Square Pie is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

1. Square Pie

8.8
801 E Passyunk Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Pizzeria · Bella Vista - Southwark · 4 tips and reviews

Allison Y.Allison Yu: The Sicilian pie crust is thick and chewy. It will change your life

HalalfoodcriticHalalfoodcritic: Soft And thick Sicilian pizza

Mr D.Mr D: Pizza ( prefer the smalls as they are more crunchy)

Cosmi's Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

2. Cosmi's Deli

9.0
1501 S 8th St (at Dickinson St), Philadelphia, PA
Sandwich Spot · Bella Vista - Southwark · 33 tips and reviews

Serious EatsSerious Eats: The Sicilian: filled with prosciutto, sopressata, hot coppa, mortadella, roasted red peppers and super piquant sharp provolone on Sarcone's bread. Read more.

Jahy T.Jahy Tse: Just had the Sicilian on a seeded roll, well built, flavorful and perfect. This is a true hoagie folks

Campbell B.Campbell Bird: Sicilian with long hots on seeded bread is pretty great. Awesome old school hoagies here.

Rustica Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

3. Rustica Pizza

8.6
903 N 2nd St (at Poplar St), Philadelphia, PA
Pizzeria · Northern Liberties - Fishtown · 32 tips and reviews

Rich H.Rich Hoff: Specialty pies such as the Federico, Truffle steak, and arugula and artichoke are amazing.

Aimee V.Aimee Viggiani: Pay with Levelup and save $$$$!!!

Tim Q.Tim Quirino: Best Pizza by the slice in the city, hands down. Don't argue, just see for yourself.

L'anima is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

4. L'anima

8.0
1001 S 17th St (Carpenter), Philadelphia, PA
Italian Restaurant · Graduate Hospital · 2 tips and reviews

Rich S.Rich Simon: Wonderful food. Friendly staff. Highly recommend!

Patricio R.Patricio Rocha: Pasta and pinsas are great

Barra Rossa Ristorante is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

5. Barra Rossa Ristorante

7.8
929 Walnut St, Philadelphia, PA
Italian Restaurant · Center City East · 25 tips and reviews

Daniel & Kristal D.Daniel & Kristal Dizon: Sicilian Margarita is a must try!

Stephen S.Stephen Stafford: Try the Italian ice martini, and one of the Neapolitan style wood fire pizzas the special red is a meat lovers dream.

Michael C.Michael Chromiak: Nice spot. Nice drink selection, very personable workers and it's a great place for an intimate dinner-date.

Renzi's Pizzeria is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

6. Renzi's Pizzeria

8.0
2728 Orthodox St, Philadelphia, PA
Pizzeria · Bridesburg · 4 tips and reviews

Kenneth F.Kenneth Fetsurka: Best pizza in the area, pretty good compared to most pizza in the city

The International G.The International Gazette: Pretty good pizza.

Patrick P.Patrick Phelps: Have only been a few times but the pizza and burgers are delicious. The staff are friendly and quick.

Termini Bros is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

7. Termini Bros

8.9
1523 S 8th St, Philadelphia, PA
Bakery · Bella Vista - Southwark · 26 tips and reviews

Lisa S.Lisa S.: Best cannolis in the city. All the desserts are amazing and I'm officially addicted to their cupcakes!

Aaron T.Aaron Tarpine: Cannoli's!

Teresa E.Teresa Emerson: You've never had a cannoli until you been here...

Toto's Pizzeria is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

8. Toto's Pizzeria

8.2
6555 Greene St (at Hortter St), Philadelphia, PA
Pizzeria · West Mount Airy · 7 tips and reviews

K. H.K. Harmon: I have had anything here besides the pizza but I love love love it! So good, & fresh from the oven. I especially love the crust.

Hirohiro U.Hirohiro Usagi: Fast and friendly service

Morris T.Morris Thomas: I love the stuffed pizza!!!

