Gatsby's
(Now Closed)Bar and American Restaurant$$$$
NoLita, New York
91 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
DensFebruary 26, 2014A lil' history lesson -- the bldg across the street was once home to The Happy Corp (2003-09), the creative shop whose "LVHRD" events acted as the glue that helped formed the 2nd act NYC's tech scene
Laura KathMarch 29, 2015Thought the wings look delicious,they are average. The drinks DO make up for it, amazing drinks, Margarita and Gin and Tonic 👏👍 Try the hamburgers!
Ms HeleneJuly 9, 2017Nice lounge area and couches down the back away from the tv screens and easy to get into but the DJ on a Sat night plays a weird mix
Alice AssadOctober 26, 2013Excelent place! The staff is great, attentioncius and helpful. The food is well served and delicius. I will come back here, for sureee! Strongly recomend!
isabella ramJuly 7, 2013I actually thought the young bartender lady was quite nice.... I don't think it should be on a to do list but bit a bad place to just come in for a beer.... Remember people bounce off your energy :)
Michele WeismanFebruary 18, 2012One of the best bars I've been to in all of NYC. The DJ plays the best music and you are bound to have a great time!
TheFestivalGuy.comJuly 19, 2012Did I mention how horrible the music is? Here is the play list tonight. Ace of Base, Boys to Men, Garth Brooks, and other bad music. Side note: the mojitos are bomb.
Kenny BurtnerJanuary 28, 2014The bartender was obviously coming off a heavy bender and was MIA for 20 minutes. Don't be lured in by the lunch special
Penny JonesMay 31, 2019The AC on Gatsby’s at 53 Spring has been roaring all night. I invite all the neighbors to call 311 with a noise complaint and to call the manager, Jason Sheridan, at (646) 785-4156.
Andrew MercierJanuary 25, 2014It did indeed smell like a urinal puck but if you get a blonde server named Vivian, consider yourself blessed. She's awesome.
michael nerenburgDecember 19, 2013Don't leave anything of value around, the busboys/waitresses whoever will steal it. They have surveillance so if you talk to the manager he can basically threaten them. But truthfully, STAY AWAY
Igor TumasovSeptember 28, 2013Nothing about this place feels Gatsby-like. Don't be fooled by the name. It's a plain-looking, clean lined, modern bar. The crowd was recent grads and college kids. A bit pricey for what it is.
Avin NarasimhanJanuary 25, 2015Decent soccer bar if you're in the area. And a fairly large beer selection
MurphGuide.comDecember 9, 2011over 40 bottled beers and a large selections of scotches, cognacs & tequilas, plus frozen drinks by Island Oasis
Kimberly BellaApril 29, 2013Kind if the worst lunch ever for the price. $75 for three (slightly bigger than a McDonalds burger) and a pulled pork sandwich that was even smaller. Will not be returning to this place...ever.
Rishi JosanJuly 14, 2014Do yourselves a favor and DO NOT EVER go to this bar! The "manager" asked us to leave our table and when we went to the bar, took our stool away saying "I'm the manager and I can do whatever I want".
Jared HaversonJune 8, 2013Probably the least fun bar I've ever been to in NYC and that is truly saying something. "No dancing" signs beneath the DJ booth?! I'm just confused.
Tru DyOctober 23, 2014Looks like a typical dive bar with overpriced drinks. But the bouncer is such a sweetheart
Peter WOctober 17, 2010This place is the closest version of what I believe will end up being my own personal hell...cheap Delirum though, so that's nice.
Maria TellezMay 18, 2014Wings are not for the faint of heart. Service is not as bad as I heard. Decent spot.
Andrea EvansJune 8, 2011Skip this place... it's not that great of food or drinks and the table and chairs felt like they were going to break- $20 min on a CC. They were really pressuring us to buy alcohol which was annoying.
- This is a BYOV* establishment. (*bring your own vegetables.)
Sandra SouNovember 16, 2011This place really sucks...specials are $4 miller lite and $5 pilot grigio?...srsly
The drinks are weaker than Stephen Hawkins. Yes I said it!!!
LexiAugust 24, 2012Warning: the waitresses are so rude, even your nicest friends leave in a rage. Drinks are way overpriced and gratuity is automatic- so save your $ and find somewhere that appreciates your business !
Michael HeerDecember 4, 2010Gatsby's is a little overpriced for food that's not so good. Sodas are 4 dollars and there's no free refills. Drafts and bottles are 7 dollars. Sandwiches are 14-15 dollars. Its not worth it.
Christie BesingerJune 18, 2014Beware this place has a secret $20 credit card min. No signs, they just tell you once it's too late. This is also an illegal practice. Too bad.
- TheFestivalGuy.comJuly 19, 2012Ask for the manager and tell them the music is fucking horrible. Together we can create change.
- prince of ArroganceMay 4, 2014The dj that worked 3rd of May should hang his head in shame. A terrible playlist, I would never come back because of that.
127 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–4:00 AM
(212) 334-4430
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Appears on 46 lists
Created by Sean666 Salmon666
199 items • 11 followers
Created by D
182 items • 21 followers
