Pizza My Heart is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

1. Pizza My Heart

8.1
1116 Pacific Ave (at Lincoln St), Santa Cruz, CA
Pizzeria · Downtown Santa Cruz · 44 tips and reviews

PaulPaul: Best pizza in Santa Cruz

Joni H.Joni Honda: My Absolute Favorite Pizza,thin crust & tasty toppings & sauce. $6 a slice with a shirt!!

Christe F.Christe Farm: THE BEST PIZZA AROUND (Espically their Pesto pizza!!!!!) suggestion for first time comers.. Because all of their pizza is on thin crust, if you're hungry order two slices(or three?) Trust me on that!

Bantam is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

2. Bantam

8.0
1010 Fair Ave, Santa Cruz, CA
Pizzeria · Westside · 16 tips and reviews

Peter M.Peter McQueen: Excellent new artisan pizza restaurant in Santa Cruz. The dungeness crab salad was outstanding. Also enjoyed the clam, garlic, and parsley pizza.

Shannon M.Shannon Madison: Probably my favorite Santa Cruz restaurant. Great wine, great snacks (the olives are addictive!), great pizza

Sid B.Sid Boz: Great salads and pizza. Delicious beers on tap. Good vibe.

Woodstock's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

3. Woodstock's Pizza

7.9
710 Front St (at Cooper St.), Santa Cruz, CA
Pizzeria · Downtown Santa Cruz · 43 tips and reviews

MediaTileMediaTile: Great pizza joint. Try the all-meat orgy (pizza). And don't forget about their Foursquare special.

Shane S.Shane Saulus: Very good pizza with fresh ingredients and they don't skimp on these ingredients

Tone M.Tone Mosley: Great Pizza, Love the crust. And OMFG the cinnamon bread is to Die for.

Kianti's Pizza & Pasta Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

4. Kianti's Pizza & Pasta Bar

7.7
1100 Pacific Ave, Santa Cruz, CA
Italian Restaurant · Downtown Santa Cruz · 43 tips and reviews

Kerstin D.Kerstin Durden: Amazing pizza and pasta! Great atmosphere and affordable prices!

Erik C.Erik Cortes: Pizza Is great!!!! Combination. Also try the lasagna ...

Nate C.Nate Calderon: Try the Kianti's Special Pasta & Pizza Rolls... So crip!

Upper Crust Pizza & Pasta is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

5. Upper Crust Pizza & Pasta

7.6
2415 Mission St (Swift St), Santa Cruz, CA
Pizzeria · Westside · 14 tips and reviews

Alan J.Alan J: My favorite pizza is their thin crust round 9inch pizza pepperoni mushroom on half ham pineapple on the other

Athonia C.Athonia Cappelli: These guys have yet to offer a vegan cheese option as do almost every other 🍕 place in Santa Cruz. You can bring your own vegan 🧀 shreds like those from Trader Joe's & they'll substitute on your 🍕

SarahSarah: Yummy square pizza! They have a pizza lunch special. Their BBQ chicken and Asian inspired pizzas are bomb, too.

Engfer Pizza Works is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

6. Engfer Pizza Works

7.6
525 Seabright Ave, Santa Cruz, CA
Pizzeria · Eastside · 15 tips and reviews

Trisha L.Trisha Liu: Yum, thumbs up for gluten-free crust! The pizzas are fairly small. We ordered 2 for the 2 of us - next time we'll order 3.

jessica g.jessica goodman: Try the Megan's Vegan. Best vegan pizza I've ever had! Yummy house made tomato tofu spread, no fake cheese here!

Maya B.Maya Borgueta: Awesome vegan pizza. I like cashew topping.

Costco is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

7. Costco

7.6
220 Sylvania Ave (at Coral St), Santa Cruz, CA
Warehouse or Wholesale Store · Central Santa Cruz · 15 tips and reviews

SarahSarah: $1.99 for a huge slice of pizza, $10 for a large pizza. If you have a membership definitely take advantage of the pizza!

Donna N.Donna Novi: This Costco is never as busy as the ones in San Jose & they often have cool summer, beachy stuff!

