See all
55 photos

Don Pepi Pizza

Pizzeria$$$$

Chelsea, New York

Save

Don Pepi Pizza

6.9^/10

ratings

"Best pizza in Penn station & good pizza in general"(2 Tips)
"train station pizza has a right"(2 Tips)
"If you have more time, NY Pizza Suprema on 8th is better."(3 Tips)
"The best place to stop for a sub when leaving the city."(4 Tips)

27 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
delis
sub sandwiches
trains
beer
city
meats
well
(3 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Julio GomezMay 3, 2013
Been here 50+ times
Frankly I think it's the best plain slice of New York style pizza in the whole city. I have other choices for brick oven or whatever but for a classic NY slice? Can't beat it.
Upvoted 2 days ago
Chris R (thechristophe)December 20, 2015
Best pizza in Penn station, New York style slices, plenty of vegetarian options. Quick and takeout available.
Brook ShelleyJune 4, 2015
This slice rules - it's way better than any train station pizza has a right to be, and is one of the better slices I've had in NYC. I got a pepperoni and a sausage - my friend got a plain - all 3 A+
Dan HoodAugust 8, 2013
You can take the escalators up to the corner of 33rd and 8th to get a far superior slice at NY Pizza Suprema. Don Pepi is more than acceptable if you are pressed for time though.
David DJanuary 1, 2013
Been here 5+ times
The "only" place inside Penn Station that makes their pizza fresh... That said it is the BEST and their deli is great too.
Rob VernonMay 1, 2016
Great pizza on the go. Always grab a slice (or two) when heading to the train.
Nick LeeApril 12, 2015
Very good NY-style pizza. If you have more time, NY Pizza Suprema on 8th is better.
RachelDecember 31, 2014
Good pizza! Very quick if you just want to grab a slice on the run!
Rebecca GMay 12, 2016
Best pizza in Penn station & good pizza in general
paul capelliApril 16, 2015
How can you move through Penn Station without stopping for a quick slice? Always well worth it...oops, there goes my train
Susan RellaMay 31, 2012
Nicest lady ever. Apologetic if they're out of anything, always gives me mustard with my $1.50 pretzel, and just generally sweet as sin.
A Victor (SU-3) Murray, IIIAugust 25, 2019
Best pizza I’ve had in years. Cheesy, crisp crust and not burnt.
chris vaglioMarch 19, 2012
Best value in the city, 2 slices and a beer under $10. A must before any game!!!!
Will WetzelNovember 5, 2011
Two eggs on the breakfast sandwich. The best place to stop for a sub when leaving the city.
David KirschMay 7, 2018
Your first or last pizza stop depending upon whether you’re coming or going. Solid.
Terence ChanFebruary 25, 2018
Not a bad place to grab a quick few slices before hopping on the train 3.5/5
Serious EatsJuly 24, 2013
Not the best pizza in the neighborhood, but fine for a quick fix if you're stuck in Penn Station.
Michael PerkinsMarch 23, 2016
Pepperoni Pizza is as good as any in NYC
Rich C.April 9, 2012
Excellent Roast Beef, VERY rare! Just order the number 2!
m. le gagaMay 15, 2014
Nice, but at $3 for a plain slice, it ain't worth it. Setting a bad trend
Diana VictorOctober 28, 2011
Fast, greasy and delicious. Big slices.
Nikki St. ickisNovember 8, 2011
Best pizza in the city for years love this place!
Katie KDecember 12, 2011
Decent pizza for Penn Station. Nicely crispy crusts!
Kelly BoneAugust 20, 2011
It's train station pizza... you know what you're getting yourself into...
JMSFebruary 10, 2012
Super nice woman running the place.
Pedro Luiz Amorim PereiraJanuary 20, 2018
Não se engane por estar em uma estação de trem. Eu acho as pizzas daqui uma das melhores de NYC.
TracieSeptember 14, 2011
Always deliciulous.

55 Photos

Don Pepi Pizza

Related Searches

Other places inside New York Penn Station

You might also like

Places people like to go after Don Pepi Pizza

Appears on 18 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.