Sal's Little Italy
(Now Closed)Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$
NoLita, New York
26 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Sal's Little ItalyApril 7, 2016Sal's hasn't last in NYC for nearly 40 decades for NOTHING. Still family owned/operated. Italian comfort food -- fried calzones and classic NY pizza. pizzeria (by the slice) & restaurant- Sal's Little ItalyApril 7, 2016Check out Sport Chaser app or
Erin MurphyMarch 20, 2015The fried calzone is like a calzone and zeppole in one. So good! The plain slice was pretty good but $3, sort of expensive.- Sal's Little ItalyApril 7, 2016If you check-in or reserve via YELP receive a FREE glass of house wine (ONE per checkin or reservation.) Dining room only.
Jason RiosFebruary 6, 2013Food and service were both great. If I'm in the neighborhood, I'll definitely give it another try.
Adriana ArtetaDecember 28, 2013Great pizza but if you're not famous the owner is rude and will dismiss you. #poorcustumerservice
Laurie D.October 26, 2013Standard slices. Nothing special. The chunky Italian guy serving you at the counter who wears the gaudy gold jewelry, isn't the friendliest. Been here, done that.
Erik LyngvedJuly 24, 2011Great neighborhood Brooklyn pizza joint! Their thin sicilian is the best I've ever had.
J TamFebruary 12, 2011Great NYC pizza. No frils. Don't order mushroom slice b/c they used canned. Their chicken parm is decent.
Krissy GJune 2, 2012The service was great. Unfortunately, I wasn't too impressed with my order. The meatball pizza didn't taste like it was cooked thoroughly & the calzone taste a bit burnt. :-/
Tasha HendersonNovember 17, 2012Tried 8 different meals...not ONE was any good. No seasoning, too greasy!!!
CampusClipperDecember 6, 2011STUDENTS: Get 25% off!More at
DanielaApril 18, 2013Non male come pizza negli USA, se proprio non potete fare a meno di mangiarla :)
44 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
34 years same Italian family owned/operated and home of the famous fried calzone, classic NY pizza, and Italian comfort food. Check out website to hear Elvis Duran speak about the calzones and pizza. Pizza profiled on NBC New York Live
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:30 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:30 AM–11:00 PM
(212) 925-0440
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
Jukebox
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer
See More
You might also like
- 9.1
"Absolutely one of the best margarita slice I ever had thank you so much Joseph!! Wish they have one in Brooklyn?"
Edward Kim - 8.8
"Everything was good. The pizza, burrata and the bread with the burrata.. not to be missed"
Nouf - 8.7
"Burger is amazing — would sleep inside that pretzel bun. The Colony2 is a perfect combo of spicy and sweet. Would have just skipped the truffle topping on the waffle fries."
Meghan Murphy
Places people like to go after Sal's Little Italy
- 8.2
"Great, quick service. You really can't go wrong with what you order. This place is the real deal"
Maddie Cannatella - 9.1
"Snag a table upstairs and pretend you're a VIP or grab a drink in the basement to take a break from the noise. Fantastic sound and great sightlines make this a downtown favorite."
Ear Candy Go: Music - 6.4
"Gelato, cannoli, and espresso! Great Late night snacks."
Chris G.
Appears on 18 lists
Created by Emmy Charles
195 items • 3 followers
One Bite, Everybody Knows The Rules
Created by Sean Quinn
200 items • 1 follower
NYC Pizza Places for Broke College Students
Created by CampusClipper
10 items • 1 follower
