Hubbard Avenue Diner
Diner$$$$
Downtown Middleton, Middleton
"Their black bean burger is one of the best veggie burgers"(2 Tips)"And they have a huge selection of pie to order"(2 Tips)
"Try their shakes, and - of course - their pies!"(38 Tips)
"Love the Meatloaf of the Gods!"(3 Tips)
72 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pies
- breakfast food
- desserts
- milkshakes
- lively
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Lindsay GronewoldMarch 14, 2016I always bring my out of town guests here for atleast 1 meal. Always busy but worth the wait. Everything is good, service is awesome. The coconut creme pie is to die for! 50's diner atmosphere, we luv
Cassie StutzJanuary 3, 2017The chicken dumpling was fantastic and the lemonade tasted like real lemonade. However, the chicken salad, though good, reminded me of chicken Waldorf with its grapes and walnuts in the salad.
Jeff OrdunoOctober 13, 2013Coconut cream pie is excellent. Not the normal bit of coconut with lots of filling. This pie is full of shredded coconut. So it's flavorful and not crazy sweet.
- Ally MDecember 20, 2015Love this diner - good food at good prices. Try their shakes, and - of course - their pies!
- Ally MJuly 22, 2015You can't miss their milkshakes - they give you every last bit that they make! The biscuit that comes with it is delicious as well.
Fallon CampbellOctober 18, 2015Great variety. Great comfort food. Got a bloody mary and it was great! Meatloaf and pot roast are always good.
Great food from scratch! And you get lots of it. Amazing baked goods, pies. Throwback 50s diner look.
Eve CNovember 11, 2012My server John was awesome in dealing with my food allergies! Very thorough and did it with a smile. Talked to the chefs for me and everything
Susannah BrooksNovember 7, 2010Here's what you do: go to Vin Santo for dinner, then here for pie. Sure, they have great desserts, and Hubbard Ave has tasty dinners, but in combination they make for one outstanding evening.
Joe SheppardMarch 1, 2015Delicious milkshakes and a Mac n Cheese plate to die for. Can't ask for much more than that!
Morgan R. TurnerAugust 21, 2018I personally like the classic diner food so the burgers are a favorite but pie is a must after.
Steve YoungMarch 27, 2022The pies are *good, not great* and the other food is decent without being truly good. This restaurant is pretty overhyped.
Michelle HinrichsDecember 3, 2015Delicious food and desserts. Meatloaf is always a good choice. Cheese cakes ! Yum! :)
Best pie. Best BLTs. Love everything about this place. Gotta try the applesauce and waffle fries.
Have a cup of coffee while you wait to be seated! Coffee is over to the right by the ice cream cooler.
Samantha McGrandyJuly 26, 2023I had a chicken sandwich that was pretty terrible and I couldn’t get past the first bite. The hash browns were undercooked but I was told that the omelet is pretty good as are the pies.
Kim GFebruary 10, 2012A great place for a fresh made pie! Perfect place for a cozy breakfast with a friend!
If it's December and you didn't order a slice of Candy Cane Pie or Gingerbread Pie, you may want to seek out medical attention!
Try the fried chicken - #excellent #delicious #comfort_food #comfortfood
Great food and very friendly service. Even if busy, very good people
- gail.October 27, 2015Wide selection of pies stocked on a daily basis, so there's something to fit any mood.
Get a slice of pie. I've tried several flavors and most of them are incredible!
Jessica UnderwoodDecember 27, 2011If you don't have time to wait for a table at lunch, offer to sit at the bar. Quick service.
Greg SchmidtMay 14, 2011It can get busy quick, so prepare to wait, but the food is worth it! Their homemade biscuits rock!
Everyone recommends pie, but the food is great, too. I recommend the mac n cheese or fried chicken (Saturdays).
Eat your pie first (the meal can always be eaten after and leftovers taken home)!
Chocolate cheesecake and Key Lime pie....to die for!!
Alex DaviesApril 24, 2012Be sure to visit the National Mustard Museum next door. You won't be disappointed!
Cold Hash Browns. Medium eggs were hard. Kitchen needs to try harder.
- James BartlettOctober 20, 2017Food was excellent. Coffee tasted like boiled coal. Orange juice was thick, but tasted like water.
JasonJuly 25, 2010Good food, but you have to try a slice of pie. There's just no excuse not to. And very kid friendly.
148 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 9:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 7:00 AM–9:00 PM
- Fri
- 7:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Sat
- 7:30 AM–10:00 PM
- Sun
- 7:30 AM–9:00 PM
(608) 831-7437
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Dining Options
Table Service
Parking
Street, Private Lot
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert
Drinks
Beer, Wine
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Hubbard Avenue Diner
- 8.3
"Very interesting place. Tons of unique mustards. Their house honey mustard is very good."
Daniel Sprehe - 8.4
"Great store with different selection than in the South. We enjoyed our quick look and purchased some nice fall clothes that we do not see in FLA."
Omi B. - 8.2
"I really love it here. I can always find something cute to wear."
Maria Pflugradt
Appears on 37 lists
Created by Foursquare City Guide
50 items • 222 followers
Created by Rachel Kantosky
12 items • 1 follower
Favorite Eating and Drinking Places
Created by Alice Ferris
88 items • 8 followers
