See all
653 photos

Connolly's Pub & Restaurant

Irish Pub and Restaurant$$$$

Theater District, New York

Save

7.2^/10

599

ratings

Ranked #8 for a rooftop in the Theater District
"The shepherd's pie and fish and chips are great!"(7 Tips)
"upstairs bartender with the Irish accent"(3 Tips)
"The rooftop deck is to die for on a nice weather night!"(7 Tips)
"The chicken pot pie is delicious!!"(4 Tips)

111 Tips and reviews

Filter:

rooftop
beer
bangers and mash
irish accent
happy hour
pies
live music
casual
meats
Irish stew
cider
breakfast food
fish
good for dates
breweries
dancing
wraps
good for a quick meal
desserts
dinner
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Heineken USAugust 20, 2014
Family owned and operated, Connolly's offers a welcoming staff and relaxed atmosphere in the heart of Times Square. It's a nice place to enjoy a traditional Irish pub experience while watching a game.
Bogdan GunaSeptember 3, 2015
One of my favourite bars in nyc. Large range of international beers, good for chill outs and a few beers with your lads.
Michelle ManderFebruary 22, 2014
Fish and chips were yummy. All staff uses an Irish accent- great touch. Cole slaw was a little sour, not sure if it went bad. Country music weird & didn't seem to fit. But overall a fun atmosphere!
Upvoted Mar 22
Steve PolandDecember 14, 2018
Shepherds pie was good. Pretzels appetizer was great- super fluffy! Great spot to grab a Guinness.
Kaitlyn PezikMay 10, 2015
I was definitely skeptical to come here due to its proximity to Times Square, but was pleasantly surprised. great food and drinks, and there's a rooftop!
Richard FerretteDecember 21, 2018
They try to send you to the restaurant next door because Connolly’s was crowded, we stuck it out and waited (only 10 minutes). Glad we did the food and atmosphere were great. Try the fish and chips.
Cindy OlMarch 17, 2018
Great Irish Stew with mashed potatoes on top. And awesome, patient helpful team on board for St. Patricks Day.
James RobertsonDecember 15, 2018
Place is always packed and full of a lot of fun people. I’ve only had drinks here but everything looked good.
ThelocaltripperSeptember 2, 2017
Great selection of beers. The shepherd's pie and fish and chips are great!
Jennifer WheelerOctober 4, 2013
Loved the food but a soda is $3 with no free refills. My kid drank $9 just in soda.
Mary BossardAugust 12, 2014
Great service, berry attentive and food came in good timing, and tasted great. This is a nice chill spot
Jessica RomanJanuary 9, 2013
Denny (Danny?) the upstairs bartender with the Irish accent was GREAT! Oh, and order the Irish Cider on tap--Mcguires--yum :)
DoubleDeuceMarch 19, 2017
Typical Midtown Irish Pub. Good service, lots of space, the Midtown work crowd all around, just as you would expect.
The Corcoran GroupApril 13, 2011
Get the chicken pot pie with a side of fries but be careful, it's incredibly hot! Sit upstairs and people watch on the streets below.
Christophe Van der LindenJuly 23, 2013
40 beers on tap, including Groene Duvel and Chimay! Nice rooftop bar.
Jeeleighanne DuboiusSeptember 16, 2016
Roof top!!!! I had the best calamari I've had in a while here! Very very very nice!
Yousef GoefukMay 24, 2012
The Shepard's pie is good but a bit small. If you're really hungry have the bangers and mash, delicious! Service can be a bit slow.
JC EarleFebruary 2, 2010
Went here for an inter-celtic festival, 3rd Floor, the Klub 45 room. Guiness on tap and tasty Bailey's. I even got the chance to dance with some Irish, Scottish and Breton people :) Good food too!
Tom M.January 6, 2016
I recommend the bacon cheese burger, super good
Darren ReillyFebruary 1, 2016
The Guinness, the juke box. Barman could be nicer, least talkative Irishman I've met in a while
Dan MagnuszewskiJune 6, 2014
Hit up the 2nd and 3rd floors if you want to chill at the bar
Jes GutMay 6, 2012
The customer is not always right here. I didn't care for the curry and they wouldnt take it back. This is America, the customer can send back food. However the ruban was great!
Ryan WaltonAugust 13, 2013
The rooftop deck is to die for on a nice weather night! They all have Irish accents too!! Hahaha
Mike DubApril 11, 2014
Patrick the manager spoke and the food arrived extremely fast and accurate. I WILL BE BACK
Gus ClassApril 14, 2013
Stick to pub food and beer and you a will be happy. They have a decent shepherd's pie.
Mick JonejaJune 1, 2013
Great pub! Clean, authentic character, great staff & good food. Worth a visit
Jarel HillSeptember 13, 2017
That chicken pot pie is no joke. Fries are also perfectly crispy
SetonMarch 19, 2015
Good times. Lots of space but be careful on the stairs between floors!
RIT Alumni AssociationMarch 13, 2012
Please join us as students and faculty from both the Advertising Photography and Photojournalism programs from the School of Photographic Arts and Sciences come to NYC. http://bit.ly/yPKQB1
Jeff SolomonJune 6, 2017
Upstairs bar is good for watching sports with a decent beer list
Chuck MathusSeptember 23, 2014
Great taps and company
Gisela CbAugust 9, 2019
Good food, excellent service, clean and quick
Joanne HaasOctober 18, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Try the Shrimp & Avocado Wrap - My fave here
Joanne HaasJanuary 24, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Try the Shrimp & Avocado Wrap - Slight spice :)
leahAugust 6, 2012
Watch out for a bartender named Graham. His behavior toward women is criminal. He's pictured with that bottle of wild turkey that another foursquare user posted earlier in June of this year.
Alexis MillerJuly 13, 2011
Great food and awesome servers! The atmosphere is so fun, and the music was great!
Peter BrewerApril 13, 2011
My New York Realtor @Corcoran_ Group suggested the Chicken Hot Pie. I love them even more now!
Tina SammonAugust 21, 2016
Great for a drink and snack before the show
Joanne HaasFebruary 27, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Try the Appletini - #midtown #thursday pre show dinner and drinks
N MartinAugust 13, 2014
their CheeseSteak is awesome
Vinny AlessiOctober 2, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Izzy is the best bartender and Edia is right behind for second!
Sabrina BianchiMay 18, 2012
The grilled ginger tuna sammy is a... wait for it... mazing.
Karl With A "K"October 8, 2015
Mozzarella sticks are great, as is the service. #GoodTimes
Travis NicholsNovember 10, 2011
The Godzilla burger might be the best burger of all time
Matías SalvadorMarch 20, 2012
Wraps are great and irish sausage too!
Caroline R.August 30, 2011
Been here 100+ times
Great pub; good food and live music to boot!
Bubba ZanettiJuly 20, 2012
The chicken dumplings and a Reuben. 'nuff said.
Ben SApril 27, 2014
Food wasn't too bad. Skip the sangria. Service was fairly bad. Not sure when servers get a "break" and just leave their tables to wait...
Joanne HaasFebruary 27, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Try the Shrimp & Avocado Wrap
Laura HernandezFebruary 15, 2019
Galic hamburger

1 2 3

653 Photos

Connolly's Pub & Restaurant

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Connolly's Pub & Restaurant

Upcoming Events

Appears on 105 lists

Top places in the area

More from Connolly's

Is this your business? Claim it now.