See all
44 photos

Scalini Fedeli

Italian Restaurant$$$$

Tribeca, New York

Save

Scalini Fedeli

8.4^/10

ratings

Ranked #7 for wine in Tribeca
"A different level of experience."(2 Tips)
"... – truly authentic. The veal chop was masterfully cooked to moist perfection,..."(2 Tips)
"Fantastic date spot."(4 Tips)
"Get the Prix Fixe ($70) and add in the Seared Foie Gras."(2 Tips)

29 Tips and reviews

Filter:

prix fixe menu
veal chops
great value
foie gras
trendy
fresh spinach
bar
dinner
staff
truffle butter
soft boiled eggs
egg yolks
good for special occasions
carbonara
ricotta cheese
pricey
(11 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Halstead PropertyOctober 7, 2013
Pure decadence – the warm ricotta and fresh spinach filled the soft Egg Yolk Ravioli impeccably. The truffle butter topped the dish, adding great flavor and our favorite melt in your mouth effect.
FunesJanuary 3, 2016
They had the holiday prix fixe and it was amazing. May be the best carbonara I've ever had. The wife's gnocchi was out of this world, perhaps better than any pasta we had in Roma or Florence.
Halstead PropertyJuly 25, 2011
The ambiance in Scalini Fedeli is reminiscent of good Italian restaurants in the movies – truly authentic. The veal chop was masterfully cooked to moist perfection, and the wait staff was excellent.
IWalked Audio ToursSeptember 24, 2011
#3 - IWalked NYC's Top 10 Italian Restaurants. Provides a blend of Italian with French highlights. Book a month in advance. Unique wine list focuses on small speciality vineyards.<LINK> Read more
Jan NielsenSeptember 25, 2011
A nice dinner with a great variety of choice on the menu. Wines are a bit on the expensive side and the waiters not overly attentive. Seems to have lost the sparkle since the Michelin accolades in '06
The Corcoran GroupApril 1, 2011
Romantic Italian restaurant with a menu that changes monthly. Get the Prix Fixe ($70) and add in the Seared Foie Gras. The service here is spectacular.
Claude DraillardJuly 28, 2013
Superb food. Good wine selection and a view on the freedom tower. Would be nice if the waiters would articulate more when they present the dish.
Tanay ModiApril 29, 2019
Fantastic date spot. Feels like you’re in Tuscany!
Jenna UlianoSeptember 1, 2013
Enjoy a glass of prosecco by the bar before grabbing a table by the window for an intimate dinner.
CarlAugust 7, 2013
Pretty awesome. Ask them to make you the Snapper Milanese. It was amazing. The 20oz Veal Chop was impressive too.
Christian NøklebyNovember 30, 2011
Fantastic Italian food, especially the pasta. Not petite enough (in European standards) to classify as a top gourmet restaurant...
MarthaMarch 7, 2015
wonderful, romantic room. food is superb. highly recommend.
Alexis YSYFebruary 16, 2015
The steak, wine ... Everything
Graceanne BoweOctober 13, 2013
Amazing! Food was divine: service was stellar. Highly recommend!
Raj S.October 10, 2010
Seared foie gras was incredible. Solid selection of wine. Highly recommended for a group of old friends.
AnngelicaNovember 23, 2010
Too many misses for a one star Michelin. The food lacked freshness and flavor. The music and decor were appropriate for a funeral home. For excellent Italian, try Aurora or Giorgione instead.
BravoNovember 18, 2010
Different level of cooking from anything that I have experienced before. -Teresa Giudice, Real Housewives of NJ
NY WaterwayAugust 23, 2012
Quiet and comfortable! The app menu is amazing!
Maha AlrasheedFebruary 19, 2023
Ravioli with mushrooms and truffle 👌
Kal MaAugust 3, 2013
Very good!!had a great time with my family :)
Marcello MialiDecember 11, 2014
A different level of experience. Excellent
Showtime NetworkApril 1, 2011
It’s obviously a special occasion, so make a toast! Here’s hoping you find a papal gift hidden in your entre.
Scott RasakMarch 28, 2013
Best Italian in NYC by far
Ben GaspariniOctober 3, 2014
Amazing service
Dad and BuriedNovember 6, 2009
if it's a bday, tell them in advance. they go all out w free drinks and special dessert flourishes.
Gregory ParkApril 3, 2014
Food is so nice here.
Julia MinFebruary 13, 2011
heavenly foccacia bread!!
Marcus StavchanskyJanuary 2, 2017
Some of the dishes were great and others were not. The gnocchi was great!
Диана Диана.November 16, 2014
Друзья нью-йоркцы порекомендовали этот ресторан. Оценка 8.1??? Заведение заслуживает 10! Невероятная кухня! Чистые тарелки - доказательство.

44 Photos

Scalini Fedeli

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Scalini Fedeli

Appears on 165 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.