Island Burgers and Shakes
(Now Closed)Burger Joint$$$$
Hell's Kitchen, New York
Has a stamp of approval from Serious Eats and The Corcoran Group
109 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
New York HabitatNovember 18, 2011Tons (60+ in all!!) of burgers and chicken sandwiches to choose from here. If you love heat like we do, go for the Napalm which features bbq sauce, jalapenos, and habanero sauce.
John (aka “PHATFoodFan”)May 16, 2015Get the slider with habanero & cheddar, best slider I have ever had. Will stop by again next time I am in NYC! The one with Thai peanut sauce is not bad either.
Evelyn SherbenouJuly 1, 2012Tijuana burger has everything I want on a burger... bacon, guacamole (with a little kick!), and sautéed onions. Om nom. Didn't need to get a side of fries or chips, the burger filled me up on its own!
Fernando KikudomeDecember 13, 2016Burguer with american cheese and (think so) homemade bbq. It was awsome, including the bacon (perfectly made). Chocolate shake was regular, tasteful but not memorable. Price ok!
Camilo GaviriaJune 21, 2015We had a really good experience at this burger joint! The burger was tasty and there were loads of different options to customize each burger. The avocado was quite spicy, so be carfull!
Halstead PropertyOctober 7, 2013The size of the restaurant sure doesn’t match the size of the menu! The Bourbon Street’s spice added the perfect flare to the meat topped with sizzling bacon and melted cheese on fresh sourdough bread
Joanne LockmanNovember 24, 2015Ordered delivery and they got it so wrong, but they corrected it and gave me a cookie to say sorry -Impressive! Loved they took the extra step to apologize. That was years ago but I still remember!❤️
Tash ConcepcionAugust 17, 2014One of the best, juiciest burgers I've had. But be prepared for it to get messy. The shakes are also one of the best things on the menu. Try the malted shakes.
Nikki VargasAugust 17, 2011A hole-in-the-wall burger joint w/ the BEST burgers I have had in NYC. Before this place I didn't even know there were so many options when it comes to burgers! The place speaks for itself--a must go!
The Corcoran GroupDecember 3, 2011This tiny burger joint has more burger variations than we could imagine! You might want to give Barzel’s a try. Finish with a Black & White Milkshake.
Lunch burger deal is great! Great staff and food. Can't go wrong with the chicken or burger.
Guillaume PJuly 4, 2016Great burgers, nice service. One of those tiny places that are worth more than the million tourist traps a few streets away.
David MorarAugust 22, 2014It would be obvious to recommend the burgers or shakes, but DAMN are they the best ever. Get your burger "au poivre". You'll love it!
Best burgers in NYC? Quite possibly! Special wine deal Monday and Tuesday nights, and be sure to check in when you're there for a loyalty bonus (every 2nd or 3rd visit?)
Michelle ConnochieFebruary 5, 2018They changed the menu and have only a handful of options now. Quite disappointing considering how good the online menu looked.
Beth KFebruary 2, 2018Small restaurant, really cool vibe. Good classic food with huge selection of burgers 🍔
SteveFebruary 24, 2013Great burger! Had the cowboy burger and it was delicious! But asked for well done and middle was medium. But it tasted great!
Serious EatsApril 13, 2014Steer clear of the mushy burgers and head straight for the excellent fries and onion rings.
The Nouveau Classical ProjectFebruary 23, 2013Bourbon street burger is yummy! Just be sure to ask them to put it on a bun--it doesn't work on toast because it falls out
Robert AccetturaDecember 6, 2014The burgers and shakes are obviously good. The fries are a more recent addition and also very good
Sean SmithOctober 24, 2014Large selection of burgers and toppings. Guaranteed to find one or three combinations you will enjoy.
I've been here a million times. Their most popular and best burger is the Bourbon St. Don't think twice and order it alongside a Black & White Shake, then spend the rest of your day on the treadmill.
There are tons of delicious burgers! Beware of ones that are on toast or sliced bread; they will probably fall apart. Ask for a roll instead.
Maurio FioreAugust 15, 2014Blackened burger with bacon and au poivre = the best damn burger I've ever ordered. Ever.
Cheapeats IncOctober 30, 2011Don't be put off by the prices...the portions are HUGE. 30 varieties of burgers & churascos (chicken sandwiches) and of course....shakes.
$15 bottles of wine every Sunday through Tuesday??? Heck yes! Got a group with you? Enjoy unique, draft beers? Get a pitcher for $25!- Island Burgers now offers french fries and they are delicious. You can also get them cheese, chili, or chili cheese fries.
Blackened Churrasco with pepper jack! No chicken sandwich like it!
Marc AdlerAugust 1, 2010BBQ burger has plenty of bite due to the enhanced sauce (with Dried Red Peppers). Well worth it and very reasonably priced for NYC. Top it off with an ice cream soda or milk shake.
Get the cajun burger as well as a guacamole and tortilla chips. Also, don't get stressed because they don't have french fries - the homemade jalapeno potato chips are great.
These burgers aren't only perfect for your weekend hangover, they're still amazing when you're fully sober.
Brian RamosMarch 7, 2013they've got a laundry list of burgers that will suit anyone's need. they're all good.
Come hungry! This place is 1 of the best burger places in the city & 1 of my favorites! Delicious!
The Cowboy is messy, but with a sprinkling of avocado slices, a buckin' bronco's bangin' burger dream! #bam
Tracy GamarraNovember 8, 2011Bourbon Street Burger! If you want to try something deliciously different and spicy.
Nic SMarch 25, 2012There are no vegetarian burgers on the menu, so you'll have to settle for grilled cheese or a salad. :( Awesome fries, though.
Juyeon LeeMay 7, 2011Cowboy burger is really tasty, but incredibly messy. Medium rare was way too rare for my liking. I'd get medium next time I go. Be prepared to have a stack of napkins on your table...!
Matthew RodriguezAugust 26, 2011Lots of burger variations, but some are overly ambitious. Good burger option though if in the neighborhood and craving a cow between two buns.
188 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Island Burgers and Shakes
766 9th Ave (btwn W 51st & W 52nd St)
New York, NY 10019
United States
New York, NY 10019
United States
We have 2 locations. Hell's kitchen and the Upper West Side
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- Noon–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- Noon–10:30 PM
(212) 307-7934
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Music
Live Music
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Island Burgers and Shakes
- 6.7
"Love shows at terminal 5! Summer shows are the best! They have nice sitting area outside where u can sit, chill and drink. Very spacious!Great venue!"
Michelle Petrozza - 7.9
"Great beer garden; cool atmosphere! Packed on fridays...you are warned! PLUS: They have "Happy Hour" 😃 AND "Angry Hour" 😡... Cheers! 🍺🍺🍺"
Rosaida Blanco - 8.5
"Excellent option for hungry, ramen-weary folks near Lincoln Center. Cozy & snug at times, but the food is more than worth a few bump-ins. Great character, great spices & great for repeat visits."
J. Longo
Appears on 328 lists
Created by Tristan
48 items • 352 followers
Cheapeats - Happiness, $25 and under.
Created by Cheapeats Inc
105 items • 201 followers
Created by New York Habitat
40 items • 152 followers
