See all
364 photos

Brooklyn Diner

Diner and American Restaurant$$$$

Theater District, New York

Save

Brooklyn Diner

7.0^/10

365

ratings

Has a stamp of approval from Village Voice and The Corcoran Group
"... is good, it's a bit expensive but great portions!"(14 Tips)
"Chinese chicken salad was amazing & huge!"(4 Tips)
"Very tasty Chicken Pot Pie, stromgly recommended..."(5 Tips)
"Love the smoked bacon and frizzled onions on a big, juicy burger."(17 Tips)

105 Tips and reviews

Filter:

breakfast food
burgers
cheesecake
French toast
pancakes
brunch food
casual
polenta
chicken
meats
milkshakes
good for a quick meal
chili
big portions
hash
eggs
coffee
sausage
restaurants
turkey
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Village VoiceApril 9, 2015
The towering bacon cheeseburger is a must. And be sure to savor the flaky, thick-cut onion rings on or off your burger. The kitchen only makes enough each day to put two on every plate.
Upvoted 3 days ago
ImSo_BrooklynAugust 23, 2014
I love how they make the old fashioned drink. My favorite. The food could be better especially for the prices they're for. But it's not a bad place in the middle of Times Square!
Dan WoodsNovember 11, 2011
The Mixed Marriage, a savory french toast with egg inside, tomato sauce, sausage, and deep fried polenta is a candidate for best breakfast meal in Manhattan. The BD opens at 8AM, too late for me.
ClaudioMarch 24, 2015
The pastrami burger was so good! Also love the cheesecake with strawberry on top
DivinityDecember 13, 2011
The tables are right on top of each other, maybe about 12 inches in between you & the table next to you. Despite the close quarters, we had breakfast & dinner & were quite satisfied with both
Sheila RodriguezMay 28, 2016
I had the French toast and it was amazing.. General manager Richard Sanchez was an awesome person, looking out for our table and very prevent
Kimmie OhhJuly 4, 2020
They’re in the middle of Times Square so expect them to be pricey. Splurge on a slice of cheesecake or chocolate blackout cake!
Kat BaylissSeptember 5, 2013
Shrimp and avocado salad is so fresh and delicious! Also had the cheesecake and it melts in your mouth.
Andrea ClaeyssenMay 20, 2012
Pretty good food a little expensive but delish...most def the freshest burger I have ever had and not greasy either I was amazed at the quality of it
HollyJuly 18, 2017
Kugel, yum-yum!! Turkey Ruben and pastrami Ruben were great, nice thick cuts of meat.
Jessica AngelesDecember 20, 2013
Fanciest diner I've ever been to. You MUST try the Chicken Pot Pie here before you die. Best I've ever known.
Lori BirkmeyerJuly 15, 2014
We had breakfast there and the food was very good! Pancakes with fresh strawberries were delicious
Emilio MoralesMarch 4, 2019
Great service! The breakfast was huge and tasty!
Saad AlJune 24, 2013
In my 1st time in Manhattan I asked the concierge about McDonald to charge the battery before exploring she refused to tell me any place but this, & still feel thankful to her for delicious food😌🙏
Frank RimalovskiMay 26, 2012
Really good, but pricey upscale diner in midtown West. Chinese chicken salad was amazing & huge! (4 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
Rosie LammogliaAugust 15, 2013
Excellent breakfast. A bit pricey, but so worth it. Had great looking desserts... Maybe after a show next time!
Loiane GronerOctober 3, 2013
Great cheeseburger and amazing cheesecake! Big portions - good to share if you don't eat that much.
The Corcoran GroupJanuary 7, 2011
A very upscale and expensive diner. Give the Coney Island Lobster Roll a try. The Open Faced Ruben is good as are all the desserts. Not kid friendly.
TV Food MapsJune 10, 2015
Check out Brooklyn Diner as it was featured on Guilty Pleasures for Robert Irvine recommends the strawberry cheesecake. Read more
Jade ArnoldSeptember 24, 2012
The new York times rated the fried Mac and cheese for a reason. Tastes even better with a nice glass of Brooklyn Oktoberfest
Mine YorukJanuary 20, 2017