Villa Di Roma is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

9. Villa Di Roma

7.4
936 S 9th St, Philadelphia, PA
Italian Restaurant · Bella Vista - Southwark · 53 tips and reviews

Deb M.Deb M: Shrimp Scampi is the best anywhere. Veal Sicilian, Villa salad, fried asparagus, it's all good!

Ricky S.Ricky Sherrill: I pop in for a meal every time I am in town. They have the best meatballs in town but you cannot go wrong with anything on the menu.

Visit PhillyVisit Philly: Repeat winner of the Golden Meatball Challenge between South Philadelphia and South Jersey, Italian Market staple Villa Di Roma has a winning 50-year-old formula for its pan-seared all-beef beauties.

Maggie's Waterfront Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

10. Maggie's Waterfront Cafe

8.3
9242 North Delaware Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Seafood Restaurant · Torresdale · 26 tips and reviews

KathrynKathryn: Grilled shrimp & bronzed shrimp & free wifi & new renovations 👌🏼

Priscilla S.Priscilla Somerville-Gray: Great food and great service. Tandy was our waitress and she was terrific! Get the bronze shrimp!!!!!

Patrice M.Patrice Morris: Cream of crab soup...excellent!

Dante & Luigi's is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

11. Dante & Luigi's

8.4
762 S 10th St (at Catherine St.), Philadelphia, PA
Italian Restaurant · Bella Vista - Southwark · 27 tips and reviews

Cheryn R.Cheryn Robles: Gnocchi with vodka sauce was amazing! Wait staff was very friendly and knowledgeable and wisely suggested I take the chocolate ricotta cannoli to go.

Visit PhillyVisit Philly: Established in 1899, you're standing in Philadelphia's oldest Italian restaurant and one of the oldest in the United States.

Kandis K.Kandis Kovalsky: One of the BEST Italian restaurants! This place has been around since the 1800s! Authentic homemade mom/pop style sauces/food. Try either the gnocchi Romano or baked gnocchi! The tiramisu is the BEST!

Saloon Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

12. Saloon Restaurant

8.3
750 S 7th St (btwn Fitzwater and Catharine), Philadelphia, PA
Italian Restaurant · Bella Vista - Southwark · 22 tips and reviews

Kyle B.Kyle Boland: The reggiano parmesan cheese & pesto dip are amazing!

Lee E.Lee Ensminger: Order the pablano peppers stuffed with ground veal.

Allison C.Allison Capocci: this restaurant is perfect for any occasion!

Gran Caffe L'Aquila is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

13. Gran Caffe L'Aquila

8.6
1716 Chestnut St, Philadelphia, PA
Italian Restaurant · Center City West · 47 tips and reviews

Dulce Carolina A.Dulce Carolina Aguila Gómez: Excelent gelato and coffee ! Delicious food

Gigio L.Gigio Longo: Pistachio Gelato

Elba R.Elba R.M.: The best gnocchi I've ever tried and the gelato is amazing! Plenty of wine to choose from.

The Buffalo House is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

14. The Buffalo House

7.7
8439 Frankford Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Pizzeria · Holmesburg · 3 tips and reviews

Sarah M.Sarah Montana: I always get a caprese salad and tomato pie. Delicious!

Gina A.Gina Amorose-Hriczo: Great food good prices

Steve O.Steve Olenski: Ask for Justin and tell him Steve O sent you! Great food!!!

Pagano's Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Sicilian in Philadelphia.

15. Pagano's Market

7.9
701 Market St (at 7th St.), Philadelphia, PA
Breakfast Spot · Center City East · 3 tips and reviews

Amy S.Amy Shellhammer: Fantastic pizza! Get there early for the tomato pie -- it sells out fast.

John N.John Neal: If you get here early enough for breakfast get their home fries. They are amazing.

Akima M.Akima Morgan: Hands down the best mac & cheese in the city... Maybe anywhere! Too bad it's only on Soul Food Fridays.