See all
27 photos

Paul & Jimmy's

Italian Restaurant$$$$

Gramercy Park, New York

Save

Paul & Jimmy's

6.1^/10

ratings

"Kind of a cute place but damn the service can be slow..."(2 Tips)
"Pasta Primavera to die for :-)"(5 Tips)

17 Tips and reviews

Filter:

primavera
pasta
wine
dinner
liquor

Sort:

Popular
Recent

P. D.September 3, 2019
Makes you work hard to draw out its charms, but they are there for the right perspective, w a little patience on hand. New York used to have many more such neighborhood joints...cherish this one.
Alison MJune 28, 2013
The pre-fixe was amazing! Go for that at lunch time
Ben MartinezFebruary 26, 2017
I had the shrimp risotto. Quality is okay but the shrimp portion is large. Service was a lot better for me than others have reported on a Saturday night.
Michael G.January 30, 2022
Old school Italian with an enticing prix fixe menu. But don’t ask for substitutions or alterations!
Evan McPheeApril 19, 2019
Drinks pretty good, but everything pretty expensive. Had the frutti de mare, which was... a little bit less than “fine”, I guess?
Charles ThomasJune 29, 2013
Great food reasonably priced. Service fell short, felt rushed in an not full restaurant
Nelson VegaSeptember 20, 2014
Been here 50+ times
Amazing pasta
Dillon I HorowitzJuly 23, 2021
They have a good ragu
Megan MastersJuly 30, 2013
Service was slow, my ravioli was al dente (raw), but the place is super cute ...
Annesa LauJuly 15, 2010
appertizer portions avail for all their pasta dishes... =) great for a summer diet!
Peter ElbaorApril 14, 2013
Service sucks. I've never received so much crap from a waiter. He shrugs at us 'so you wanna drink?' Having not yet given a wine list. Forgets about us for 20 mins then totally abandons my table
JengaMarch 11, 2011
Pasta Primavera to die for :-)
Kathleen CheeversDecember 16, 2014
This place is horrible. Don't waste your money. Over priced, not authentic Italian, cheesy decor. Perfect for Kitchen nightmares w Ramsey.
Darrell WhitelawDecember 9, 2011
How was this place not able to get my prix fixe dinner served in NINETY minutes.
William ScanlanSeptember 11, 2011
Great meal!!
Kevin TDecember 10, 2011
Kind of a cute place but damn the service can be slow...
Lisa ShawMay 25, 2010
Been here 50+ times
Gnocchi sorrentino osfoos.

27 Photos

Paul & Jimmy's

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Paul & Jimmy's

Appears on 20 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.