Ambiance is great. People working there are friendly. Food is mediocre, actually tipping the scale to "bad". How can one go wrong even with French Fries. I've never seen soggy French fries in the US
Shauna LMarch 22, 2014
A bit pricey for a diner ;) but the food was damn good! And so is there 3 layer coconut cake
Sergio Rodriguez LDecember 31, 2012
American Kitchen met New York style. Try the cheeseburger and the chicken soup. Expensive but totally worthy!
Dan LunerJuly 7, 2013
Chicken Pot Pie is fantastic. Overall, a little expensive for a diner, but worth it.
Christina ChinMay 14, 2022
Burger is pretty good albeit time sq pricey. For a diner, doesn't have dinner prices...its a theme restaurant
Mark CurtisDecember 1, 2011
Chinese chicken salad was delish. Waitress was a delight. Two thumbs up. Much better than expected for times square diner.
Dennis MoyJanuary 19, 2012
17.5% gratuity added for 5+ and a 5.00 charge for sharing. Expensive but good food. Due to prices it should be called Brooklyn Restaurant rather than Brooklyn Diner.
FoodiesprNovember 13, 2016
Cheeseburger was a little disappointing no flavor in the meat at all but the Bronx Pale Ale save the night!
Rose D.November 16, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Cheeseburgers are great. Love the smoked bacon and frizzled onions on a big, juicy burger. Plus you get a ton of crispy shoestring fries :)
Mike GilmourDecember 1, 2013
Food was good, staff were good, but c'mon guys, no Wi-Fi? It's 2013! The cell reception inside is pretty bad so you definitely need Wi-Fi. Especially if you're trying to attract us tourists!
Brad SlavinMay 21, 2013
A bit pricy, but... Chicken salad sandwich was great. Chunky pulled chicken, with crisp bacon and thousand island dressing. Fries were awesome too
Humberto PelaezNovember 1, 2014
One of my favorite stops everytime Im in town! Always good service and good food
DebraMarch 22, 2015
Great food and service close to the action
Jose NaninFebruary 17, 2017
Excellent service!! Pastrami hash was amazing!
Glen GilmoreJanuary 11, 2014
Try the Israeli Breakfast. Tasty!
IbtisamDecember 31, 2013
I don't recommend! food tastes eh; was FULL of garlic! It's a diner, but acts like a gourmet restaurant? I don't get it! waiters and staff were polite, friendly and serve with a smile. Not yummy food
Erin AllweinApril 22, 2012
The Chinese chicken salad is delicious! Well worth every penny...ate every bite!
Chris PolloneJune 20, 2014
Despite the name, this is not a "greasy spoon" diner. It charges high prices for food that doesn't match other upscale spots. Avoid the stuffed trout. Caprese salad is good.
Kelly HillOctober 14, 2011
They have the most amazing French toast! Cinnamon, raisins, pecans, topped with powdered sugar and fresh strawberries. Absolutely to die for!
Ömer G.September 10, 2013
Very tasty Chicken Pot Pie, stromgly recommended...
Eduardo MekitarianDecember 5, 2013
Food presentation and taste were good. But absolutely pricey. Spaghetti with meatballs came in a small portion and much spicy. 12.95 for a very little portion of mac'n cheese. Not worthy the price.
Joseph BanegasNovember 4, 2011
The spaghetti and meatball 'de la nonna' is to die for! Italian home style!
Lauren DubeDecember 27, 2012
Wonder wonderful service :) best I've ever had! Definitely worth coming here!
Rick AtherleyJanuary 27, 2019
the eggs Benedict were ok. I also ordered fruit plate. the bananas look brown and old 😒
FoodiesprNovember 13, 2016
This place is more for desserts and coffee!
Jamal AnthonyJune 29, 2013
Great service, very friendly, Food is good, it's a bit expensive but great portions!
Kevin VaughnAugust 18, 2014
Great for a late night burger but a bit over-priced.
Tara CallaghanMay 23, 2011
Pizza is huge - good for sharing! Great pizza, great burgers and great shakes :)
Patricia LockeMarch 16, 2012
Get the lamb burger. Pizza also yummy. Great for kids.
Richard FrenchJuly 15, 2013
Eggs over medium, sausage and polenta is awesome.

1 2 3

364 Photos

Brooklyn Diner

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Brooklyn Diner

Appears on 134 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.