1. Roberta's Pizza
9.2
261 Moore St (at Bogart St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · East Williamsburg · 864 tips and reviews
Ines P.: Order the cheeseplate and a classic like the crispy glover and then spend the night shmearing delicious cheese on perfectly singed pizza. Also, cuttlefish is good.
goop: It’s worth the few extra stops on the L train (and the wait once you get there) for some of the best wood-fired pizzas and good rustic Italian (including veggies from their very own co-op garden). Read more.
Steven Lambiase: you can't go wrong with any pizza here. All fresh ingredients. Worth the 1-2 hour wait if youve never been. Grab a drink in the backyard while you wait or head around the corner to pine box rock shop.
2. Emmy Squared
8.7
364 Grand St (at Marcy Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Williamsburg · 168 tips and reviews
Cory Forsyth: Excellent pizzas. If there's a wait go to 20 Sided Store next door, where you can play games while waiting to be seated.
Allie Briskin: get there early, but enjoy everything. definitely try the cheese curds, one of the many sandwiches and the roni pizza....or of course, the Emmy.
markus gerdemann: Amazing detroitvl style pizza. Everything here is bomb
3. Best Pizza
9.0
33 Havemeyer St (btwn N 7th & N 8th St.), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Williamsburg · 200 tips and reviews
Britney Greenhouse: Absolutely get the anchovies with caramelized onions, delicious!! then follow up with a pickled veggie pizza slice, bomb. Ice tea to wash it down, and you are money.
Serious Eats: For Best Pizza's Pickled Vegetable Pie, onions, fennel, broccoli, sprouts, and cauliflower all get the brine treatment before being generously deposited on top of a pizza.
Ben K.: The white pizza with caramelized onions has a sesame seed crust which I've never seen before and is delicious. Also must try the pickled vegetable pizza, chicken parm and meatball subs.
5. Joe's Pizza
9.1
216 Bedford Ave (btwn N 5th St & N 6th St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Williamsburg · 83 tips and reviews
L: Perfect NY style classic pizza. Cheap too! Several chairs by the window, gets busy but service is fast.
Rubén García: Great for late night pizza, open until 4am!
Olivia Slutsky: Obviously, some of the best pizza in New York. Tasty thin crust slice really hits the spot.
6. Williamsburg Pizza
8.9
265 Union Ave (South 3rd Street), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · East Williamsburg · 80 tips and reviews
nora walker: Great new addition to a neighborhood with a lot of pizza options. Try the Tartufo - ermahgerd truffle oil! Yum. Also follow them on instagram if you want to crave pizza A LOT.
Diego G: I was skeptical about kale pizza and 4 buck slices but it was well worth the money and kale pizza is awesome! Tender below the cheese and crispy like kale chops on top. Highly recommended.
Lee Simpson: We visited this place on a Brooklyn Pizza Tour and it was the easily the best slice of the night. Get the one with all the meat and be sure to pick up plenty of napkins.
Ben Gasparini: Great pizza, Brie, garlic, so many good options
Leemor Yuravlivker: Burrata pizza is worth every penny 🍕 classic pie with fresh basil burrata and Parmesan.
Tarah Feinberg: Superb pizza and interesting approach. You walk up to a bunch of cheese pies and choose from an eclectic, very creative menu. Meat, veggie, burrata pizzas are sure to have something for everyone.
8. Alligator Lounge
7.8
600 Metropolitan Ave (btwn Lorimer & Leonard St), Brooklyn, NY
Karaoke Bar · East Williamsburg · 119 tips and reviews
Laura Notini: Free pizza is the best pizza, especially when it's good pizza.
The Brew Noob: Buy any draft beer of your choice (they have quite the selection on tap) and get a free personal pizza! Good deal for tasty beer and bar food.
Raquelle Jessie: karaoke here not for the faint of heart, free mini personal brick oven pizza w your libation & a huge variety of drinks= solid spot
9. Carmine's Pizzeria
8.5
358 Graham Ave (btwn Conselyea St & Metropolitan Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Williamsburg · 85 tips and reviews
yesenia linares: this is one of the best places to get a slice of pizza, the buffalo chicken with jalapenos is my fave!
Jennifer Jberry: Bruschetta was delicious along with the mozzarella sticks, the Philly cheese steak pizza was out of this world 😍😍 the pepperoni and sausage was ok..
Audrey Sheppard: Marsala pizza slice is to DIE for... so creamy and filling!!
11. Forcella
7.5
485 Lorimer St (btwn Grand & Powers St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · East Williamsburg · 93 tips and reviews
jessica m. hintermeister: here's the deal. order the following & thank me after: insalata caprese, marinara pie, margherita pie, & montanara pie (fried Margherita)
James Laurenti: Dope spot with many excellent pizza options. Get the Materdei, which has some awesome spicy salami on it. Read more.
Tom Walsh: Everything I liked the montanaro pizza is different with the fried pizza crust. The service was good on a scale of 1 to 10 10 being the best I give it a 8.
13. Sal's Pizzeria
8.0
544 Lorimer St (Devoe St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · East Williamsburg · 42 tips and reviews
Adam Schwartz: My favorite pizza place in the burg. Really nice guys, great anti pasta and pizza.
Mager Mager: Get the garlic knots. Also, best pizza in NYC.
Nicole: Best pizza in the city/world. Get the chicken and veggies, or anything with pesto.
Noah Weiss: All Rosenberg, Lil' Stinker, and Bee Sting all fantastic 💯🍕. Arbitrage crazy lines with take out here and then eat in the Roberta's back yard bar.
Rahul Gupta: Best pizza in Brooklyn
Will Harahan: Margherita pizza was fantastic. Friendly staff, and great outdoor seating nearby. Will go back and try some of their other pies.
15. Charleston
7.2
174 Bedford Ave (btwn N 7th & N 8th St.), Brooklyn, NY
Bar · Williamsburg · 108 tips and reviews
Max Long: Dollar personal pizzas with every beer is awesome! They also play great movies to watch while you eat too
Bradley Patrie: Best dive bar in the area. Staff is unmatched, Dave the bartender/manager is the single greatest bartender I've ever known. Great for a cheap drink, and free pizza!
Amber Nagle: Fun place. Free pizza, great pickleback shots and games to play.