Hillstone is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

1. Hillstone

9.0
378 Park Ave S (at E 27th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · NoMad · 265 tips and reviews

Akiko B.Akiko Bombita: Service is spectacular! So everything on the menu is so good. The pan seared ahi tuna salad is perfect if you want something lighter but savory. Yum!!

Su P.Su Park: California burger was so good! Shoestring fries were on point and addictive - ahi tuna salad was very fresh and good for something on the lighter side. Mangoes were sweet!

D S.D Sic: Flying ahi tuna salad is a great healthy option

Jack's Wife Freda is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

2. Jack's Wife Freda

8.7
226 Lafayette St (btwn Kenmare & Spring St), New York, NY
Mediterranean Restaurant · SoHo · 522 tips and reviews

Sandro M.Sandro Meyer: Very Slow Kitchen but good Service and good Food! Try the Tuna Salad.

Gal A.Gal Amir: Great food, small portions though. The tuna salad is great! Green shakshuka is nice.. Definitely recommend.

ᴡ F.ᴡ Feinberg: I got the tuna salad. It's some great seasoned tuna on top of leafy lettuce/spinach leaves. Amazing! But expect to bump elbows with those around you.

Bite is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

3. Bite

8.4
62 W 22nd St (at 6th Ave), New York, NY
Mediterranean Restaurant · Flatiron District · 56 tips and reviews

Rich B.Rich Boyce: It's ALL about the Exotic Tuna Salad Sandwich!!! If I had to choose a sandwich to eat every day for the remainder of my life, this would be the one...hands down!

Joe K.Joe Kiley: Mediterranean salad and exotic tuna salads are both must try's

Harry R.Harry Raymond: Exotic tuna salad or Mediterranean tuna panini.

The Grey Dog - Nolita is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

4. The Grey Dog - Nolita

8.2
244 Mulberry St (btwn Spring & Prince St), New York, NY
Café · NoLita · 300 tips and reviews

Ariela grinbergAriela grinberg: The classic tuna salad sandwich is great! Also if you are not into cofee order the cranberry lemonade !! Yummi

Jake P.Jake Pearce: This place is great value, ultra hip yet mellow. Tuna salad is good.

Susan L.Susan Loh: Seared tuna salad. Awesome.

The Smith is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

5. The Smith

8.5
55 3rd Ave (btwn E 10th & E 11th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · East Village · 517 tips and reviews

Thiago C.Thiago Carrapatoso: The vegetable bibimbap is good, but not that good. The tuna salad of the side table, nonetheless, look very good!

refinery29refinery29: The Smith has a little bit of everything. You can get Swedish meatballs and lamb Milanese one night, then come back for ahi tuna salad and vegetable bibimbap the next. Read more.

Nate B.Nate Beatty: Fish on the tuna salad was cooked perfectly rare. Cool old NY atmosphere. I'll be back soon!

Breads Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

6. Breads Bakery

9.2
1890 Broadway, New York, NY
Bakery · Lincoln Square · 46 tips and reviews

Natalie L.Natalie LeMoss: Great tuna salad and the vegan cauliflower sandwich is amazing.

Nenzo C.Nenzo Cruz: Holy crap the chocolate Babkas are amazing !

XinnieXinnie: We tried quite a handful of parties and all of them were fantastic. Really love the egg salad croissant sandwich and chocolate babka.

The Smith is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

7. The Smith

8.8
956 2nd Ave (at E 51st St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 362 tips and reviews

Morgan P.Morgan Polotan: Get the tuna tartare and seared tuna salad.

Cory B.Cory Bangert: Mussels are amazing and I highly recommend the seared tuna salad

Bonnie S.Bonnie Smyth: Very consistent. You can’t really go wrong because everything is delicious - but ESPECIALLY the Brussels sprouts and seared tuna salad.

Zucker's Bagels & Smoked Fish is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

8. Zucker's Bagels & Smoked Fish

8.4
146 Chambers St (btwn W. Broadway & Greenwich St), New York, NY
Bagel Shop · Tribeca · 126 tips and reviews

Brad K.Brad Klein: [Whole wheat everything]+[tuna salad]+[cucumber]=tits. Well worth the price

Ms H.Ms Helene: Daily lunch special -filling of the day (Thu is tuna or chicken salad) with tomato and lettuce on a bagel, wrap or bread, with soda, coleslaw and pickle $6.95. Tuna salad and bagel were great!

