Proper Pie Co. is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

1. Proper Pie Co.

9.2
2505 E Broad St Ste 100 (N 25th St), Richmond, VA
Bakery · Church Hill · 49 tips and reviews

Rita S.Rita Street: Savory pies take pot pies to new levels!!! Love the Banofee

Alejandra M.Alejandra Morlett: Their pies are absolutely delicious! My favorite is their pork and Chile Verde pie (savory) and their coconut cream pie (sweet).

Krista L.Krista Lew: Chicken and kumara pie is killer. Coffee is Lamplighter. Amazing plave

Shyndigz is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

2. Shyndigz

9.0
1903 W Cary St, Richmond, VA
Dessert Shop · The Fan · 49 tips and reviews

Elle B.Elle Breezee: The crack pie, any fresh fruit cake, salted chocolate cake a la mode

Hardy G.Hardy Graves: Key Lime Pie is awesome! Service is great.

Akshay A.Akshay Anikhindi: Prepare to wait a long time. Key lime pie is good, so is bread pudding.

Ipanema Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

3. Ipanema Cafe

8.4
917 W Grace St (btwn N Harrison & Shafer St), Richmond, VA
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · VCU · 44 tips and reviews

Mike L.Mike Landefeld: Get the blueberry, strawberry, or mixed fruit pie. Simply amazing! Read more.

Johnny H.Johnny Hugel: Great dinner spot for vegan-friendly friends. Also, I hear that the pie here will blow your mind.

Leslie 🔆 H.Leslie 🔆 Haas: The "Pasta Roulade w/ Oyster Mushrooms, French Beans, Arugula Pesto + Tofu Ricotta" was AMAZING and don't leave without dessert! LOVED the Apple Strawberry Pie and the Chocolate Pie was great too.

Well-Made Pastry Alliance is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

4. Well-Made Pastry Alliance

8.9
2707 E Marshall St, Richmond, VA
Bakery · Church Hill · 28 tips and reviews

Tess D.Tess Dixon: All The Treats! Delicious things from the king of sweet baked goods in RVA. Seriously, it's the absolute best. Buttermilk pie is my current favorite.

Tess D.Tess Dixon: Everything is fantastic. You really can't go wrong. But if you want to know where to start, a sticky bun for breakfast and a slice of buttermilk pie for dessert are good candidates.

Dwight S.Dwight Smith: Buttermilk Pie. It is incredibly delicious and the texture is just perfect. Job well done!

Garnett's is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

5. Garnett's

9.1
2001 Park Ave (at N Meadow St), Richmond, VA
Sandwich Spot · The Fan · 53 tips and reviews

David Y.David Young: Excellent artisan sandwiches and salads! Stick around for the fruit pies. They are outstanding!

Mad Bike WomanMad Bike Woman: Gluten free sandwiches, soups, cakes, and pies. All unbeatable in taste.

Travis S.Travis Stansbury: Pie! Sandwiches! Beer! Wine! Happy hour snacks! Date night!

Penny Lane Pub is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

6. Penny Lane Pub

8.1
421 E Franklin St (at N 5th St), Richmond, VA
Pub · City Center · 75 tips and reviews

Jae E.Jae E: Charm, Wit and Simply Smashing Fare! I had a Snakebite, which I have never had before; cider and beer mixed, who knew? Tried the steak & Guinness pie, which was highly addictive. Do not miss this spot Read more.

Karen K.Karen Kersting: Chicken pot pie = yum.

Brian C.Brian Clay: Omg, the cottage pie is awesome!

Siné Irish Pub & Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

7. Siné Irish Pub & Restaurant

8.0
1327 E Cary St (at Virginia St), Richmond, VA
Pub · Shockoe Slip · 64 tips and reviews

EJ O.EJ O'Malley: Cheese steak is abominable. Shepherd's pie is incredible.

Kristen B.Kristen Becher: The Vegetarian Shepherd's Pie is great!

Phil L.Phil Lederer: Had shepherds pie with a smithwicks. The pie was very good. Nice irish pub.

Gelati Celesti is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

8. Gelati Celesti

9.2
1400 N Boulevard (Norfolk St), Richmond, VA
Ice Cream Parlor · Carytown - Museum District · 4 tips and reviews

Loree C.Loree Ching: Mud pie is awesome!!!!

