Carmine’s Italian Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

1. Carmine’s Italian Restaurant

8.9
200 W 44th St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 564 tips and reviews

BECKY C.BECKY COLLINS: Chocolate Torta very rich but delicious!

Nuclear CowboyzNuclear Cowboyz: I’m always looking for the best place to eat. Everyone needs to hit this place up! It is in Times Square and has the best Italian food I’ve ever had. I can’t wait to go back! – Ronnie Faisst, Nuclear

James S.James Sims: The chicken parm is fantastic, but the garlic bread is amazing!

La Masseria is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

2. La Masseria

8.8
235 W 48th St (at 8th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 87 tips and reviews

Chase H.Chase Hubbard: Had the ravioli, it was amazing! So was the gnocchi as well as the clams and linguini!

Ivana G.Ivana Goldstein: The cheesecake is to die for!!!! Never had a better one.

Alex M.Alex M: Wi-Fi password - lamasserianyc

Tony's Di Napoli is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

3. Tony's Di Napoli

8.7
147 W 43rd St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 235 tips and reviews

Dip P.Dip Pachuka: amazing “house” salad😋 and penne broccoli garlic&olive oil.

Anthony R.Anthony R.: family style food

inkpushcoinkpushco: No fuss Italian.

Trattoria Dell' Arte is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

4. Trattoria Dell' Arte

8.1
900 7th Ave (at 57th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 157 tips and reviews

Berta A.Berta Alfonsina: The best lobster pizza & key lime pay toped with créeme brulet as a dessert.

Rima A.Rima Alisa: Try the veal chop it was too good to be true. And the service was excellent! 👌

Michael C.Michael Cooper: Dinner at the bar is a great scene. Loved it!

Bond 45 is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

5. Bond 45

7.9
221 W 46th St (Broadway), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 20 tips and reviews

Cengiz O.Cengiz Ozkardes: Veal is the best. Here we are again. The best. Smiling friendly people are welcoming you.

Sally H.Sally Houck: Chocolate chip cookie ‘for the table’. So yummy!

Chad M.Chad Martin: Excelente! Veal parm was probably the best I have ever had

Sardi's is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

6. Sardi's

7.9
234 W 44th St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 102 tips and reviews

HolidayHoliday: Squeeze up to the bar upstairs for a cocktail and light bites. Order a Manhattan and enjoy the theater crowd.

Chris P.Chris Phillips: This place is a pre-theater tradition. Get a drink at the bar upstairs and dive into the free cheese and Ritz.

Maria C.Maria Costa: feel like an adult by ordering a martini

Osteria al Doge is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

7. Osteria al Doge

7.6
142 W 44th St (btwn Broadway & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 55 tips and reviews

Debbie T.Debbie Tramel: Lasagna very good and so is the pasta with seafood! Can't wait for dessert!

bernie d.bernie davis: Great spot in midtown for authentic Italian. Great decor. Nice staff.

Junior M.Junior Marino: Totally awesome!!! Love it!!!

Patsy's Italian Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

8. Patsy's Italian Restaurant

7.5
236 W 56th St (Broadway), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 72 tips and reviews

Dom C.Dom Crincoli: Amazing and the owner helped us order. Very good.

Michael K.Michael Kauffman: Try the Stuffed Zuchinni Flowers

Jay N.Jay Nash: I love this place. You know if it was Frank Sinatra's favorite place they must be doing something right! Read more.

Paul's On Times Square is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

9. Paul's On Times Square

7.6
136 W 42nd St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 9 tips and reviews

Matt W.Matt Wieser: Very friendly staff. Good service and hearty food. Nice place

Dino R.Dino Redzic: Enjoy a cocktail on us with the purchase of your entrée when you mention FOURSQUARE! Simply show to your server to redeem!

Marcos A.Marcos Armenta: Very good food, service and atmosphere. Must see in Time Square.

Da Marino Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

10. Da Marino Restaurant

7.4
220 W 49th St (btwn Broadway & 8th), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 49 tips and reviews

ellen r.ellen resnick: The food is excellent, the music fantastic, no cover charges, extremely friendly spot, gives a coming home feel..

HBOHBO: Sex and the City happened here. "When I was seventeen, it was a very good year…" Big serenaded Carrie at this restaurant.

Jana G.Jana Griffin: You have to visit the ladies room. It is worth it to see such a romantic potty. :)

Nocello is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

11. Nocello

7.3
257 W 55th St (8th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 19 tips and reviews

Social News NetworkSocial News Network: If you're looking for amazing Italian food, this is the place. Located in the Theater District, it's cozy, it's delicious, it's authentic. You'll be tempted to sneak some warm bread home for later.

Evan U.Evan Unger: Mediocre at best

Lisa E.Lisa E: 10% off for Friends of City Center

Scarlatto is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

12. Scarlatto

7.3
250 W 47th St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 31 tips and reviews

Diana F.Diana F.: Antipasto Misto is great to share! Meat and cheese! mmmm

Janice T.Janice Thys: Food, ambiance and service are impeccable!

Abigail E.Abigail Elise: Pumpkin ravioli. Get it now.

Azalea Ristorante is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

13. Azalea Ristorante

7.3
224 W 51st St (btwn 8th Ave and Broadway), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 28 tips and reviews

Mel O.Mel Ooh: The red snapper is to die for !! Delish !! Cheers!! ✌️🍸🗽

Dianne P.Dianne Pino: First time,not so great...if you want warm bread,have to ask for it...they don't bring it out warm..waiter,no so friendly...

Svetlana E.Svetlana Ertakhanova: Nice food, friendly staff and cozy atmosphere just few steps of Times Square

Olive Garden is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

14. Olive Garden

7.2
2 Times Sq (W 47th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 292 tips and reviews

Mohammad A.Mohammad A.: Definitely must try, the salade, sea foos alfredo, and spaghetti were all delicious, plus excellent service.

George LopezGeorge Lopez: Can’t believe anyone would go to New York and eat at the Olive Garden. Wait… UNLIMITED FREE BREAD STICKS?? I’m there! (See? That’s how they get you!) Read more.

Fitness MagazineFitness Magazine: If you just had a big dinner that was high in fat, skip the caffeinated coffee. "Coffee slows your body's ability to deal with sugar," a researcher explained in FITNESS mag recently.

Trattoria Trecolori is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in the Theater District, New York.

15. Trattoria Trecolori

7.2
254 W 47th St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 94 tips and reviews

Ashley A.Ashley A: Love the food and GREAT service. Staff was extremely polite and helpful. The best Fettuccine Alfredo with chicken (maybe because I was starving).

Court P.Court Passant: Great pre theater dinner!

New York HabitatNew York Habitat: Fantastic place for dinner around Times Square or if you need somewhere to eat before a show. Go for the classics here, we love the chicken parm.