandwich) is really good!
- Linda SongAugust 24, 2015You don't expect it, but their coffee is absolutely delicious. I had to stop myself from pouring more! Hahaha would have been up all night!
This is a wonderful restaurant where the food is always good without pretense , smoked salmon platter oysters and the crab cakes , and for desert banana foster- Linda SongAugust 24, 2015Let's talk banana fosters. Wow. It looks heavy, but it's not a stomach killer at all. Just delicious caramelly goodness.
Travel + LeisureJune 14, 2012This red-brick Victorian hasn’t changed much since 1846. And that’s just how guests like it, with its faded elegance, backgammon tables in the lobby, and a bartender who will soon know your name.- The Corcoran GroupDecember 10, 2010Sit at the bar with Vinnie or Paul, grab a backgammon table in the front room, dine outside and watch the crowds, or host an intimate party in one of the private rooms.
- Stephen BSeptember 1, 2013Andres (and Dennis) are great waiters! Their service and the food made for a great night. Make sure to try the crab cakes
- Classic old style Americana , French cuisine from 20 years ago but really good and really nice wine list.
David TaylorJuly 31, 2017Lovely terrace to go with lovely food! Watch the cars and people as you enjoy a sandwich and a glass of rose.
Ellen AntonucciApril 14, 2013Great almonds at the bar. Roast chicken and the duck are highly recommended.
Rainbow LAApril 26, 2015Ask for Richard the Prince of Leonard street during the day. Have a Davidoff 6000 while playing Backgammon with the Wasps, take a gander at cougars and gays.
An iconic spot in the Hamptons. Have a drink at the bar and play some backgammon. Say hi to Billy Joel for me.
Vanity FairDecember 7, 2012This storied bar has hosted book editor Robert Loomis, who prefers a hardy Jack Daniel’s on the rocks.- allie whiteAugust 4, 2013This place reeks of wealth. Super iconic, classy and old fashioned. Billy Joel is standing next to me.
Zina MalcolmAugust 12, 2011The salmon with chanterelle mushrooms was orgasmic! The service was amazing!
Some times people become mayor when they don't deserve to- Some people check in when they aren't even there yet
151 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 10:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 8:00 AM–10:00 PM
(631) 725-3535
See More
You might also like
- 8.4
"Great spot for afternoon drinks with live band and fun people watching of the pool"
Charlottes - 7.3
"Clean & newly Renovated. Waterfront rooms w views of marina & sunset"
Robert S - 7.0
"Anything from the wood burning oven. The cauliflower, the octopus, the branzino , the ribs, the pizzas. And brunch is insanely good here!"
Jenny R
Places people like to go after American Hotel
- 7.7
"Tasting menu during off season, amazing deal!!! Sunday - Thursday... Must try!"
JeSsiCa 🐳 Miranda - 7.7
"Great local dive bar. A must in Sag Harbor."
Daniel McDonough - 7.6
"Tuna burger is fantastic! Great service & delicious food. Soft drinks for kids doesn't include apple juice. They'll charge you for it."
Eric Black
Appears on 61 lists
Corcoran's Most Popular In The Hamptons MegaList
Created by The Corcoran Group
34 items • 101 followersT+L's Insider's Guide to the Hamptons
Created by Travel + Leisure
77 items • 261 followers
NY Region Old-Timey Bars, Cafes, and Restaurants
Created by Buford Barnes
139 items • 92 followers
