"Started with mixed green salad followed by the rigatoni siciliana."(4 Tips)
"The chocolate mousse dessert is delicious."(2 Tips)
"Excellent chicken parm and home made pasta"(2 Tips)
"Risotto: mushrooms and TRUFFLE OIL: Delicious and..."(2 Tips)
38 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- good for dates
- chicken parmigiana
- wine
- risotto
- polenta
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- Nak BratApril 26, 2015Service was great, the food was good. Started with mixed green salad followed by the rigatoni siciliana. Nice wine selection as well. Finished with tiramisu and an espresso shot. Went home happy
FaithJanuary 6, 2013A calm, intimate atmosphere that makes you forget the bustling city is right outside its soft lite decor. Spectacular staff, & even more spectacular food! This whole place gave the true Italian feel!- FaithJanuary 6, 2013Get the "Your mother's eggplant parm" dish and substitute the spaghetti for penne with pink vodka sauce. It was unbelievable! The staff is happy to prepare exactly what you want!!
HolidayDecember 9, 2018Disappointed they were out of Long Island oysters but waiter made it up to me with an extra glass of wine. Spaghetti with red sauce and classic chicken parmigiana lunch specials were amazing.- FaithJanuary 6, 2013I literally stumbled on the place and went in on a limb not knowing what to expect. I can truly say it exceeded any expectations and blew my mind! Loved it!
- Lee HoffmanJune 2, 2017Excellent chicken parm and home made pasta - at the sister location 44th st at least
Terry SFebruary 15, 2013Pollo parmigiana with spaghetti pomodoro was AMAZING. VERY large piece of chicken. Perfect. Very romantic atmosphere. Two thumbs up.
Maritza MatzJuly 18, 2016Great service! They cared all the times about us. Food was amazing. Best quattro formaggi sauce ever!
Janice PersonJune 19, 2012Get dessert - my 16 yr old nephew says the chocolate mousse cake has ruined all future chocolate desserts for him. He took time to savor each bite & write his first yelp review ever,- Will GarréJune 28, 2012Nice portion size. Not too much. Great bread. Bread is a little sweet. The chocolate mousse dessert is delicious.
loran jonakJune 24, 2015Delicious food! Small restaurant, so if you don't have a reservation, get there by 6.
Tom NawaraMarch 28, 2012The lamb shank with house made polenta was amazing. Service was top notch. Really enjoyed our visit.
MichaelNovember 14, 2012The seafood special with clams and shrimp and fresh handmade spinach pasta was amazing.
Heather CMay 4, 2015Went with a party of 6, decent food & wine for the area. My Mom & I both ordered decaf coffee. We were both up all night - decaf served was definitely not decaf. Be careful!
- Valentina MonteFebruary 16, 2012Risotto: mushrooms and TRUFFLE OIL: Delicious and perfect, add sautéed shrimp!
Leonard WeinbergJanuary 27, 2013Food was very good, however the roasted vegetables were returned as they were burnt! Second time they were very good.
Jenny Soo HooFebruary 13, 2013Free bruschetta along with an assorted bread basket. Mushroom risotto wasn't great
Leslie DavidsonApril 1, 2012Order the pollo parmiaganna...absolutely delicious and a huge portion too!
Ami AquinoAugust 21, 2011Avoid the gnocchi but try the tortellini or rigatoni and vodka sauce. Great atmosphere.
Brian MichaelJuly 12, 2014Baked clams were tiny with underwhelming taste and served on a huge plate. Rigatoni was served with basically frozen chicken. Cheesecake was one of the worst I've ever had.
- Cristina DiazApril 19, 2017Buen italiano en Hell's kitchen. Tienen menú de medio día y por la noche. Se pueden compartir. Hablan español. 20$ pp aprox
63 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Cara Mia is in the heart of the theater district and specializes in homemade pastas, meats, and seafood dishes. Cara Mia features a magical combination of Italian cuisine and the finest wine selection.
Closed until Noon (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- Noon–11:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- Noon–Midnight
(212) 262-6767
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Drinks
Wine, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 7.7
"awesome ambience, great cocktail list and amazing food. you must get the rosemary wings when you go here"
Caroline Le - 5.7
"Great bartenders and staff, generous pours, always friendly, and have an awesome happy hour. brunch on weekends is out of this world."
Jonathan Homan - 8.0
"The 2-for-1 martini special is awesome, favorites are blood orange, passion fruit, and French. Great vibe and atmosphere for having a drink and conversation with someone. Their food is solid too."
Gail Amurao
Places people like to go after Cara Mia
- 8.8
"Every cookie is phenomenal. Favorites include key lime, red velvet, blueberry cobbler, sea-salt/chocolate. The coffee is also really good."
Vivek Pradhan - 8.5
"Great place for a unique NYC experience; full of colorful screens, restaurants, famous shops, Broadway shows, and street shows. Place for souvenirs. No1 place to see in NYC! A-must-see."
Murat - 8.8
"$4 sangria and you can bring it to your seat! Cheers!"
Susan Wallach
Appears on 37 lists
Created by Katrin Forslund
58 items • 1 follower
Created by Juan Seguí
21 items • 1 followerThe 20 best value restaurants in New York, NY
Created by Quinn M. Bass
10 items • 2 followers