Ken H.Ken Hardesty: researching the only Costco that has a special coffee brand

Companion Bakeshop is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

8. Companion Bakeshop

8.8
2341 Mission, Santa Cruz, CA
Bakery · Westside · 21 tips and reviews

Susan C.Susan Cannon: Brick oven pizzas Tuesdays between 4:30-6:30pm

Hatice U.Hatice U.: Gibraltar coffee and blueberry lemon pie are great together; I can die for them!!

Michael P.Michael Phillips: Blue Bottle coffee pour over bar!!!

Blaze Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

9. Blaze Pizza

7.6
1901 Mission St, Santa Cruz, CA
Pizzeria · Westside · 4 tips and reviews

Phillip P.Phillip P: The pizza crust is the best of the West

Athonia C.Athonia Cappelli: “popcorn” protein is gone. Order your vegetarian pie w/red sauce, Daiya cheese, kalamata olives, roasted red peppers, roasted garlic & jalapeños. This is the best places you’ll ever go for vegan 🍕🤗

Athonia C.Athonia Cappelli: As of July 17 blaze pizza has a cauliflower pizza crust. whaaaaaat? yum! it costs a bit more but worth it

Whole Foods Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

10. Whole Foods Market

8.1
911 Soquel Ave (at N Branciforte Ave), Santa Cruz, CA
Grocery Store · Eastside · 18 tips and reviews

John S.John Smith: Pizza here ia very good. Use soups to make sauce on other prepared foods that are too dry.

Sarah R.Sarah R: Some great deals on produce here, and the cashiers are friendly and helpful.

Kara M.Kara McCain: Get the chocolate tortilla chips by FoodShouldTasteGood (chip isle). This is one of the *few* WF that carries them. They sound weird but are ridiculously good.

Joe's Pizza & Subs is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

11. Joe's Pizza & Subs

7.2
841 N Branciforte Ave (at Water St), Santa Cruz, CA
Pizzeria · Eastside · 16 tips and reviews

Addison K.Addison Kester: Subs & Burgers are Tasty. Don't touch the Pizza (Shakes Head)

Stephen L.Stephen Lear: Best subs in Santa Cruz and the pizza is also excellent. But if you're dieting, stay away!!

ABAB: I'm under the impression that the burgers are frozen (and there are better burgers in town anyway), but you can't go wrong with their subs!

Abbott Square Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

12. Abbott Square Market

7.6
725 Front St, Santa Cruz, CA
Food Court · Downtown Santa Cruz · 1 tip

Nim G.Nim Gat: Pizza, espresso, wine, vegetarian

Coaster's Lounge is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

13. Coaster's Lounge

7.5
115 Cliff St (Inside Boardwalk Bowl), Santa Cruz, CA
Karaoke Bar · 7 tips and reviews

Jerry M.Jerry Miller: Turkey club is a decent sandwich here. Pizza and beer are a good choice as well

DuntronDuntron: Incredible spot for people watching.

Martha R.Martha Rotter: If Rippin is playing, get down here! They rock!

Boardwalk Bowl is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

14. Boardwalk Bowl

7.5
115 Cliff St (at Beach), Santa Cruz, CA
Bowling Alley · 9 tips and reviews

HelloKitty B.HelloKitty BayBay: Bowling, arcade, Karaoke & a bar...it's all good :)

Kelly T.Kelly Thomson: The mayor is bullshit he is never here

Mitchell M.Mitchell Money: $3.00 Beer of the Month! valid anytime open ...

La Posta is one of The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Santa Cruz.

15. La Posta

7.7
538 Seabright Ave (btw Hall & Watson), Santa Cruz, CA
Italian Restaurant · Eastside · 7 tips and reviews

Judy H.Judy H: Great wine list, loved the watermelon and buratta starter. The counter is the way to go for an engaging evening.

Matt R.Matt Rodkey: Sit at the bar for great service and wonderful conversation.

Gabby H.Gabby H: House-made bread, salads are generous, pasta has good texture. (Hostess seated three new tables in green waiter’s section — didn’t work out well for us. He was great but in the weeds.)