McFadden's Saloon
(Now Closed)Bar, Pub, and American Restaurant$$$$
Turtle Bay, New York
100 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Gabriel HayesOctober 16, 2015Sign up on their mailing list to be entered to win a free happy hour. The winner gets free drinks for 3 hours and everyone with them gets $5 drinks for that timespan.
Victoria MenichettiSeptember 8, 2012Watch the bartenders and green man dance on top of the bar to every genre of music in the past 30 years played on shuffle.. Get 20 dollar open bar for ur bday
- Gabriel HayesSeptember 11, 2015Good place to watch the game. Lots of TVs and good draft beer options. Can be very crowded but I had fun for Thursday Night Football.
Terecille Basa-OngOctober 8, 2013Our burgers took forever to come out, and we were one of the first tables seated at lunchtime. The fact that they're "gourmet" is no excuse! They were delicious, though.
Tara RocheJune 19, 2013Nice place to meet someone in midtown for lunch. Good salads, burgers, sandwiches. Wait staff very attentive. Lunch crowd is quiet
Andres RipollJune 1, 2013The glorious adventure starts at the front of this lovely establishment where we were greeted by a large group of highly intoxicated patrons, randomly hitting on my wife as we managed to get in.
John CassilloJuly 11, 2015Have a soft spot for this place from back in college. It's nothing special, but it's a good time with basic drinks and TVs.
Michael NataleJuly 31, 2015Nice big space with large bars. But it fills up mad quick with the late night crowds.
Adam WillisMay 5, 2015The sign that says $3 drafts doesn't really mean $3 drafts. Only shitty beers are $3. The good stuff is $7+
Larissa AlvarezDecember 4, 2016While looking for somewhere to dance earlier in the night (9pm-ish everywhere else was football). There was a dj. Tons of people, no space to move let alone dance and impossible to get to the bar.
Went to McFaddens with a friend and has one of the best times ever! Saturday night was wild and didn't leave till 5am. Get a booth. Enough said!- Gabriel HayesOctober 16, 2015Both a Buffalo Bills bar and a New York Mets bar. Great to watch games for both teams.
Larry EderDecember 18, 2012McFaddens is across the street from the Hilton Manhattan East, on E 42nd and second. Nice Irish pub, good food, great place to watch the 49ers and the Patriots game.
This place is the best! Sign up for a free happy hr and if u get called, u drink for freeee! Plus ur friends get $25 open bar or half price drinks!
Aryan JOctober 6, 2010Forget the bar. Go to McFadden's for their Cookie Smash. It is basically a large, freshly-baked cookie baked & served on a small baking pan. It is one of the best desserts I have ever had...EVER.
Mike HornMarch 1, 2010I enjoyed this place until people found out about it. However, they are really good about birthdays & letting you "win" open bars once a month as long as you keep putting your name on a stupid list.
Fish and Chips are great, simple and perfectly portioned for further drinking...- Andy McMillanOctober 6, 2012The music at this bar is indistinguishable from the music that plays when you're editing your house in The Sims.
The DJ Beyrer is pretty cute! Ask nicely for a request and I you are a girl remember to tip the bathroom attendant!!!
Emmy GeraghtyJune 29, 2013The only difference between this bar and the fratty bars in college is the guys here wear suits.
Kristen BaxterJuly 19, 2014I wish my blowgun shot tranquilizing darts -- if it did, one would be reserved for the DJ in the McFadden's embroidered shirt.
Shirlene W. HenryAugust 4, 2015Too many college kids, and the bartenders aren't really paying attention when you want to get a drink. They are more focus on entertaining the crowd.
Nice midtown bar for beers with the colleagues. Beer selection is subpar.
Lori BenderOctober 31, 2012Thank you McFaddens for being open yesterday with lots of power outlets! You helped me get through storm Sandy!
Daniel RosoneMay 17, 2015the dj doesn't know the difference between I want it that way and gecko overdrive. He mistakes 180bpm for 110bpm. Absolute moron.
No NoJuly 5, 2013This would've been kind of acceptable if I was still 16. Worse than a college bar. There was also a crystal-like substance at the bottom of my drink and I quickly sent it back. Never again.
GoodnitegraciSeptember 12, 2010Buffalo Bills backer bar. Come every Sunday! All you drink & eat (Buffalo wings) specials
Sean MurphFebruary 21, 2011They have a monthly birthday bash, where if it is the month of your birthday, you drink free and your friends drink half price
Tina MaffeoSeptember 15, 2013I was there for a fundraiser. I would have liked to try the food but it was hard to get to it.
Joonbug.comFebruary 4, 2011Every Friday VIP Party, host drinks free (must bring 10 friends), 10pm-12am $20 Top Shelf for friends!
John PermaulJune 8, 2012One of the employee's here had a "Lets Go Cena...Cena Sucks" shirt. And he got Alberto Del Rio's theme song to play over the speaker!!!
Jaclyn LeJuly 13, 2014Don't go here. Terrible club/bar. The crowd seems like what you'd find in the suburbs in the Midwest. Mainstream top 100 hits if you're into that kind of thing.
Sergi KapanadzeMay 28, 2016Worst place. Rude manager who would not turn the sound for a Champions League game on. Just because he feels like it. No other reason. Last time ever we went there. Awful place
Chad HApril 28, 2012This place is essentially Coyote Ugly run by dudes which is awesome if you're a tourist.
DanwenJune 2, 2015Meh. They have a happy hour contest which gets you good deals but otherwise not worth it.
Tuesday is $1 bud/coors light drafts after 6p, just beware that they mostly plays 90's music here.
230 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Come to McFadden's Saloon - New York City's Midtown happy hour bar! Our resident DJs and bartenders deliver an experience you will not soon forget!
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–4:00 AM
(212) 986-1515
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Music
Live Music
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar
See More
You might also like
- 8.2
"Professional grade table tennis facilities with a full bar soldered on to sweeten the pot. Everything is high quality, with commensurate pricing. Worth the money, though."
Billy Keenly - 8.8
"Sweet neighborhood bar with great drinks, trivia nights, live music and nice people."
Ted Barnett - 8.6
"Great place to catch up with friends, love the ambience and solid cocktails and beer selection. Also need to have a pickleback shot, one of the better ones I've had."
Dave Reed
Appears on 102 lists
Bars in New Jersey to watch NFL SUNDAY TICKET™
Created by DIRECTV
71 items • 24 followersCreated by harryh
25 items • 165 followersCreated by Alex Mizrahi
25 items • 27 followers