Nicodemus B.Nicodemus Boffin: A great addition to the Scott's Addition neighborhood. Gelati Celesti offers great ice cream in a fine-looking space served by a prompt and friendly staff. Wonderful.

Lynn A.Lynn Abraham: Coconut cream and chocolate chocolate chip are awesome

Julep's New Southern Cuisine is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

9. Julep's New Southern Cuisine

8.5
420 E Grace St (at N 5th St), Richmond, VA
Southern Food Restaurant · Shockoe Bottom · 31 tips and reviews

MikeMike: I Highly Recommend The Vegetarian Pot Pie Consisting of Leeks, Shiitake Mushrooms, Sweet Corn, Carrots and Potatoes in a Parmesan-Béchamel with Puff Pastry. FOR DESSERT: Bananas Foster Read more.

Peter M.Peter Merholz: Brunswick stew was delicious. Also the pumpkin crack pie. Well crafted cocktails. Friendly service.

Kelley B.Kelley Bode: Get the Victorian cocktail. It's perfectly sweet. Also, the bananas foster was to die for, especially since they make it table side.

The Roosevelt is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

10. The Roosevelt

8.9
623 N 25th St (M St), Richmond, VA
Southern Food Restaurant · 56 tips and reviews

DanaDana: Peanut butter pie. Mmm.

Greg R.Greg R: It was Richmond restaurant week, so it was a set menu but the scallops with sausage and pesto were excellent. However, the peanut butter pie was to die for!

Ben T.Ben Thare: Great meal! Doubt you will go wrong with any of the choices.

Dot's Back Inn is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

11. Dot's Back Inn

8.5
4030 MacArthur Ave, Richmond, VA
Diner · Bellevue · 57 tips and reviews

Edward D.Edward Dancy: Elvis Pie! Do not miss it.

Karen H.Karen Holder: Mediterranean Pie!

Eric S.Eric Spivack: The corned beef hash is good and unique: the corned beef is set is a fried potato patty

Belmont Food Shop is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

12. Belmont Food Shop

8.8
27 N Belmont Ave, Richmond, VA
New American Restaurant · The Museum District · 10 tips and reviews

Chad W.Chad Williams: Porcini Custard, Chestnut Soup, Venison Cassoulet, Braised Rabbit, Silk Pie and Butterscotch Custard were all very good. I would order all of them again.

Traci F.Traci F: Get the orange blossom cocktail. Can't go wrong with any entree and the 3 course for $30 can't be best. The chef obviously puts a little bit of love into each dish. A true gem.

Elle B.Elle Breezee: I would love to keep this secret to myself but: get the roast lamb or monkfish with clams. The individual peach cobbler with cardamom scented whipped cream = divine!

Charm School is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

13. Charm School

9.0
311 W Broad St, Richmond, VA
Ice Cream Parlor · Downtown Richmond · 14 tips and reviews

Mike K.Mike Kelleher: The seasonal & rotating flavors (even vegan and gluten-free) mean that there is something for everyone. Pumpkin pie, Cap n’ Crunch And Cinnamon Toast Crunch (Cereal Milk flavors) are my faves.

Travis M.Travis Miller: The toasted fluff is too good. So many unique flavors too!

John W M.John W Mason-Smith: Everything's good. Ask for extra waffle cone bits on your ice cream!

The Hill Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

14. The Hill Cafe

8.7
2800 E Broad St (at N 28th St), Richmond, VA
American Restaurant · Church Hill · 38 tips and reviews

Kristen E.Kristen Edwards: Thai chicken lettuce wraps and key lime pie are awesome! Seared tuna app is okay.

Rosie J.Rosie J.: Blackened Rib Eye is the best! The shrimp and grits were excellent also.

David A.David Adkins: Tip the bartender

Bon Air Seafood is one of The 15 Best Places for Pies in Richmond.

15. Bon Air Seafood

7.8
2722 Tinsley Dr, North Chesterfield, VA
Seafood Restaurant · Midlothian · 4 tips and reviews

Janet B.Janet B.: Around the holidays, the line is way out the door for their shrimp ball and fresh seafood. These are good and fair people. Check out the pies and bread, as well.

John S.John S: Fresh swordfish

Mary W.Mary Williams: Get a half a bushel of fresh crabs to take home - they are awesome!