Ted S.Ted Smith: David Burke special: bagel w cream cheese, tomatoes, capers and pastrami lox

The Grey Dog - Union Square is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

9. The Grey Dog - Union Square

8.5
90 University Pl (btwn E 11th & E 12th St), New York, NY
Café · Greenwich Village · 327 tips and reviews

DarrenDarren: Baked oatmeal for breakfast. Seared tuna salad for lunch. Done!

Kate L.Kate Lord: Most amazing seared ahi tuna salad I've ever had! You can't go wrong here though.

Loriah P.Loriah Pope: Ahí tuna salad is fantastic! Great service also.

Gotan is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

10. Gotan

8.9
130 Franklin St (at Varick St), New York, NY
Café · Tribeca · 145 tips and reviews

Jeanne C.Jeanne Cho: Avo tuna salad super decadent and lovely. Needs something bland to balance bc its super saturated w flavor

C F.C F: Tuna salad

AnikaAnika: Gotan has lots of good food and pretty good coffee. Lots of friendly staff members and a nice vibe!

Mémé Mediterranean is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

11. Mémé Mediterranean

8.7
607 10th Ave (at 44th St), New York, NY
Mediterranean Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 32 tips and reviews

Eric H.Eric Ho: Great Tuna Salad

Yousef S.Yousef Sama: Complimentary olives are great done the way in Syria and turkey are done, the appetizer ( Ravioli) is tasty and healthy

Kathleen S.Kathleen Shim: Scallops, laffa tacos and the falafel are absolutely amazing!!

Gramercy Bagels is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

12. Gramercy Bagels

7.4
246 3rd Ave (btwn E 20th & E 21st St), New York, NY
Bagel Shop · Gramercy Park · 30 tips and reviews

Matthew W.Matthew Weinberg: Everything bagel with tuna salad is the key order here.

Laurie D.Laurie D.: If I'm not ordering a breakfast sandwich, I'll have one of their bagels with their tuna salad. Not bad if you ask me.

David L.David LaBar: Great bagels, nice seating area and coffee by La Colombe

Breads Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

13. Breads Bakery

9.3
18 E 16th St (btwn Union Sq W & 5th Ave), New York, NY
Bakery · 335 tips and reviews

Katie H.Katie Holt: Try the tuna salad sandwich and the focaccia bread! Perfect size sandwich.

Natalie L.Natalie LeMoss: Loved the tuna salad and the coffee was delicious. Perfect spot to meet up with friends for brunch or lunch

Salman A.Salman Alissa: Wow really delicious bakery! Recommend Chocolate Bakba

Jack's Wife Freda is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

14. Jack's Wife Freda

8.3
50 Carmine St (at Bedford St), New York, NY
Mediterranean Restaurant · West Village · 177 tips and reviews

Arielle S.Arielle Silverman: Great spot for lunch or dinner. Everything is great, but my favorites are the tuna salad and Greek salad with chicken.

Dane F.Dane Feldman: My favorite spot in the whole city. The menu is perfect. Go for Jack's breakfast, tuna salad, or zucchini chips. Vesper and cantaloupe mimosa are both great too. Wonderful atmosphere. Worth the wait.

Samiha K.Samiha Khan: Great for dates. Cute and cozy design. Reminds me a little of the bar Ramona in Greenpoint, but with food! Zucchini chips and peri peri chicken is the way to go!

Del Frisco's Grille is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in New York City.

15. Del Frisco's Grille

7.7
50 Rockefeller Plz (Rockefeller Center), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Rockefeller Center · 101 tips and reviews

Lucas L.Lucas L: Get the Seared Tuna Salad! 

BanueBanue: Sliced steak & Parmesan frites, Ahi tuna salad are excellent

LaurenLauren: There are TWO - one is a restaurant, one is a grille. The grille is GREAT for happy hour - I highly recommend the flatbreads, especially the prosciutto and arugula one.