See all
41 photos

Montauk Seafood Grill

Seafood Restaurant$$$$

Vail

Save

7.7^/10

ratings

"Never pass on Sand Pie for dessert."(2 Tips)
"The Ahi Seared Tuna is about the best you will ever have."(3 Tips)
"The halibut is to die for."(2 Tips)
"You must try the dungeoness crab and the kumomoto oysters."(2 Tips)

19 Tips and reviews

Filter:

seafood
sand pie
great value
good service
desserts
duck
swordfish
slaw
dinner
(4 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

lauren wellsSeptember 3, 2012
Amazing seafood flown in daily from hawaii. Ahi tuna is the signature dish. Best Ahi we've ever had!
Susie HuxfordNovember 14, 2013
An oldie but a goodie. We love Montauk in our family. The Ahi Seared Tuna is about the best you will ever have. The seafood is always cooked and grilled to perfection. Rarely is any food sent back.
Alexandre MOAH OgataApril 23, 2012
Very good Restaurant!Ordered the Grilles Hawaiian Swordfish, and it was very good! The appetizers (calamaris and mussels) were good...And the off-season price is honest! hehe
David StreetFebruary 12, 2023
The seafood tower was excellent, very fresh, very good service. Great values on the wine list.
Stevan PopovicAugust 19, 2014
Great food, but you do pay your price for it. Worth it if you are treating someone
Carie L KounalisSeptember 21, 2013
The food was fantastic. The sirloin steak was amazing!!
Ross HendersonMarch 25, 2011
Food always on point! The slaw is great! I had the yellow fin and the duck, both are recommend!
RebelFebruary 18, 2021
Everything is so delicious !
Jessica CummingFebruary 25, 2011
One of my favorites in Vail. You must try the dungeoness crab and the kumomoto oysters.
David BetrasMarch 12, 2013
The halibut is to die for. Ask for Kalee as a server.
Meredith C.March 15, 2011
Tuna sashimi tar tar cold app is enough for an entree and delish!
SvetlanaFebruary 6, 2014
Chilien salmon from the grill!!! Mmmmm delicious)
Matt LafoneJanuary 1, 2012
Honestly it was fair at best. Oyster Rockefeller came out way over cooked. New York strip had a very bland sauce and covered up the flavor of the meet. Service was good but I would not come back.
Anders HallinJune 9, 2016
Great food and great service!
Amanda CarrollJuly 2, 2022
My halibut was extremely lacking in flavor. The rest of the menu looks intriguing though.
Kevin CostelloApril 16, 2011
Do not miss the Sand Pie. Best desert anywhere!
Christine FiedorowiczJune 26, 2013
Get the scallops. Period.
Chad ArangoApril 3, 2011
Go for the duck, you won't regret it.
Lauren KlostermannJune 13, 2010
Never pass on Sand Pie for dessert.

41 Photos

Montauk Seafood Grill

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Montauk Seafood Grill

Appears on 12 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.