Get Antonio Starita's specialty pizza!
Montarara Starita - the lightly fried special pizza is a must
Their speciality pizza is amazeballs! Fried dough is the best.
They now offer wine as well. Great specialty pizzas, and very hard to choose.
Best pizza in NYC! If you're in a daring mood try one of the specialty pizzas. Some of the topping combinations seem weird however they know what they are talking about.
Best pizza I've had on UES; and comes out quick from the brick oven. The Capricciosa is my go-to on the menu. For caffeine, the Macchiato can't be beat.
Pricey but amazing specialty pizza. Buffalo chicken and bbq chicken slices are my favorite.
The best pizza in NY! You must try the Famous Buffalo Chicken Grandma Slice...!!!
Mad good. Buffalo slice is ABSURD
They'll make you the proscuitto arugula special pizza even when its not a special. And its the best pizza they make. Do it!
Outstanding pizza that oozes simplicity & genius. Burrata starter: ditto. Best tiramisu we ever had; probably the most authentically home-made dessert you can ever eat outside home; must try.
Great atmosphere! And the specialty pizzas are EXCELLENT! I especially love the TV in the back!
They use egg products for their pizza crusts (in case you were wondering). The pizzas are delicious, especially the sausage, sweet pepper and onion (#2 combo)
This brick oven contends with whatever you think is good.
The Ilaria special pizza on Thursdays is incredible - cherry tomatoes, smoked buffalo mozzarella DOP, and arugula combine to make your mouth water.
All the antipasti are very very good! Service is okay.
A fine Neapolitan pizza spot but not markedly better than say Keste or Roberta’s. Super simple topping options. The ice cream is fantastic tho.
Get the daily special pizza, every time. Also the vodka pizza, and the supreme pizza. Great value for Nolita, too.
Meatballs are to DIE for & specialty pizza was INSANE: capicola, cherry peppers, garlic, and ricotta!!
All time favorite. Amazing food. The pizza here is something different. Vodka pizza #1. Mozz sticks. Pasta A+
Stopped by with a big group of friends and split a few pizzas, get the specialty pizzas they are worth the wait
🍕🍕it is the new PIOLA in town -- Authentic Italian pizza in Pala.
The blood-orange margarita is not to be missed. Read more.
Try the Prosciutti Special Pizza
Best sit-down pizza in the East Village (and probably Manhattan). An ambitious eater can down a whole pie, so get a couple different ones for your table.
Loved The Suprema Special Pizza. Really great Sauce And big slices.
Pizza this good can change your day, month or life for the better. The plain slice is blissful.
The best pizza near Penn Station. Order an 'upside down' slice.
Brunch menu is all-around excellent; bring a group and split several special pizzas and maybe the spinach-and-goat-cheese omelet. Good coffee too.
Perhaps some of the best pizza on the Upper East Side - if not NY. Wonderful to order a large with three different styles and share....
Some of the best pizza I've had in NYC
Special pizza it's great. We try 3 different types of pizza and all of them was great.
Everything was delicious and not just saying because it was a 2am bite. Margerhita pizza, gnocchi and bruschetta all winners. Cash only. Picnic tables outside dining.
their customer service is...lacking
The Best veal parmegiana in NYC. Tip: ask about angel hair pasta with marinara souce.. Its perfect.
You can buy pizza here.
High on flavor. Lots of garlic and spices in that sauce, loads of cheese. Best bet is an original cheese slice. Charming, because often the Italian owners are the ones serving you.
Great food, big slices of homemade pizzas, great calzone and huge pasta ! Definitely recommend this place !
Both Chicago and New York-style options
Not really Chicago style. It's the worst stereotype of what New Yorkers think Chicago Pizza is - NY Pizza with a bunch of extra bread.
cheese burst was awesome.with garlic bread and chissy dip too yum,guys plss try cheese burst it will gonna melt in your mouth...
Don't come during the estimated ready time or you'll wait way too long. Double the time and you might get out ok.
Good in a pinch
Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA