Croxley's Ale House
Bar, Wings Joint, and American Restaurant$$$$
Farmingdale
"10 cent wings on certain nights Menu"(8 Tips)
"From Isles fan @pangus86: "Best choice of beers and wings.""(3 Tips)
"Great beer selection and atmosphere!"(8 Tips)
"Charged 20% tip during wing specials"(4 Tips)
87 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- chicken wings
- beer
- pretzels
- happy hour
- TVs
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Ginu ThomasJuly 7, 2013Great wings and great venue to watch a game! A lot of space at this Croxleys makes it a good place to bring a few friends without feeling crowded
Katie TuohyNovember 25, 2014Do yourself a favor and try a po'boy the best time you're there. It's not authentic, but it's really delicious. Also, Croxley's has the best fries I've ever had at a bar.
Ava AdamsNovember 6, 2012Mon tues wed 10cent wings so good but......you have to get two drinks sit at the bar or you will get charged for service. Also if you can finish the wings on your plate they cost 60cents to bring home
Half these tips are bullshit. Dont be an ass and u wont get served like one. Good wings and great beer. Outdoor seating with open air bar. First stop for main street hoppin!
George AndriopoulosSeptember 9, 2023Not my typical scene but I’ve never really been disappointed here. Good drinks, good food. A little crowded at times but that’s probably the old man in me talking. A definite win for Farmingdale.
Paul HarrisJuly 10, 2014So many beers to choose from. I dare you to count that high. It may take a few hours, Yeag it's that good...and can't go wrong with ten cent wings!!!!
Jessica PalladinoMay 15, 2015The Bavarian pretzel is huge & delicious, try it with a side of cheese sauce!
Tim BackusAugust 14, 2016Great beer selection and a nice atmosphere no matter what time: from lunch to late night- Jessica PalladinoMay 15, 2015Great selection of beers on tap, ask for a menu - they include the alcohol percentages on them 🍻
So many great craft beers can be found here. One more thing, ask for Adam at the bar.
Excellent craft beers. A must try bar if you are a beer aficionado, an alcoholic, or both.
Consistent bar food with a great selection of tap beers. Damn good wings!!
Robert RotondoApril 13, 2012go in at 12noon on sunday during football season, they always have a different beer every sunday for free for til 1pm kichoff
tara umlandMarch 17, 2013You would think a place that serves a lot of beers on tap would know how to serve it without so much foam on top- NewsdayJanuary 13, 2014There are more than 80 lagers and ales are on draft at Croxley's Ale House & Biergarten.
- Talesof theTattSeptember 26, 2014Their Chicken Pot Pie is awesome!!! a must have on a cold football day.
Great selection of beers on tap. Plus delicious wings and good music!
There's a list of rules about ordering wings. You cannot bring any home, and during wing specials your table is charged a 20% service few. The wings suck and me and my friend were both shorted on ours
Good place to hang if you don’t mind noisy and congestion.- Dawn OAugust 24, 2011Charged 20% tip during wing specials, even when ordering sandwiches & waitress disappeared. Surprise charge for curly & sweet potato fries.Blackened Cajun chicken was plain piece of chicken on a roll.
Michael KFebruary 12, 2012Good food, sometimes pricey depending on what you get.... great brewery selection! =]
Shivone LatortueJune 13, 2010this place is sickkk in the summer. never tried so many different beers before i came here. staff was really nice and generous w/the wings
Remember to park on Main Street or in the Back Lot! My friend and myself have gotten hit with parking tickets because we dont have a town sticker
One of the worst ladies restrooms in Long Island. I go to the bar across the street to use the bathroom. If they care about their female customers at all it should have been redone by now.
Michael Steven WilliamsSeptember 22, 2013Awesome place for good beer, good service, good food and the UFC fights!
Their Croxleys pumpkin ale was awesome! A must have!
Wing specials are good but watch out because they add a 20% service charge to the entire check when you partake
Danny ByunNovember 17, 2015Wings are good but watch out for the bogus tip guide on the bill. Calculate 20% of total bill and its nowhere close to actual amount.
Explore Long IslandJanuary 27, 2013We reviewed Croxley's Ale House and our critics enjoyed the classic pairing of beers and wings. Read more
If you get Shannon as your waitress....proceed with caution.
Tvs everywhere, good food, tons of great beers. Not many specials tho at least not advertised in bar.
Clarisse BaluyotApril 17, 2012Awesome wings. Brother ordered them extra crispy, honey BBQ flavored and they were superb!
LennyOctober 18, 2011Decent wings... Great variety of beers.....better than average bar to watch sports....
- Jason BaumanApril 18, 201210c wings is a crock of shit now. they require you spend $7.20 for 10 wings!
Curt UmlandMarch 17, 2013Most disgusting pint of Smithwick I ever had. Insanely over carbonated. I can't believe I paid six bucks for this. Much better and cheaper bars in farmingdale
229 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
New York's Original Ale House & Eatery, Craft Beer, Wings, Sports
Open until 3:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- Noon–3:00 AM
(516) 293-7700
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 6.5
"Mike is the man great bartender. Great food. Way better than the black wolf sports bar the inn between actually has a respectable customer base unlike the wolf"
John Leidl - 7.6
"Monday nights are good. John and Ayla know how to make some good drinks!"
William Wohlsen 
"gotta touch the pool table the right way if you want it to work. fun crowds and music! just don’t mind some of the patrons have missing teeth 🤣"
Alexis Morisi
Places people like to go after Croxley's Ale House
- 7.3
"The Nutty Irishman offers various food and drink specials nightly, along with live music and DJ events, sports packages for game viewing, plus karaoke on Wednesdays."
Newsday - 6.4
"Spilt a combo platter appetizer to try their wings, mozzarella sticks, and potato skins and they were all pretty good. Nice selection of beers on tap. Pretty nice place overall."
Jason M.
Appears on 45 lists
Created by beermarkapp
36 items • 15 followers
Fan-fave spots to catch the #Isles on TV
Created by NY Islanders
36 items • 28 followersCreated by Erin Caner
32 items • 33 followers
