Awesome pastas, gnocchi and creamy pesto for sure
The gnocchi is amazing; ask to sub it in the Pappardelle Al Ragu Di Vitello. Favorite wine there is the Montepulciano D'Abruzzo.
Very cozy and romantic atmosphere. Gnocchi was as really delicious as its famous reputation, and the scampi was amazingly fresh and tasty.
by far the best Italian food I've ever had. make sure u order the gnocchi ( w gorgonzola) and the tiramisu for dessert! you won't regret it! pinky promise ;)
Green beans, diced tomatoes & red onions in balsamic vinegar = perfect Springtime appetizer. The gnocchi is light and delicious. Best Italian on the Upper East Side? Limited seating - book in advance.
Great Gorgonzola gnocchi, can't go wrong with any of the pasta dishes, lamb chops, or fish entrees. Wouldn't recommend the scampi.
Gnocchi is the best I've ever had. Personally I think the mac and cheese is a bit too rich, but basically everything is delicious.
had the lamb gnocchi special and it was amazing! great little spot if you live in UES.
If the daily special pasta is gnocchi - get it! Heidi's has the best gnocchi I've ever had! 🙌
The spinach gnocchi is delicious!
Always go for the specials - their menu is seasonal and sourced from local farms and vendors. Gnocchi is a favorite of ours. They have a new one to offer every time we come.
Amazing burrata and really unique style of gnocchi.
Gnocchi were fantastic! Skirt steak also great. Churros were nice...dipping sauce was a tad too spicy though. But overall a GREAT addition to the UES. Good vibe, nice service, great food!
Great gnocchi , tacos and salad
Get the tuna tartar crostini, the gnocchi and the churro dessert - heavenly!!
The Gnocchi di mama is amazing
The Serafina Chicken Salad is amazing as is the Kale Pesto Gnocci
Try the pizza(Margarita) and the gnocchi, no one can go wrong with gnocchi.
Gnocchi just melts in your mouth and get the pear and Gorgonzola salad is prob one of the best salads I've ever had
Can’t go wrong with the homemade gnocchi!
Homemade pastas, bread baskets & sauces are all delicious. An authentic, ambient Italian restaurant. Enjoy a great meal for reasonable $. Much more elegant than a pizzeria, but w same hearty feeling.
Homemade gnocchi to die for, and old-school carbonara with consomme instead of cream.
Homemade pasta, Homemade dessert, Oyster Cocktail, Clams Oreganate, Pasta Fagioli, Caesar Salad, Malfatti, Gnocchi
Best italian on the upper east side. The staff is great and the food is amazing.
No need to go downtown or Brooklyn. The pizza is here. Try their gnocchi too. Tutto bene! :)
San Matteo is a slice of Italy in the upper east side accompanied with authentic food. I wouldn't get the gnocchi again, but the margarita pizza was close to perfection.
Good pizza, cute small pace. very cozy and service as good it can gets. Buffalo mozzarella is great too as well gnocchi...!!
Great restaurant. Very accommodating (they split the starter without we even asked :) ). Food is amazing. Fig gnocchi is delightful, and the spinach and ricotta ravioli is precise. Very recommended.
Excellent beef carpaccio, seafood over black pasta, fig gnocchi and creme brûlée.
A lovely place to have dinner. I had the best ravioli with creamy truffle sauce ever!
The gnocchi is heavenly and the pizza is some of the best I've ever had.
Closest thing to authentic Italian pizza you’ll find. Get the classic margarita with prosciutto if you’re craving tomatoes—they’re super sweet and refreshing. Top it off with Hazelnut gelato.
Love the calzone ztonino!
The gnocchi with pork shoulder is amomg the best pasta dishes I've ever tasted.
Sit at the bar, and order the pappardelle and seasonal dessert tart. You can't go wrong with any of the cocktails (especially the tangerine cello). The roast chicken is a staple and always delicious.
The lovely intimate atmosphere (they work with a 10 person dining area) make it advisable to call ahead for a reservation. Worth every minute!
Try the gnocchi ai fromaggi and a Montepulciano wine.
Come for the veal ragu, stay for the delicious selection of Italian wines.
Best for wine and apps only. Main courses are average.
Fettuccine Alfredo, Gorganzola gnocchi, and butter sage ravioli are my fav dishes. Skip the Caesar salad. Only of my favorite places in the city!
truffle tortollini was aaaaamazing, and the veal tortollini was even better. Make sure you save room for dessert because the strawberry shortcake and homemade canoli were fantastic! Hidden gem!!
Very small, very cozy, and very attentive staff!
gnocchi is so fluffy!
Authentic to the key. Dover sole was fantastico as was everything ordered to the table (my goodness the lobster spaghetti) Molto buono! A must go to in NY.
Honestly, everything is amazing...but definitely try the beef carpaccio!
Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA